[batch] pm-dispatch SKILL consolidated amendments + compression — eight ruled cards, two serialized PRs (skills seat, round 1)

Sweep/batch card filed by the skills seat (#7623, session session_01ATJiqhFNL82YwV8udPkoqX). All eight members carry maintainer rulings recorded 2026-08-11 on their own threads. Batch shape confirmed by the maintainer in the seat's 专题讨论 (2026-08-11): scope confirmed 「确认,七张全收」, then 「包括 7498」 (PR #7552 closed, its content folded here), then the compression directive quoted under PR₂ below. One claim; two serialized PRs, both human-merged (sweep discipline, #6243 precedent).

Members (each row = one checklist section in PR₁'s body; ruling text lives on the member's thread)

member	what lands
#7498	Four-lens analysis block required on every `needs-user-decision` card (step 0 + step 8); Blocked-by-aware batch selection tier; round-brief decision flags. Reference implementation: closed PR #7552's diff (branch `claude/issue-7498-decision-four-lens`, head `24934cf8b`) — reuse against current anchors, do not re-derive; keep `check:skill-frame-sync` green exactly as that PR's body explains (the frame stays 3-axis; the block is its card-face serialization)
#7548	Step-7 ACCEPT path fork extends to `.claude/skills/` + `skills/` (same three-part terminal state as `docs/adr/**`); Guardrails entry quoting 「所有 skills 的更新和 adr 类似,需要人工审核」 verbatim; skills-seat structural registration (domain table row, roster/vocabulary row for `domain:skills`, one-time-setup label line)
#7493	发版板 → three queries (objectstack + objectui + cloud); `repo:cloud` seat gains `target:*` production (one-producer-per-backlog); repeal the "a hit in cloud is a mislabel signal" clause; step-9 metric = sum of three. Ruling marks it most urgent
#7492	Operational note 1: queue-membership criterion → `added_to_merge_queue` timeline event (branch test kept for batch position only; `auto_merge`-field warning verbatim); success-sequence rule (`removed_from_merge_queue`→`merged` within ~1s = landing, not ejection); fold note 21's empty-receipt prescription into the same reading discipline (tally 3/3; `disable` does not dequeue)
#7518	Five measured lessons (queue-kick signature receipt + single re-queue then steward handoff; empty-receipt second timing shape — read the queue before flipping; opportunistic restart conditions hang on dispatch-time checks in the owning seat post; claim-race loser posts a handoff comment with its readings; lane inventory via field-narrowed `list_issues` whole-lane read, intersect locally)
#7553	Direction 1: one line making the canonical `Claim:` spelling explicit (predicate stays strict); ⛔ no predicate widening
#7583	Seat-post protocol: bounded body template (Scope / Current PM / Inherited state / Hot-file serial queue / Standing commitments / Notes — all current-state); shift narration lives on cards/PRs/round reports; takeover compaction standard step (edit history = archive); script half: report-only oversized-body H-item in `scripts/pm/check-half-states.mjs`
#7512	Option (a): explicit clause in `.claude/agents/os-dev.md` (+ dispatch-brief echo where it verifiably repeats) ranking the dispatch contract above platform-injected PR-subscription postures

PR₂ — structural compression (maintainer directive, 2026-08-11, verbatim, untranslated)

现在的项目经理skills 太长了,需要考虑怎么压缩

Measured composition @ origin/main (3027 lines): The round loop 1870 (step 5 Dispatch 587, incl. Prompt template 326; step 7 Review 380; step 0 sweep 200; step 6 Collect 195; 入队与落地 167; step 8 130), Operational notes 612, Domain lanes 209, State model 111, the rest 189. Existing extraction targets: references/incidents.md (140 lines, append-only), references/compile-surfaces.md (27).

Prescription (seat's plan of record; the maintainer vetoes at PR review):

Target: main file ~1400–1600 lines (deep compression, roughly −50%).
Method: every rule keeps its imperative + criteria/command + one-line case anchor (issue number); narratives, 沿革, worked examples, incident retellings move verbatim to references/incidents.md (append-only, 出处 line each) or a new references/operational-notes.md. Machine-consumed tables (domain lanes, 词表, roster, label setup) stay in the main file.
⛔ No rule deletion — compression moves prose, never removes a binding rule, criterion, or prohibition; deleting a rule requires its own maintainer ruling.
Ratchet: lower check:pm-skill-ratchet's ceiling from 3050 to the achieved count (shrink-only lock-in).
check:skill-frame-sync stays green; the four frame copies are untouched by moves.

Delivery order (load-bearing, #7341 precedent: pure moves come AFTER all textual additions)

PR₁ — amendments: the eight member sections above. Fixes #7498, #7548, #7493, #7492, #7518, #7553, #7583, #7512 + Part of #7631. Ratchet: 3027/3050 today — pay any overage by minimal extraction.
PR₂ — compression: opened only after PR₁ is merged (same file, strict serialization). Pure structural moves + ratchet lowering. Part of #7631; this card closes after PR₂ lands.
Both PRs are ADR-class: draft/review by AI seats, then visibly pending; ⛔ nobody merges, enqueues, or arms auto-merge — the maintainer merges manually.

Constraints

File surface: .claude/skills/pm-dispatch/SKILL.md, .claude/skills/pm-dispatch/references/**, .claude/agents/os-dev.md, scripts/pm/check-half-states.mjs, scripts/ ratchet config (+ published skills/objectstack-pm-dispatch/** only if the dispatch-brief echo verifiably repeats there). ⛔ No docs/adr/**. Zero changes beyond the checklist (git diff --stat matches 1:1 per PR).
PR pm-dispatch SKILL: require a four-lens block on every needs-user-decision card, Blocked-by-aware batch selection, round-brief decision flags #7552 is closed (maintainer instruction, provenance on its thread) — no in-flight SKILL.md PR remains; this batch is dispatchable now.
skip-changeset label (.claude/ + scripts/ only; 空 frontmatter changeset 相对 skip-changeset 标签零收益、单向风险 —— 「禁止空 changeset 进 .changeset/」的决策证据(#5292 结案后无处存放) #5471 rejects empty changesets). English on GitHub. Sanitizer discipline on every write (HTML entities for literal angle brackets; read back and verify).
Dispatch tier: model: claude-fable-5 mandatory (SKILL surface, maintainer 2026-08-10), mode:cloud.

Member candidacy

Per sweep rule 5: members keep pm:queue but are not individual dispatch candidates while this card is open; they close together via PR₁'s Fixes lines.

Claim: PM loop round 1 (skills seat)
Session: session_01ATJiqhFNL82YwV8udPkoqX
Branch: claude/issue-7631-skill-batch
Worktree: objectstack-issue-7631 (cloud session's own clone)
Domain: domain:skills
File surface: .claude/skills/pm-dispatch/SKILL.md, .claude/skills/pm-dispatch/references/**, .claude/agents/os-dev.md, scripts/pm/check-half-states.mjs, ratchet config under scripts/ (+ published skills/objectstack-pm-dispatch/** only if the dispatch-brief echo verifiably repeats there) — stop on breach; explain in the report
Container & model: L (batch: 8 members + compression), mode:cloud, model: claude-fable-5 (mandatory — SKILL surface, maintainer 2026-08-10)
Serial constraints cleared: PR #7552 closed 2026-08-11 ~10:0xZ on the maintainer's instruction (was the only in-flight SKILL.md PR); no other open PR or claim touches this surface — checked label:domain:skills is:open and the seat post's hot-file serial queue at claim time. PR₂ (compression) serializes strictly behind PR₁'s human merge.

Generated by Claude Code

{
  "issue": 7631,
  "status": "done",
  "branch": "claude/issue-7631-skill-batch",
  "pr": "https://github.com/objectstack-ai/objectstack/pull/7698",
  "premise_still_valid": true,
  "summary": "PR₁ (draft #7698) lands all eight member sections in the card's file surface, zero riders: SKILL.md, references/incidents.md, .claude/agents/os-dev.md, scripts/pm/check-half-states.mjs. #7498 was reused verbatim from closed PR #7552 (head 24934cf) via cherry-pick onto current main — zero conflicts, its own commit, PM review carries over. #7548: step-7 ACCEPT fork now fires on .claude/skills/** + skills/**, Guardrails entry quotes the ruling verbatim, domain:skills registered (lane-table row carved from devx, 词表 row → #7623, label loop + skills). #7493: three board queries, repo:cloud seat produces target:*, mislabel clause repealed with cloud#1222 cost recorded, step-9 metric = sum of three. #7492: note-1 membership criterion is the added_to_merge_queue timeline event (branch reading demoted to batch position, positive hit still sufficient; auto_merge warning verbatim), success-sequence rule added in note 1 (~1s gap = landing), note 21 folded into the same reading discipline (3/3 counter-tally; disable does not dequeue but clears the flag). #7518: all five lessons (note-2 third signature + receipted single re-queue; lesson 2 inside note 21; opportunistic restart conditions → trigger files + lane dispatch-time check in label discipline; loser's board-readings handoff in step 4 with #7145; whole-lane list_issues inventory read in step 1). #7553: one explicit canonical-spelling line in step 4, predicate untouched. #7583: six-section bounded seat-body template + narration relocation + takeover compaction in 座位贴协议, and H6 (report-only, >10 KB bytes) in check-half-states.mjs. #7512 option (a): ranking clause in os-dev.md's report-at-draft item + one-line echo in the internal SKILL.md prompt template; the published skills/objectstack-pm-dispatch/SKILL.md was verified to NOT repeat the dispatch brief and is untouched. Ratchet: 3027 → 3043 (cherry-pick) → additions paid by verbatim narrative extraction into references/incidents.md (15 new append-only sections, one 出处 line each; no binding rule/criterion/prohibition deleted) → exactly 3050/3050. Mechanism assumptions verified: frame-sync gate green with the four-lens block (4 copies isomorphic, frame untouched); ratchet config located at scripts/pm/check-skill-line-ratchet.mjs (ceiling 3050 confirmed); PM's section measurements @ origin/main re-measured and confirmed (3027 total). Per the batch card, PR₂ (compression) is NOT opened this turn — it serializes behind PR₁'s human merge. Both this PR and PR₂ are ADR-class: awaiting a human merge; not queued, no auto-merge. The platform auto-subscribed this session to #7698 with a drive-to-green posture — per #7512's own ruling (executed in this PR) the dispatch contract outranks it; ending at branch + draft PR + report.",
  "tests": "pnpm check:pm-skill-ratchet → '✓ SKILL.md is 3050 lines (ceiling 3050; headroom 0)', self-test 5 pass. pnpm check:skill-frame-sync → '✓ 4 copies of the decision frame are structurally isomorphic across 3 files; 3 axes; binding sentence present in all 4; 4 count mention(s) agree', self-test 12 pass. pnpm check:doc-authoring → '✓ 375 files clean'. pnpm check:nul-bytes → 'OK (scanned 7089 text file(s))'. pnpm check:agent-model-declared → green (os-dev.md → opus; frontmatter unchanged). node scripts/pm/check-half-states.mjs --self-test → '✓ 24 cases pass' (4 new H6 cases prove the new H-item parses; the script has no --help flag, the self-test is the prescribed proof). pnpm --filter @objectstack/lint run check:doc-formula-expressions → '✓ 22 record-scoped formula example(s) across 390 files / 1408 TS blocks judged clean' after building the lint dependency closure. Markdown + one report-only script under .claude/ + scripts/ — no package suites apply. CI at report time: in_progress (report delivered at draft-PR time per L2).",
  "open_questions": [
    {
      "question": "Placement of #7492's success-sequence rule: the member card sketched 'its own note' but Operational notes are append-only-numbered at the tail, and the ruling fixed content, not placement.",
      "options": ["A. Inside amended note 1, as one queue-reading discipline (implemented)", "B. New tail note 22"],
      "recommendation": "A, because the batch card itself frames #7492 as one reading discipline (criterion + sequence + note-21 fold) and a tail note would separate two halves of the same timeline read; content is identical either way — settled per the self-drive clause, recorded here."
    },
    {
      "question": "H6 threshold and unit: the ruling says 'e.g. body > ~10 KB' — implemented as 10,000 bytes (UTF-8), byte length not code points, exported as SEAT_BODY_SOFT_LIMIT.",
      "options": ["A. 10,000 bytes as implemented", "B. A different constant or code-point measure"],
      "recommendation": "A — the read-limit failure the item guards against is byte-sized, and the compacted #6019 body (~4.5 KB) sits far below while the pathological one (~61 KB) sits far above; report-only, so re-tuning later is a one-line change."
    },
    {
      "question": "PR₂ plan sketch (NOT opened this turn, per the card): target ~1400–1600 lines by moving step-5 narrative mass (Prompt template rationale blocks), Operational-notes narratives, and step-7/入队与落地 retellings verbatim into references/incidents.md and a new references/operational-notes.md; then lower the ratchet ceiling to the achieved count (shrink-only). PR₁ already established the extraction pattern (15 sections moved) and left the file at exactly 3050, so PR₂ starts from a clean measured base.",
      "options": ["A. Proceed as sketched when the PM signals PR₁ has been human-merged", "B. PM adjusts targets first"],
      "recommendation": "A — awaiting the PM's message after the maintainer merges PR₁; no PR₂ work was prepared beyond this sketch."
    }
  ],
  "out_of_scope_findings": []
}

Generated by Claude Code

ACCEPT — PR₁ #7698 (skills seat review of record)

Review verified against GitHub, full diff read (1,356 lines, 100%):

Shape: draft, targets main, first line Fixes × 8 + Part of #7631; changed files = exactly the four declared (SKILL.md, references/incidents.md, os-dev.md, check-half-states.mjs), zero riders; all 286 deletions in SKILL.md, incidents.md purely append-only.
Per member: all eight rulings implemented as recorded — pm-dispatch SKILL: require a four-lens analysis block on every needs-user-decision card #7498 reused from closed PR pm-dispatch SKILL: require a four-lens block on every needs-user-decision card, Blocked-by-aware batch selection, round-brief decision flags #7552 via cherry-pick (own commit, frame untouched, check:skill-frame-sync green); pm-dispatch SKILL: skills updates are ADR-class — human review/merge required (maintainer ruling 2026-08-11) #7548 ACCEPT fork + Guardrails verbatim quote + domain:skills registration (lane table / 词表 / label loop); pm-dispatch SKILL: the file-at-destination ruling (#7165) puts target:v17 cards into cloud, which the 发版板 section says can never happen — a live v17 card was invisible to both prescribed queries for ~10h #7493 three queries + cloud producer + mislabel clause repealed; pm-dispatch SKILL: Operational note 1's gh-readonly-queue/* test gave a false negative at queue capacity — propose the added_to_merge_queue timeline event as the criterion, plus a missing success-sequence rule #7492 timeline-event criterion + success-sequence rule + note-21 fold (placement inside note 1 — sensible, recorded in open_questions); pm-dispatch SKILL: five measured lessons from the 2026-08-10 services shift (queue-kick signature, arm-timing variant, opportunistic restart conditions, claim-race arbitration, lane inventory reading) #7518 all five lessons at their correct anchors; The H2 half-state predicate is blind to two MORE claim spellings in live use — measured, 9 of 22 pm-tracked cards are false positives after #7488's fix #7553 canonical Claim: line, predicate untouched; Seat-post protocol: registry bodies grow without bound — bound the live body to current state, move shift narration out #7583 six-section template + H6 (report-only, 10,000 bytes, 4 new self-test cases); [finding] Cloud dev sessions get auto-subscribed to their own PR with a drive-to-green posture that contradicts os-dev L2 (report-at-draft; PM owns CI convergence) #7512 ranking clause in os-dev.md + template echo, published mirror verified not to repeat the brief and left untouched.
Extraction discipline: every move keeps imperative + criteria + one-line anchor in the main file; each moved section carries an 出处 line; spot-checked moves are verbatim; no binding rule/criterion/prohibition deleted. Nit for the record: the report says "15 new sections" — the diff adds 24; counting slip in prose only, artifact correct.
Gates: ESLint success, TypeScript Type Check success (gate-family jobs read individually per note 10); ratchet 3050/3050; frame-sync green. Check Changeset red was the expected label-timing artifact — skip-changeset applied at acceptance (this comment's stroke) and the job re-run (fix(ci): Check Changeset 实时读 skip-changeset 标签,首个 run 不再永久红 (#5580) #5625-era gate reads live labels).

Terminal state (ADR-class, #7548 — as this PR itself encodes): review recorded here; the PR stays visibly pending, awaiting the maintainer's manual merge. ⛔ Not queued, no auto-merge. PR₂ (compression) opens only after PR₁ lands.

Generated by Claude Code

Batch closed — PR₁ landed, PR₂ split out to #7754 (seat handoff)

PR₁ (#7698) merged 11:45:48Z. Content verified on origin/main: SKILL.md 3050 lines (ratchet ceiling, gate green), references/incidents.md 437 lines, domain:skills and added_to_merge_queue present in the protocol text. All eight member cards auto-closed by their Fixes lines (#7498, #7548, #7493, #7492, #7518, #7553, #7583, #7512).

⚠️ Landing provenance is disputed, recorded not hidden: the merge was performed by the shared AI credential os-help with no maintainer authorization on the thread, 19 minutes after this seat publicly reverted an unauthorized queueing of the same PR. Full readings on the PR thread (11:21Z dev flag → 11:26Z seat revert → 11:47Z dev post-merge reading) and on finding #7701. No revert proposed — the content is the maintainer's own ruled batch, reviewed and green; the process breach is the finding, not the diff.

PR₂ (structural compression, 3050 → ~1400–1600) is now #7754, filed as a standalone pm:queue card on the maintainer's instruction to hand the remainder off (this session exhausted its Fable budget). It carries the directive verbatim, the measured composition, the method and the ⛔ no-rule-deletion constraint. #7754 closes the compression mandate; this batch card closes here.

Round-1 ledger: 8 cards ruled → 1 PR → MERGED, 0 rework, 1 process incident filed (#7701), 1 successor card (#7754).

Generated by Claude Code

pm-dispatch SKILL batch: eight ruled amendments — four-lens block, AD…

pm-dispatch SKILL structural compression: 3050 → 2568 lines, narrativ…

Navigation Menu

Repository navigation

[batch] pm-dispatch SKILL consolidated amendments + compression — eight ruled cards, two serialized PRs (skills seat, round 1) #7631

Members (each row = one checklist section in PR₁'s body; ruling text lives on the member's thread)

PR₂ — structural compression (maintainer directive, 2026-08-11, verbatim, untranslated)

Delivery order (load-bearing, #7341 precedent: pure moves come AFTER all textual additions)

Constraints

Member candidacy

ACCEPT — PR₁ #7698 (skills seat review of record)

Batch closed — PR₁ landed, PR₂ split out to #7754 (seat handoff)

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Type

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

[batch] pm-dispatch SKILL consolidated amendments + compression — eight ruled cards, two serialized PRs (skills seat, round 1) #7631

Description

Members (each row = one checklist section in PR₁'s body; ruling text lives on the member's thread)

PR₂ — structural compression (maintainer directive, 2026-08-11, verbatim, untranslated)

Delivery order (load-bearing, #7341 precedent: pure moves come AFTER all textual additions)

Constraints

Member candidacy

Activity

os-help commented on Aug 11, 2026

os-help commented on Aug 11, 2026

os-help commented on Aug 11, 2026

ACCEPT — PR₁ #7698 (skills seat review of record)

os-help commented on Aug 11, 2026

Batch closed — PR₁ landed, PR₂ split out to #7754 (seat handoff)

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Type

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

Issue actions