The snow had turned grey along the curbs, and the platform was full of students with suitcases and parents with paper cups of coffee. Elliot’s train left at 10:14. They stood under the departure board for the last six minutes and didn’t say much.

“Two hours on the train,” Nate said. “Then eight days. Then I see you.”

“Eight days,” Elliot said. “You’ve done the math.”

“I’m good at math.” Nate pulled his phone out of his pocket. “My mom wants a photo. A real one. She’s asked three times.”

So they took one, there on the platform, with the train already waiting behind them: Nate’s arm around Elliot’s shoulders, Elliot’s head tipped against his jaw, both of them squinting and red-nosed and laughing at something neither of them could remember afterwards. It wasn’t a good photo. Nate’s thumb was in the corner of it. It was the best photo either of them had ever been in.

Then the doors beeped, and Nate kissed him, in front of the parents and the suitcases and a very interested little boy in a dinosaur hat, and Elliot got on the train.

He watched Nate through the window until the platform bent away and disappeared. Nate didn’t move the whole time. He just stood there under the departure board with his hands in his jacket pockets, getting smaller.

Elliot’s phone buzzed before the train had even left the station.

His mom was waiting at the station at home in her hospital scrubs under her winter coat, because she had come straight from a shift, and she hugged him so hard on the platform that his bag slid off his shoulder.

“You look different,” she said, holding him at arm’s length.

“I’ve been on a train for two hours.”

“No.” She narrowed her eyes at him. “You look happy. You haven’t looked happy since the spring.”

The apartment was exactly the same as always: fourth floor, a radiator that clanked, a Christmas tree from the supermarket with far too many lights on it, and his old swimming certificates still stuck to the fridge with magnets from places neither of them had ever been. It smelled of pancakes. It always smelled of pancakes when he came home. She had told him once that it was the only thing she knew how to make that tasted like being welcome.

They sat at the kitchen table, and he told her everything.

Not everything everything. But the important parts. The lecture hall. The coffee. Sophie. The months of being a secret, and the night he had ended it, and the presentation, and the second row on the last Tuesday. He told her about Nate’s father. He told her about the snow.

She listened the whole time without saying a word, her chin in her hand, her pancake going cold on her plate. When he was done, she was crying a little, the same way she had cried at this table when he was sixteen.

“Does he make you happy?” she asked.

“Yes,” Elliot said. “He makes me feel like I don’t have to be careful.”

“Then I like him already.” She wiped her eyes with the back of her wrist. “Show me.”

He showed her the photo from the platform. She looked at it for a long time.

“He’s very handsome,” she said. “His thumb’s in the corner.”

“I know.”

“Send it to me.”

The next morning the photo was on the fridge, printed out on the cheap printer in the hallway, the colors slightly too pink, stuck right in the middle between his swimming certificate from when he was nine and a takeout menu from a Chinese place that had closed years ago.

Nate drove north on the twenty-third, after his last shift at the Anchor, with the heater broken and a bag of Bev’s leftover Christmas mince pies on the passenger seat.

His mother was waiting in the open doorway before he had even turned off the engine. She didn’t say anything. She just came down the steps in her cardigan, into the cold, and held him for a long time on the gravel, and Nate put his face into her hair, which smelled of flour and lavender, and let himself be held.

His father was in his study. The door was closed.

“Give him time,” his mother said quietly.

Christmas Eve was the quietest one Nate could remember. The fire crackled under the mantelpiece full of trophies. The lake outside the big windows was black, with a thin edge of ice along the shore. Under the tree, there was a small present wrapped in silver paper with Sophie written on the tag in his mother’s handwriting. Halfway through the evening Nate noticed that it was gone. His mother had moved it somewhere without a word.

His father said “Nathan” when he came in to dinner, and “Pass the potatoes,” and “Halloran tells me your erg times are holding.” That was all. He cut his meat into small precise squares and didn’t look up.

Nate went to bed early. His childhood bedroom was cold, under the slope of the roof, with the trophies on the shelf and the curling poster of the national team and the photo of himself at eight in a tiny life jacket on his father’s lap. He lay on the narrow bed under the plaid blanket and called Elliot.

“Hey,” Elliot said, very softly. In the background Nate could hear a television and someone laughing at it. “How is it?”

“Quiet,” Nate said. “My mom’s being amazing. My dad’s being a closed door.” He looked at the ceiling. “There was a present for Sophie under the tree. My mom hid it.”

“Oh, Nate.”

“It’s okay. It’s actually okay.” He was surprised to find that it was true. “How’s yours?”

“My mom’s watching a Christmas movie she’s seen eleven times and telling me what happens before it happens.” Elliot laughed. “She’s made pancakes twice today. She keeps asking when she can meet you.”

Nate smiled into the dark. The floorboards out in the hallway creaked, the way they always did in this house, because it was a hundred and ten years old and carried every sound.

The last time he had lain in this bed on the phone with Elliot, he had whispered. He had held his breath at every creak. He had been so afraid of being heard.

“Elliot,” he said.

He didn’t whisper.

“I love you.”

There was a silence on the other end. Then, very quietly: “Your dad’s in the house.”

“I know,” Nate said, in exactly the same voice. “I love you. Merry Christmas.”

“Merry Christmas,” Elliot said, and Nate could hear that he was smiling, and maybe crying a little. “I love you too. Go to sleep.”

He did, for the first time in that room, without lying awake.

On Christmas morning Nate woke before the sun, the way his body always did, and went down to the dock with his coffee.

The mist was low on the lake. The ice along the shore was thin and grey and creaked when the water moved under it. He sat on the end of the dock his grandfather had built, his legs hanging over the water, and watched the light come up behind the pines.

He heard the footsteps on the frozen grass before he saw him. His father came down the garden in his old waxed jacket, with a mug in each hand. He stopped at the end of the dock for a moment, as if deciding something. Then he walked out and stood next to Nate and held out one of the mugs.

Nate already had a coffee. He took the second one anyway.

Nate stayed sitting and his father stayed standing, and for a while they just looked at the lake.

“Halloran called me,” his father said finally. “He says you took a single out alone on the twelfth. At five in the morning.”

“Yes, sir.”

“He says you rowed like you used to. When you were small.” His father didn’t look at him. “Before I started timing you.”

Nate didn’t know what to say to that, so he didn’t say anything.

“Your mother showed me the photo,” his father said. “The one at the station.”

Nate’s hands tightened around the mugs.

“I’m not going to pretend I understand it, Nathan.” His father’s voice was very even, very careful, the voice of a man walking across ice that might not hold him. “I don’t. And I’m not ready to talk about money, or next year, or any of it.” He paused. “But I watched that boy at the regatta. He was the one you looked for. Before your mother. Before me. Before the time on the board.” He was quiet for a moment. “I noticed. I didn’t like noticing.”

“I know,” Nate said.

“Your mother wants him here at Easter.”

Nate turned and looked up at him.

His father was still looking at the lake. His jaw was set, the same sharp jaw Nate saw in the mirror every morning. But something in it had shifted, just slightly, the way ice shifts before it breaks up in spring.

“I’ll be at the house,” his father said. “That’s all I can tell you right now.”

Then he turned and walked back up the garden with his empty hands in his jacket pockets, and Nate sat on the end of the dock with two cups of coffee going cold and the sun coming up over the pines, and found that he was crying, and that it didn’t hurt.

It wasn’t much. It wasn’t an apology, or a blessing, or a hug.

It was, Nate thought, the most his father had ever said with so few words.

On the twenty-sixth Elliot took the morning train back.

His mom drove him to the station in the dark before her shift, with a foil package of pancakes on his lap “for the boy, he looks like he doesn’t eat breakfast”, and a long green scarf she had knitted wrapped around his neck, “to go with your eyes”. She kissed him on both cheeks on the platform.

“Bring him home,” she said. “Soon. I mean it.”

“I will.”

“And Elliot.” She held on to his hands for a moment. “Don’t be careful. You’ve been careful enough for one life.”

Nate was waiting on the platform at the other end. He was standing in exactly the same place where Elliot had left him eight days ago, under the departure board, in his jacket, with his hands in his pockets, as if he hadn’t moved the whole time.

Elliot didn’t run. He wanted to. He walked very fast.

Nate caught him halfway down the platform and lifted him clean off his feet.

“Hi,” Nate said into his scarf.

“Hi.”

“You smell like pancakes.”

“My mom sent you some.” Elliot pulled back and held up the foil package. “She says you look like you don’t eat breakfast.”

Nate ate two cold pancakes standing on the platform, then and there, with snow falling on the foil, and told Elliot that his mother was a genius and that he was going to marry her.

They spent the afternoon walking. The town was half empty and very quiet between the holidays, the shop windows still full of tinsel, the river slow and grey under the bridge. They walked past the Anchor, closed for the day, with a handwritten sign in Bev’s capital letters on the door: BACK TOMORROW. GO HOME. They walked past the boathouse, where the big doors were shut and the snow lay untouched on the gravel. They walked past the old lecture building, dark and locked, and Elliot looked up at the tall windows of Lecture Hall B and thought about a pale October morning.

In the car, with the engine running and the broken heater blowing lukewarm air at their knees, they gave each other their presents.

Elliot’s was a box of twelve good pens, the heavy metal kind.

“So you stop chewing mine,” he said.

Nate laughed so hard he had to rest his forehead on the steering wheel. Then he took out one of the pens, looked at it seriously, and put the end of it in his mouth.

“Nate.”

“It’s a good pen,” Nate said around it. “Very chewable.”

Then he took something out of the pocket of his jacket and put it in Elliot’s hand.

It was a key. A single silver key on a ring, with a small cardboard tag. On the tag, in messy slanted handwriting without a single capital letter, it said: room 214. so you never have to wait outside.

Elliot looked at it for a long time.

“There was a rule,” Nate said quietly. “Back in November. Never in my dorm. Do you remember?”

“I remember.”

“I hated that rule.” Nate looked at the key in Elliot’s palm. “I made it, and I hated it. Every single Thursday. You were never allowed to see where I live. Where I wake up. Like you were something I had to keep outside.” He closed Elliot’s fingers around the key with his own. “So. No more outside.”

Elliot didn’t say anything. He just leaned across the gearshift and kissed him, and the pen fell out of Nate’s mouth and rolled somewhere under the seat, and they never found it again.

There was one more thing in the bag on the back seat: a tin of lavender shortbread wrapped in silver paper, with a card taped to the lid. Elliot opened it.

For Elliot. Thank you for asking about the scar. Come for Easter. With love, Helen.

And underneath, in a different hand, sharp and upright and very small, as if it had been written quickly before anyone could see:

R. Carter

Nate stared at it.

“He signed it,” he said. “He actually signed it.”

That evening they went to the cinema.

It was the old Regent on the high street, with a neon sign that had been missing its second E for as long as anyone could remember, red velvet seats worn bald at the armrests, and a carpet that smelled of popcorn and forty years of rain. The film was a Christmas comedy about a dog that neither of them had chosen and neither of them would remember.

Nate had bought the tickets online. When they found their seats in the half-empty cinema, Elliot stopped in the aisle and started to laugh.

Row B. Seats one and two. On the left.

“Second row,” Nate said innocently, sitting down. “Left side. It’s just where I like to sit.”

“You’re unbelievable.”

“I’m consistent.”

They held hands through the whole film. Not under anything. On the worn velvet armrest between them, in the flickering blue light, where anyone who turned around could see. Nobody turned around. Halfway through, Nate fell asleep on Elliot’s shoulder for about four minutes and woke up with a jolt, saying “I was watching,” and Elliot laughed so hard that a woman in the row behind them shushed him.

When the lights came up, Nate said he needed the bathroom.

“Me too,” Elliot said.

They looked at each other.

The men’s room at the Regent was long and narrow, with green tiles that had probably been fashionable in the sixties, a hand dryer that roared like a jet engine, and four urinals in a row along one wall.

It was empty.

Nate went to the one at the far end. Elliot hesitated at the door for a second. Then he walked down the row, very deliberately, and stood at the one right next to him.

Read more

It was five in the morning and still completely dark. Nobody else was at the boathouse. He carried the boat down the ramp by himself, set it on the black water, and pushed off from the dock, and for an hour he rowed upstream under the bridge and back again, past the oak tree at the finish line, past the Anchor with its windows dark, past the place where the gravel lane came down to the water.

He didn’t race. He didn’t count strokes. He didn’t think about his father or the national team or the internship or the reading he wasn’t going to give. He just rowed, slowly, the way he hadn’t rowed since he was six years old, when the boat had still been something that floated and not something he had to win in.

When the sun came up, grey and pale over the trees, he sat still in the middle of the river with the oars resting on the water and watched the mist lift.

He thought about Sophie, getting ready in a hotel room with an ocean view, in a pale blue dress. He hoped it was a beautiful day. He hoped she danced. He hoped someone made her laugh so hard she spilled her drink.

Then he thought about a second row, left side, and a blond head bent over a notebook full of semicolons, and he picked up his oars and rowed home.

“So,” Priya said on Monday night.

She was packing. Her train home left on Tuesday at three; the dorms closed on Friday, and half the floor had already gone. Her suitcase lay open on her bed, half full of books and socks, and she was folding a sweater with great concentration and not looking at him.

“So what?” Elliot said.

“So. Tuesday. Last lecture before Christmas.” She folded the sweater again, though it was already folded. “Second row.”

“Left side,” Elliot said.

“Are you going?”

“Of course I’m going. It’s a lecture. Attendance is...”

“Ell.”

Elliot was quiet for a while. He was sitting on his bed with his back against the wall, the spot where Nate always sat, and he had been staring at the same page of his book for twenty minutes.

“Whitcombe said it would be a shame if he were the only one,” he said finally. “The only one who said the true thing out loud.”

Priya put the sweater down.

“And?”

“And I’ve been thinking about it all weekend.” He looked up at her. “He did everything I asked. He told Sophie. He told his mom. He told his whole team. He stood up in front of two hundred people and told them about me. He lost his dad’s money for it. And I walked out.” He laughed, a little shakily. “I’ve been so busy being brave about not being a secret that I forgot the other half.”

“What’s the other half?”

“Being brave about wanting him anyway.”

Priya looked at him for a long moment over her glasses. Then she crossed the room, sat down next to him on the bed, and put her head on his shoulder.

“I’m leaving at three tomorrow,” she said. “This room is going to be empty until January.” She paused. “Just saying.”

“Priya.”

“I’m just saying,” said Priya, and Elliot laughed properly for the first time in eleven days.

On Tuesday morning Elliot arrived at Lecture Hall B at 8:40.

The hall was half empty already. Christmas sweaters, people with suitcases next to their seats, ready to go straight to the station after the lecture. Snow had been promised for the afternoon, and the light coming through the tall windows was flat and white and strange.

He sat down in the second row, left side. He took out his notebook and wrote the date at the top of the page, very neatly.

Then he waited.

At 8:52 the door at the back opened.

Read more

He had expected it to be dramatic. Crying in the shower, sad songs, staring out of windows in the rain. And there was some of that. But mostly it was just Saturday, and then Sunday, and getting up, and brushing his teeth, and going to the library, and reading the same paragraph about loss aversion six times. Mostly it was the space next to him on the bed where nobody was. The coffee he made himself, black, and didn’t drink.

Priya was very careful with him. She didn’t say I told you so. She didn’t say anything about Nate at all. She made him eat. She dragged him to a film with Nina on Saturday night and let him sit between them in the dark and not watch it.

On Sunday evening she came back from Nina’s with a strange look on her face, sat down on the end of his bed, and took her glasses off, which she only did when something was serious.

“Okay,” she said. “I’m going to tell you something, and I need you to not freak out.”

“That’s a terrible way to start a sentence.”

“I know.” She took a breath. “Nina heard it from Amira, who heard it from Jess. Who’s one of Sophie’s best friends.” She paused. “Nate broke up with Sophie. On Friday. The day after you ended it.”

Elliot stared at her.

Read more

Then he turned his phone face down on the shelf above his bed and didn’t turn it over again until morning. There was nothing.

On Monday there was nothing.

On Tuesday, at 8:58, Elliot heard the sneakers on the wooden steps of Lecture Hall B, and heard them go past the second row without slowing down, up and up, to the very top, where Marcus and Dev sat. He didn’t turn around. He wrote the date at the top of his page, very neatly, and underlined it once.

There was no coffee on his desk.

Whitcombe talked about the planning fallacy for fifty minutes. Elliot took notes in full sentences. Halfway through, without meaning to, he turned his head, just a little, and looked up the rows of creaking wooden seats.

Nate was sitting at the end of the top row with his hood up, staring at his desk. He looked like he hadn’t slept since the lake. He didn’t look up. Not once.

Next to him, Dev did. Dev met Elliot’s eyes across the whole lecture hall and held them for a second, and then gave him a small, tired nod, the kind of nod that said I know. I’m sorry. I’m watching him.

Elliot turned back to his notebook. The margin next to his notes was empty. He realized he had been leaving space for Nate’s handwriting for six weeks.

“I’m going to key his car,” Priya said on Wednesday night.

“You’re not going to key his car.”

“I’m going to key his car so hard.” She was sitting on her bed with her laptop closed in her lap, which was how Elliot knew she was really angry. “Two months, Ell. Two months of you being his dirty little secret, and the first time things get hard, he just... switches you off? Like a phone?”

“His dad threatened to cut him off. Everything. His tuition, his car...”

“So? Your mom works double shifts at a hospital and you’re on three scholarships. Nobody gets to keep everything.” She stopped. Took a breath. Her voice went softer. “I’m sorry. I know you love him. I’m just so tired of watching you wait by your phone.”

Elliot didn’t say anything. He was tired of it too. That was the worst part. He was so tired of it, and he still checked the phone the second Priya went to brush her teeth.

Nothing.

On Thursday, at 7:06 p.m., there was a knock on the door.

Priya was at Nina’s. She had left at six, without being asked, and squeezed his shoulder on her way out and said, “Just in case,” and Elliot had told her nobody was coming.

He opened the door.

Nate stood in the hallway in his grey hoodie and his jacket, no coffees, no pretzels, nothing in his hands. He looked worse than he had in the lecture hall. Grey under the tan. His eyes red-rimmed. A small cut on his lip where he’d been biting it.

“Hi,” he said. His voice was hoarse.

Elliot held on to the door.

“You said you needed time,” he said.

“I know.”

“It’s been four days.”

“I know.” Nate’s jaw worked. “I tried. I sat in my car for an hour tonight in the parking lot down there, telling myself to drive away. I couldn’t.” He looked at Elliot, and his eyes were wet. “I can’t stay away from you. I’ve tried for four days and I can’t.”

Elliot should have closed the door. He knew it. Some calm, clear part of his mind knew it with absolute certainty.

He stepped aside instead.

Nate came in and stood in the middle of the room, under the fairy lights, and told him everything: the dock, the mist, the coffee going cold. The pine boards that carry sound. Some boy you’ve known for two months. Tuition, car, apartment. Your mother doesn’t need to know. His voice was flat and steady the whole time, the way you’d read out a list, until he got to his mother at the car, I am your mother first, and then it cracked down the middle and he had to stop.

Elliot listened to all of it without interrupting. When Nate finished, he sat down on the edge of the bed.

“What are you going to do?” Elliot asked quietly.

Nate sat down next to him. Their shoulders didn’t quite touch.

“I don’t know,” he said. “I don’t know yet. I just know that I didn’t want to spend another night not seeing you.”

Elliot looked at him for a long time. At the scar. At the bitten lip. At the hands lying open on his knees, palms up, as if he were waiting to be handed something.

And Elliot knew, very quietly and very clearly, what he was going to do. Not now. Afterwards. He knew it the way you know, halfway through a book, how it’s going to end.

He reached over and touched Nate’s face.

“Come here,” he whispered.

His heart was pounding like a metronome set too fast. He cupped Nate’s jaw, feeling the coarse stubble beneath his fingertips, the sharp line of Nate’s cheekbone. His thumb traced the small cut on Nate’s lower lip, a stark red against the pale skin. Nate’s breath hitched, and he leaned into Elliot’s touch, his eyes fluttering closed.

“Elliot,” Nate whispered, his voice barely audible, like a prayer.

Elliot leaned in, pressing their lips together gently, as if Nate were made of glass. He kissed him slowly, carefully, exploring the softness of his mouth, the roughness of his stubble. Nate kissed him back, desperate and hungry, but Elliot guided him, slowing him down until they matched each other’s pace.

Nate’s hands came up to grip Elliot’s wrists, his fingers digging into Elliot’s skin. “I’m sorry,” he murmured against Elliot’s lips. “I’m so sorry.”

Elliot pulled back slightly, looking into Nate’s red-rimmed eyes. “Shh,” he said softly. “It’s okay.” But it wasn’t, not really. Not with the secret weight of their future hanging between them.

He started with Nate’s jacket, slowly pushing it off his shoulders and down his arms. Nate helped him, wriggling out of it until it fell to the floor with a soft thud. Elliot tossed it aside, never breaking eye contact with Nate.

Read more

He told it badly. Out of order, too fast, his hands gripping the steering wheel as if the car were moving. The phone on the bench. The gym bag with Elliot’s name on it. Six a.m., two cups of coffee, twenty-two days, Carter.

When he’d finished, Elliot was quiet for a long time.

“He’s right,” Elliot said finally.

“I know he’s right.”

“No, I mean...” Elliot turned in the passenger seat to look at him. “He’s right, and he’s being kind about it. He could have walked straight to Sophie’s door on Thursday night. He didn’t. He gave you three weeks.” He paused. “That’s more than I would have given you, honestly.”

Nate laughed, short and miserable, and rested his forehead on the steering wheel.

“I’m going to do it,” he said into the wheel. “Next weekend. After I get back from my parents’. I’ll take her somewhere quiet and I’ll tell her everything.”

“Your parents’?”

“My mom called. They want me home next weekend. Just me.” Nate lifted his head. “She said my dad wants to talk about the internship. About the summer.”

Something in his voice made Elliot reach over and take his hand.

“Just the internship?” Elliot asked.

“I don’t know,” said Nate. “With my dad, it’s never just anything.”

The following Saturday, Elliot had dinner with Priya and Nina.

Nina was an art student with a silver ring in her nose, paint permanently under her fingernails and a laugh so loud that people at other tables turned around. Elliot had met her maybe a dozen times. He liked her enormously, mostly because she was the only person in the world who could make Priya blush.

They went to a cheap Lebanese place near the art building, and Nina ordered for all of them without asking, and halfway through the second plate of falafel she pointed her fork at him and said, “So. The rower.”

Elliot choked on his water. Priya hid her face in her hands.

“I tell her everything,” Priya said through her fingers. “Sorry. It’s a relationship thing.”

“It’s fine,” Elliot said, wiping his mouth. “It’s... fine.”

“Is he good to you?” Nina asked. No joke in her voice now. Just the question.

Elliot thought about it. About the notebook. About the scar and the steamed-up windows and the way Nate had said I mean it in the locker room, his voice breaking.

“When he’s with me,” he said slowly, “he’s the best thing that’s ever happened to me. It’s when he’s not with me that it’s...” He shrugged. “Hard.”

Nina nodded. She and Priya exchanged a look that Elliot pretended not to see.

“He’s at his parents’ this weekend,” Elliot said. “His dad wanted to talk to him.”

“Uh-oh,” said Nina.

“Yeah,” said Elliot. “Uh-oh.”

His phone buzzed on the table. He turned it over too fast, and both of them grinned at him.

Read more

He was sitting up in bed with the duvet pulled around his shoulders, watching Nate hunt for his clothes in the grey morning light. One sock under the desk. The navy shirt on the floor by the door. The trousers with the buzzing phone still in the pocket.

“I can’t.” Nate was pulling on the shirt, buttoning it wrong, starting again. “Not like this. Not by text at eight in the morning while she’s standing outside my door with pancakes.”

“Then go there and tell her to her face.”

“Elliot.” Nate stopped buttoning. “She’s standing in my hallway. Marcus is standing in my hallway. Half the team lives on that floor. You want me to do it there?”

Elliot didn’t answer. He didn’t have an answer. He just watched Nate pick up the phone, stare at it, and start to type.

Read more

He sat on the closed lid of the toilet in the bright, empty bathroom for twenty minutes with the phone in his hand, typing and deleting. He’s fine. Delete. I don’t really know him that well. Delete, because it was a lie, and a stupid one. Maybe you should ask him. Delete.

In the end he went back to his room, lay down in the dark, and stared at the ceiling until three in the morning, with Sophie’s three messages glowing on the screen next to his pillow like something radioactive.

is nate ok? he’s been really different. like, distant. I’m kind of worried about him.

She was worried about him. She was worried about her boyfriend, and she had come to Elliot for help, because Elliot was Nate’s sweet, nerdy econ friend who was saving his grades.

He pressed the heels of his hands into his eyes, the way Nate always did.

“Show me,” Priya said the next morning.

He handed her the phone. She read the messages, then read them again, and her mouth went thin.

“Wow,” she said quietly. “Okay. She took your number from his phone?”

“Apparently.”

“Does he know?”

“I don’t think so.”

Priya handed the phone back and sat down on the edge of his bed. For once, she didn’t make a joke.

“Ell, whatever you write back, it’s going to be a lie,” she said. “Unless it’s the truth. And the truth isn’t yours to tell. It’s his.” She looked at him. “That’s the problem with being the secret. You end up lying for someone who isn’t lying for you.”

Elliot looked at the screen for a long time. Then he typed, slowly, choosing every word as if it were made of glass.

It wasn’t a lie. That was the worst thing about it. Every word was true, and it was still the most dishonest thing he had ever written.

The answer came in under a minute.

Elliot put the phone face down on the duvet.

“Well?” said Priya.

“She invited us to the regatta,” Elliot said. “Both of us. Finish line. Big oak tree.”

Priya closed her eyes for a second.

“Of course she did,” she said.

He told Nate on Thursday, at 7:04 p.m., before Nate had even taken off his jacket.

He’d planned to wait. He’d planned to at least let Nate sit down. But Nate came in with rain on his shoulders and two coffees and a grin, and leaned in to kiss him, and Elliot stepped back and held out his phone instead.

Nate’s grin faded as he read. Elliot watched it go, line by line.

“She took your number,” Nate said. “From my phone.”

“Yeah.”

“When?”

“I don’t know. Does it matter?”

Nate put the coffees down on the desk, very carefully, as if they might explode. “She... I leave it on the table when I shower. I never thought...” He scrolled up, then down again. “And you answered her.”

“What was I supposed to do? Ignore her?” Elliot heard his own voice rising and couldn’t stop it. “She’s worried about you, Nate. She’s actually, genuinely worried, and she came to me, and I had to sit there and write her something that was technically true so that I wouldn’t have to lie to her face. Do you know what that felt like?”

Nate didn’t say anything. His jaw was tight.

“And now she wants me to come to the regatta. To stand next to her at the finish line and cheer for you. With your parents there.” Elliot laughed, and it came out cracked. “I can’t keep doing this. I can’t be your friend in public and your... whatever I am in here. I’m not good at it. I don’t want to be good at it.”

“I know,” Nate said quietly.

“Do you?”

“Yes.” Nate turned around. His eyes were red. “I know, okay? I know. You think I like this? I lie to her every single day. I lie to my teammates. I’m going to lie to my dad on Saturday, to his face, with my mom standing right there. Every time I’m with her, I’m thinking about you, and every time I’m with you, I’m thinking about how I have to go back.” He dragged a hand down his face. “I hate it. I hate myself for it.”

“Then stop,” Elliot said.

“After the regatta.” Nate’s voice broke on it. “Please. Just let me get through Saturday. My dad’s going to be there. Halloran’s put me in the first boat. If I blow up my whole life two days before the race, I’ll... I can’t think, Elliot. I can barely row as it is. After Saturday I’ll figure it out. I’ll talk to her. I swear to God.”

Elliot looked at him for a long time: at the red eyes, at the rain still drying in his hair, at the hands that were shaking slightly at his sides.

“You swear,” he said.

“I swear.”

The silence stretched. Outside, a car alarm went off in the parking lot and stopped again.

Elliot’s heart hammered against his ribs as Nate’s mouth crashed onto his, teeth clicking, tongues tangling in desperation and anger. The force pushed him backwards until his legs hit the edge of his narrow bed. Then they were a tangle of limbs and urgent hands, pulling at each other’s clothes.

Nate’s jacket hit the floor first, followed by his hoodie, revealing smooth, tanned skin damp from the rain. Elliot’s T-shirt joined the pile, baring his warm, flushed chest. The contrast was stark - Nate’s cool, rain-kissed skin against Elliot’s heated flesh sent shivers dancing down Elliot’s spine.

They fell onto the bed, Nate on top, their erections grinding against each other through denim and thin cotton. Elliot gasped at the sensation - the thick, hard length of Nate pressing into him, the curve of it digging against his own. He could feel every ridge, every pulse as Nate rocked into him, his breath ragged in Elliot’s ear.

The anger in the kiss began to ebb, replaced by something softer, more desperate. Nate paused, looked down at Elliot with red-rimmed eyes, and whispered, “I’m sorry. I’m so sorry.” Elliot pulled him back down, their mouths finding each other again in a slower, deeper dance.

They undressed each other slowly this time, fingers fumbling with buttons and zippers. Nate’s jeans slid off, revealing the thick, veined length of him straining against black boxer briefs. Elliot pushed his sweatpants down, his own erection tenting his white boxer briefs.

Nate’s penis was a thing of beauty - long and very thick, with prominent veins along the shaft, it curved slightly to the right, ending in a broad, pink head already glistening at the tip. Elliot’s own cock was no less impressive, the head swollen and dark, a prominent vein running along the underside.

Nate settled on top of Elliot again, their skin pressing together from chest to thighs. They rocked against each other, their erections sliding between their stomachs. The heat was intense, the friction sending sparks shooting through Elliot’s body. He could feel Nate’s wetness mixing with his own, spreading between them, making their movements slick and smooth.

Elliot wrapped his hand around both of them, feeling the different shapes sliding against each other - Nate’s thickness, his curve, the soft skin over steel hardness. Nate’s breath hitched as Elliot’s long fingers gripped them tightly, stroking in time with their hips.

He’s still here, Elliot thought. And I want him. All of him. But he also wanted Nate to be sure, to be free. So, he held on, their bodies moving together, their hearts beating in sync, and waited for what came next.

Nate breathed against Elliot’s ear, his voice a low rumble, “I want more. I want all of it. With you.” Elliot’s heart pounded in response, his body aching with desire, but he kept his voice steady as he replied, “Not yet. Not while you’re still hers.” Nate went still for a moment before nodding against Elliot’s neck, his kiss turning soft and sad.

They continued to move together, their hips setting a faster rhythm, hands joined around their erections. Elliot could feel every ridge, every pulse of Nate’s cock as they stroked each other, the heat building between them like a storm about to break.

Nate’s breath came in ragged gasps, his body trembling above Elliot. The bed creaked beneath them, the sound of their flesh meeting echoing through the room, punctuated by the steady rhythm of rain on the window. Elliot’s thoughts fragmented, his world narrowing down to Nate - the smell of soap and rain, the taste of his skin, the sound of his breath.

Nate’s body tensed suddenly, a low groan tearing from his throat as he came. His cock pulsed in their joined hands, thick ropes of cum shooting out, landing hot and slick on Elliot’s stomach and chest. Elliot watched, fascinated, as Nate’s release coated him, the white liquid stark against his flushed skin.

Feeling Nate come pushed Elliot over the edge seconds later. His back arched, a cry tearing from his throat as waves of pleasure crashed over him. He could feel every pulse, every jet of cum as it mixed with Nate’s on his stomach, the sensation almost overwhelming in its intensity. This is Nate, he thought. All of him. And I love him. Fear prickled at the edges of his consciousness - fear of Saturday, fear of losing this moment - but he pushed it away, focusing instead on the feel of Nate’s body against his.

They lay there, sticky and panting, Nate’s cum cooling on Elliot’s skin. Nate looked down at the mess they’d made, a shaky laugh escaping him before he reached for the box of tissues on the shelf above the bed. He cleaned Elliot up slowly, almost tenderly, wiping away the evidence of their passion. Elliot watched him, his heart swelling with emotion - this was more than sex, more than desire. This was Nate, and he was falling in love.

When Nate finally settled down next to him, his head on Elliot’s chest, he said, “After Saturday.” Elliot stroked his damp hair, feeling the softness beneath his fingertips. “After Saturday,” he echoed, but they both knew it wouldn’t be that simple.

The morning of the regatta was cold and bright and absolutely perfect for rowing.

That was what everyone kept saying. Elliot heard it four times on the walk down to the river with Priya: perfect conditions, flat water, barely any wind. The whole town seemed to have turned up. The riverbank below the boathouse was lined with white tents and club flags snapping in the breeze, people in scarves and puffer jackets holding paper cups of coffee and mulled wine, kids on their parents’ shoulders, a man with a megaphone announcing heats nobody could quite understand. The air smelled of frost and fried onions from a food truck by the path.

“I’m going to say this once,” Priya said, linking her arm through his as they pushed through the crowd. “If at any point you want to leave, you squeeze my arm twice, and I fake a migraine. I’m very good at fake migraines. I did it at my cousin’s wedding for three hours.”

“Thanks.”

“I mean it.”

“I know you do.” He squeezed her arm once. Not twice. Not yet.

The big oak tree stood at the finish line on a little rise above the water, its last orange leaves clinging to the branches. Sophie was already there, bundled in a cream-colored coat and the scarf wrapped twice around her neck, waving both arms. And next to her stood two people Elliot knew immediately, even though he had never seen them before.

Richard Carter was tall, grey-haired and straight-backed, with Nate’s sharp jaw and none of Nate’s softness. He wore a dark wool coat and stood very still, binoculars in one hand, watching the start line far upriver as if he could make the boats go faster by looking at them. The woman next to him was small and fair, with kind, tired eyes and Nate’s exact smile. She was holding Sophie’s hand.

They look like a family, Elliot thought. She already looks like part of the family.

“Elliot! Priya!” Sophie hugged them both. “You came! Oh my God, this is so nice. Mrs. Carter, Mr. Carter, this is Elliot, Nate’s project partner. I told you about him. He’s basically Nate’s best friend now. And this is Priya.”

“Helen,” said Nate’s mother warmly, and shook their hands. “Please. Nate’s mentioned you, Elliot. He says you’re very clever.”

“He said that?”

“In his way.” She smiled. “Which means he said ‘he’s okay’ in a tone of voice I haven’t heard since he was about nine.”

Elliot didn’t know what to do with his face. He settled for smiling.

Richard Carter lowered his binoculars and looked at him. It was a long, assessing look, the same kind of look he’d probably give a boat before buying it. Then he held out his hand. His grip was dry and hard and very brief.

“So you’re the one,” he said.

Elliot’s heart stopped.

“Who’s been teaching my son economics,” Richard finished. “Halloran says he spends more time on that project than on the water.”

“It’s a big project,” Elliot said. His voice came out almost normal.

“Hm,” said Richard Carter, and lifted his binoculars again.

The first-boat final started at 11:40.

Elliot couldn’t see much at first: eight dots far upriver, then a distant shout, then the dots slowly growing into boats, long and narrow and impossibly fast, oars rising and falling in perfect unison like the wings of something alive. The crowd along the bank started to roar as they came closer. Two boats were ahead, almost level: the university crew in dark blue and a crew in red.

“That’s him,” Sophie screamed, gripping Helen’s arm. “Seat five! That’s Nate!”

Elliot found him. Seat five, in the middle of the boat. Even from that distance he recognized the shape of his shoulders, the line of his back as he drove through the stroke, his whole body uncoiling like a spring and then folding up again, over and over, in rhythm with seven other men. Elliot had never seen him row before. He had imagined it. He hadn’t imagined this: the power of it, the grace, the way Nate looked like he had been made for exactly this one thing.

The red boat pulled ahead by half a length. The crowd groaned. Next to him, Richard Carter said something under his breath that sounded like come on, come on, Nathan.

Then the cox in the blue boat screamed something, and the rhythm changed. Faster. Harder. Elliot watched Nate’s back bend and straighten, bend and straighten, and the blue boat started to creep back up, inch by inch, the bows level now, two hundred meters out, a hundred, fifty, and the noise of the crowd was so loud that Elliot couldn’t hear himself screaming Nate’s name, and then both boats shot past the oak tree and a horn blew and nobody knew who had won.

The announcer’s voice crackled over the speakers. Dark blue. By four-tenths of a second.

The riverbank exploded. Sophie was jumping up and down. Helen had both hands over her mouth, crying. Even Richard Carter’s face cracked into something that was almost a smile. Priya was hugging Elliot from the side and yelling something into his ear.

Out on the water, the blue boat was drifting past the finish, all eight rowers slumped over their oars, chests heaving. Then, one by one, they straightened up and started whooping and slapping each other’s backs.

Nate turned his head toward the shore.

He was looking for someone. Elliot could see it even from the bank: the way his eyes swept along the crowd under the oak tree. Past his mother. Past his father. Past Sophie, who was waving both arms over her head and screaming his name.

His eyes stopped on Elliot.

For one long second, across the water, they just looked at each other. Nate’s face was red and sweaty and wrecked with exhaustion, and it broke open into a smile so huge and so unguarded that Elliot felt it in his chest like a blow.

Then Nate’s eyes slid on, to Sophie, and he lifted his hand and waved at her.

Elliot let out a breath. Okay, he thought. Okay. Nobody saw that.

Next to him, Richard Carter slowly lowered his binoculars.

He didn’t say anything. He just looked at Elliot for a moment, one long, thoughtful look, and then turned back to his wife.

Elliot squeezed Priya’s arm twice.

The restaurant was called Marlowe’s, and it was the kind of place where the waiters put your napkin on your lap for you.

Nate sat between Sophie and his mother, in the navy button-down shirt his dad had bought him for occasions like this, his hair still damp from the boathouse showers, a medal on a ribbon in his jacket pocket that his mother kept asking him to put on and he kept refusing. His whole body ached in the good way it did after a race. His head ached in the other way.

“Four-tenths of a second,” Richard Carter said, for the third time, cutting his steak into precise squares. “Halloran says it’s the closest final in eleven years. That third five hundred, Nathan. That’s what I’ve been talking about since you were twelve. Focus.”

“Yes, sir.”

“Now you need to hold on to it. Next season, nationals. The national team selectors are going to be watching.” He pointed his knife across the table. “And Lewis at the firm says there’s an internship for you in June. Corporate finance. I told him you’ll take it.”

“Dad, I haven’t even...”

“You’ll take it.” Richard Carter chewed. Swallowed. “You’ll thank me in ten years.”

“Richard,” Helen said softly.

“What? I’m proud of him.” He looked at Sophie and his face softened, very slightly. “We’re all very proud of him. Aren’t we, Sophie?”

“So proud,” Sophie said, and squeezed Nate’s hand under the table. She was glowing. She had been glowing all day.

“And you two.” Richard leaned back in his chair. “Two years now, isn’t it? Helen and I got engaged when I was twenty-two. Best decision I ever made.” He raised his glass toward them with something that was almost a wink. “Just saying. Nobody’s getting any younger.”

Sophie went pink and laughed and hid her face against Nate’s shoulder. Helen said “Richard!” in a scandalized voice that wasn’t really scandalized at all. Everyone at the table was smiling.

Nate smiled too. He didn’t know how. His face was doing it without him.

“Excuse me,” he said. “Bathroom.”

The men’s room at Marlowe’s was all black marble and soft lighting and little rolled towels in a basket. Nate locked himself in a stall, sat down on the closed lid, and put his head between his knees.

He couldn’t breathe. That was the strange thing. He had just rowed two thousand meters flat out and won by four-tenths of a second, and he’d still been able to breathe. Now his lungs had forgotten how.

He took out his phone with shaking hands.

The answer came almost immediately.

Three dots. Then:

Nate stared at the screen. Then he closed his eyes and breathed. In, two, three, four. Hold. Out. Catch, drive, finish, recover.

A long pause. The dots appeared and disappeared twice.

He knocked at 11:20 p.m.

Priya opened the door. She was in pajamas, glasses on, a book in one hand. She looked at Nate standing in the hallway: still in the navy shirt, his coat open, his tie stuffed in the pocket, his face so pale and lost that he looked about twelve.

For a second she didn’t say anything. Then she sighed, stepped back into the room, grabbed her pillow, her phone and her charger, and walked past him into the corridor.

“Nina’s,” she said to Elliot over her shoulder. Then, to Nate, quieter, almost gently: “Congratulations on the race.”

The door closed behind her.

Nate stood in the middle of the room. Elliot was sitting on his bed in a T-shirt and boxer briefs, the fairy lights on, a mug of tea going cold on the shelf.

“Hey,” Elliot said softly.

“I can’t do it,” Nate said. His voice was hollow. “I sat there all night and listened to them plan my whole life. Internship. Nationals. Engagement. Sophie’s mom booked a hotel for December. My mom cried at the finish line. And the whole time all I could think about was you, standing under that stupid tree.” He laughed, and it turned into something else halfway through. “I looked for you. After the race. Before anyone else. I didn’t even think about it.”

“I know,” Elliot said. “I saw.”

“My dad saw too, I think.” Nate rubbed his face. “He didn’t say anything. But he looked at me at dinner like he was trying to work something out.”

Elliot got up, crossed the room, and took Nate’s face in both hands.

“Hey,” he said. “Look at me. You don’t have to figure it all out tonight. Tonight you won a race. Tonight you’re here. That’s all.”

Nate looked at him. His eyes were wet.

“Can I just...” he whispered. “Can I just stay? The whole night. I’ve never stayed the whole night.”

“Yeah,” Elliot said. “You can stay.”

In the soft glow of the fairy lights, Elliot unbuttoned Nate’s shirt with deliberate slowness, each button a ritual undoing of armor Nate had worn all day - through his victory, his parents’ pressure, and the silent plea that brought him here. The navy cotton fell open to reveal tanned skin taut over defined muscles, a testament to hours logged in the rowing shell. Elliot’s fingers brushed Nate’s neck, feeling the tension there, and he leaned in to press a soft kiss at the base of his throat.

Nate stood still, eyes closed, letting Elliot undress him like one might unwrap a gift. The shirt slipped off his shoulders, pooling on the floor. Elliot opened Nate’s belt, the leather cool under his fingertips, before pushing the trousers down over lean hips and powerful thighs. They puddled around Nate’s ankles, and he stepped out of them, standing now in only black boxer briefs.

Elliot noticed the new blisters on Nate’s palms, raw from gripping the oar through two thousand meters of sheer willpower. He took each hand gently, turning them over to press a soft kiss to the tender skin. Nate’s breath hitched at the contact, eyes fluttering open to meet Elliot’s gaze.

Next, Elliot reached for Nate’s boxer briefs, hooking his thumbs under the elastic band. But he paused, looking up at Nate with a question in his green eyes. Nate nodded, giving permission, and Elliot tugged them down, letting Nate step out of those too.

Elliot pulled his own T-shirt over his head and let his boxer briefs fall, and now, finally, they stood naked before each other, bathed in the warm orange light seeping through the window. Elliot’s heart pounded in his chest, not just from desire but from something deeper, something he’d been feeling for weeks but had yet to put into words. He reached for Nate’s hand, leading him towards the narrow bed pushed against the wall.

They climbed under the duvet together, Nate’s body fitting perfectly against Elliot’s as they lay down together. Nate’s head rested on Elliot’s chest, his breath warm on Elliot’s skin. For long minutes, they simply lay there, skin to skin, heat radiating between them. Elliot stroked Nate’s back in slow circles, feeling the tension gradually ebb away under his touch.

Nate’s body was a map of exhaustion and triumph - the sore muscles in his shoulders and back from hours spent training and racing, the chafed palms, the faint scent of river water still clinging to his skin. Elliot pressed kisses to Nate’s temple, breathed him in, and whispered, “You’re here now,” as if saying it aloud could chase away the ghosts of earlier conversations and unspoken fears.

Nate’s heartbeat thudded steadily against Elliot’s ribs, syncing with his own until they beat as one. The dorm was quiet around them, most residents asleep after a day filled with cheers and celebrations. Only the distant hum of traffic and the occasional hoot of an owl penetrated their little bubble.

Slowly, deliberately, Nate began to trace patterns on Elliot’s chest, his fingers calloused from rowing, yet gentle. The movement was soothing, lulling Elliot into a state of relaxed awareness. He felt every brush of Nate’s skin, every hitch in his breath.

Then Nate lifted his head, finding Elliot’s mouth in the dim light. Their lips met softly at first, then deeper, more urgent. Elliot could taste the remnants of their dinner on Nate’s tongue - wine, garlic, the faint tang of fear and adrenaline. He deepened the kiss, wanting to consume it all.

As they kissed, their bodies responded, pressing against each other with growing urgency. Elliot felt Nate harden against his thigh, the thick length of him pressing hot against Elliot’s skin. His own erection pulsed, nestling against Nate’s hip.

Elliot broke away from their kiss, breath ragged, and whispered, “Let me take care of you tonight.” He pushed gently at Nate’s shoulder until he rolled onto his back, then pulled the duvet down to reveal him fully.

But Nate caught his wrist and pulled him back up until they were face to face. “Together,” he whispered. “Please. I want to see you.” Their legs tangled beneath the duvet. Their foreheads pressed together, breath mingling as their eyes searched each other’s depths. The soft glow of the fairy lights danced on Nate’s skin, casting shadows that emphasized every plane and curve.

Elliot reached between them, wrapping his long fingers around Nate’s thickness. He felt the pulse of life there, the heat radiating from him like a brand. Nate was big, bigger than average, with prominent veins along his shaft that Elliot traced gently. His hand fit snugly around Nate, thumb brushing over the broad, wet head, making Nate gasp.

Nate mirrored his actions, his blistered fingers wrapping around Elliot’s length. The sensation was exquisite - Nate’s touch rough yet tender, sending jolts of pleasure up Elliot’s spine. He felt the vein on the underside of his cock throb under Nate’s exploration, the head swelling and darkening with need.

They moved together, hands stroking in sync, their bodies learning each other’s rhythm. The duvet rustled with their movements, the scent of their arousal mingling with the faint smell of old books and detergent from Elliot’s room. Their breaths came in short pants, synchronizing as they climbed towards release.

Elliot looked into Nate’s eyes, saw the raw emotion there - fear, hope, love. It mirrored his own feelings, a whirlwind of sensation that threatened to overwhelm him. He felt tears prick at the corners of his eyes, but he blinked them away, not wanting to break this moment.

“I think I’m falling in love with you,” Nate whispered, his voice barely audible over their ragged breaths.

Elliot’s heart stuttered, then pounded wildly against his ribs. He wanted to say it back, wanted to shout it from the rooftops, but the words caught in his throat, held captive by the sheer magnitude of what he felt.

Instead, he leaned in, capturing Nate’s mouth in a searing kiss. Their hands continued to move, strokes long and sure, building pressure at the base of their spines. Elliot could feel Nate’s body tensing, hear the hitch in his breath as they neared the edge.

Together, they tumbled over. Elliot felt Nate’s release first - hot, thick spurts coating his hand, spilling over onto his stomach. The sensation pushed him over the edge, and he came with a moan muffled against Nate’s lips. His own orgasm pulsed through him, waves of pleasure cresting one after another, leaving him breathless and reeling.

They stayed locked together, bodies trembling, as their orgasms subsided. Cum mixed between them, sticky and warm on their stomachs, a testament to their shared release. Elliot reached up, brushing a tear from Nate’s cheek with his thumb before bringing it to his lips, tasting the salt there.

Nate’s eyes fluttered open, meeting Elliot’s gaze. “Me too,” Elliot whispered finally, his voice hoarse with emotion. “For a while now.”

A slow smile spread across Nate’s face, chasing away the lingering shadows of doubt and fear. He leaned in, kissing Elliot softly before resting his head on Elliot’s chest, listening to his heartbeat.

Elliot reached for the tissues on the shelf above his bed, cleaning them both up with gentle efficiency. Then he pulled Nate close again, tucking him under his chin. “Sleep now,” he murmured, stroking Nate’s hair until his breath evened out and he drifted off to sleep.

Elliot lay awake for a long time afterwards, Nate’s arm heavy across his chest, watching the orange light on the ceiling.

He stayed.

Nate’s phone woke them at 8:14 the next morning.

It buzzed on the floor, somewhere in the pocket of the navy trousers, and kept buzzing, and stopped, and started again. Nate groaned into Elliot’s neck. Elliot blinked at the grey light in the window and, for one perfect, sleepy second, didn’t remember anything except that Nate was warm and heavy and here.

Then Nate sat up so fast the whole bed shook, and fished the trousers off the floor, and pulled out the phone, and Elliot watched the color drain out of his face.

“Nate?”

Nate didn’t answer. He just turned the screen so that Elliot could see.

Seven missed calls.

Nate stared at the phone in his hand. Outside, somewhere in the building, a door slammed and someone laughed, the way they always did.

“Elliot,” Nate said, and his voice was very small. “What do I tell her?”

Leave a comment

Elliot told her. Not every detail. Some things were only his and Nate’s, and Priya seemed to understand that without being told. But he told her about the notebook, and the talk, and the way Nate had said I’m here, and the way he had laughed afterward, helplessly, with his face in Elliot’s neck.

When he finished, Priya was quiet for a long moment.

“He kissed you in the doorway,” she said finally. “Where people could see.”

“Yeah.”

“Huh.” She took a sip of coffee. “That’s either really brave or really stupid.”

“Can’t it be both?”

“With boys like that, it’s usually both.” She put the mug down and looked at him over her glasses, and her face softened. “You look happy, Ell. Like, actually happy. I haven’t seen you like this since before the breakup.”

“I am happy,” Elliot said, and was surprised to find it was true.

“Okay.” Priya nodded slowly. “Then I’m happy for you. And I’m going to keep my mouth shut. Mostly.” She pointed at him. “But if he hurts you, I’m going to key his car.”

“He’d probably deserve it.”

“I know,” said Priya. “That’s what worries me.”

They never talked about the rules. They just had them.

The rules were: never in public. Never in Nate’s dorm, where the walls were thin and Marcus lived two doors down. Never text after midnight, because Sophie sometimes slept over and Nate’s phone lit up the whole room. Never say Sophie’s name in Elliot’s room. Never say what are we.

Tuesdays: second row, left side. A coffee on Elliot’s desk, black. Nate’s knee against his under the desk for fifty minutes. Notes in the margins of Elliot’s notebook that had nothing to do with behavioral economics.

you look nice today

It’s the same hoodie I wore last week.

still

Thursdays: Elliot’s room, seven o’clock. Priya at Nina’s. The project, in theory.

They actually worked, which surprised both of them. The outline turned into a draft. The draft turned into eleven pages, then fourteen. Nate built a spreadsheet of race times from his freshman year so detailed that Elliot laughed out loud when he saw it, and Nate went red and said “What? I like numbers,” and Elliot kissed him in the middle of the sentence, because he couldn’t not.

And in between, the stolen moments. Those were the ones Elliot would remember later, long after he’d forgotten what the project was even about.

On the first Wednesday, in the library, on the fourth floor where nobody ever went: the old economics journals, rows of dusty bound volumes from the seventies, a narrow aisle between two tall shelves. Nate came round the corner while Elliot was looking for a book, glanced both ways down the aisle, took the book out of Elliot’s hands and put it back on the shelf, and kissed him against the bound volumes of the Journal of Political Economy, quick and hard and grinning. Then he walked away without a word, and Elliot stood there for five minutes with his heart racing, holding a book he couldn’t remember picking up again.

On the second Monday: a paper cup on the bench outside the lecture hall, with a pretzel balanced on the lid and E written on the side in messy, slanted handwriting.

On the second Tuesday: Nate’s hand finding Elliot’s under the desk in the middle of Whitcombe’s lecture on hyperbolic discounting, their fingers threading together and staying that way, hidden, for forty minutes, until Elliot’s palm was damp and he didn’t care.

The first Thursday was different from the one before. Less fear. More hunger.

Nate came in at 7:02 with rain in his hair and closed the door with his back and didn’t even take his jacket off before he kissed Elliot, and they didn’t open the laptop for an hour.

Later, lying in the warm tangle of Elliot’s narrow bed, Nate traced a slow line down Elliot’s stomach with one finger and said, very quietly, without looking at him: “Can I ask you something embarrassing?”

“Always.”

“What’s... what does it feel like? When a guy...” Nate’s face was red. He made a small, hopeless gesture. “You know. With his mouth.”

Elliot propped himself up on one elbow and looked at him. Nate was staring at the ceiling, very determinedly, the way he had when he’d asked When did you know?

“Sophie doesn’t,” Nate said to the ceiling. “Like it. Doing that. Which is fine. Totally fine. I never... I just wondered. If it’s different.”

Elliot smiled slowly.

“I could show you,” he said. “If you want.”

Nate turned his head and looked at him, and swallowed hard.

“Yeah,” he said. His voice cracked. “Yeah. I want.”

Elliot’s lips found Nate’s, a soft press, a question. He moved down, tasting skin, mapping Nate’s body with his mouth. Nate’s neck, salty and hot; his chest, firm and smooth; the fading bruise on his ribs, a tender kiss to soothe old pain. His stomach quivered under Elliot’s lips, muscles taut as he traced the lines. Nate was hard already, breath coming fast.

Elliot pushed the duvet away, settling between Nate’s legs. He looked up, green eyes meeting brown. “Still want this?” His voice was low, barely above a whisper.

Nate nodded, throat working as he swallowed. Words seemed beyond him.

Elliot leaned in, close enough to feel Nate’s heat on his lips. Nate’s cock rose, thick and long, veins prominent along the shaft. It curved slightly to the right, the broad pink head slick with precum. Elliot took a moment, drinking in the sight, before he touched, tasting the saltiness of Nate’s skin.

He started slow, teasing. His tongue flicked out, circling the head, licking away the bead of fluid. Nate gasped, hips jerking up. Elliot flattened his tongue, running it down the shaft, feeling the pulse under the skin. He cupped Nate’s balls, heavy and tight, rolling them gently in his palm.

Then he took Nate into his mouth, just the head at first, sucking softly. Nate’s hands fisted the sheets, a strangled noise escaping him. Elliot looked up, saw Nate’s face flushed, eyes closed, and felt a surge of power. He took more, using his tongue to press against the underside, feeling the prominent vein.

He found a rhythm, taking Nate deep, then pulling back, swirling his tongue around the head. His hand worked in time with his mouth, stroking what he couldn’t take in, twisting at the base. Nate’s cock was big, but Elliot handled it with ease, saliva glistening as he worked.

Nate gripped the sheets, then tentatively reached for Elliot, fingers tangling in his blond curls. He didn’t push or pull, just held on, gentle permission sought and given. Nate bit his forearm, muffling a cry as Elliot took him deep, humming around his cock.

“Elliot,” Nate panted, broken, breathless. “Elliot, I’m... I’m going to...”

Elliot didn’t stop. He wanted to taste Nate, wanted to give him this pleasure he’d never had before. Nate came with a shudder, back arching off the bed, cock pulsing in Elliot’s mouth. Elliot swallowed, feeling Nate’s release hot and thick.

He moved up, lying beside Nate. Nate stared at the ceiling, chest heaving, brown eyes wide. “Okay,” he said finally, voice hoarse. “Yeah. It’s different.”

Elliot laughed softly, pressing a kiss to his shoulder. “I told you.”

Nate turned to him, hand sliding down Elliot’s stomach, finding his hard cock. He stroked it once, twice, before leaning in for a kiss. His hand worked Elliot’s length, thumb swirling over the head, spreading precome. Elliot kissed him back, deep and hungry, hips pumping into Nate’s fist.

He came with a groan, burying his face in Nate’s neck. Nate kept stroking, drawing out his pleasure until Elliot had to push his hand away, too sensitive.

“Fuck,” Elliot muttered, collapsing onto the bed.

Nate pulled him close, chuckling. “Yeah,” he agreed, and kissed him once more.

Nate left at eleven that night, later than ever before. At the door, he kissed Elliot once more, slow and lingering, and said against his mouth: “I’m going to be thinking about that for the rest of my life.”

“Good,” said Elliot.

Being with Sophie had always been easy. That was the thing Nate couldn’t get out of his head. It had always been so easy.

Now it was like walking through a house he’d lived in for two years and suddenly noticing that every door was a little too narrow and every ceiling a little too low.

On the Tuesday after the first Thursday, she came over with Thai takeaway and a film, the way she always did, and Nate said, “Soph, I’ve got practice at six. Halloran’s got us doing double sessions before the regatta. I’m going to be dead.”

“So I’ll be quiet,” Sophie said, smiling, already unwrapping the spring rolls. “You won’t even know I’m here.”

She stayed. She fell asleep on his chest halfway through the film, the way she always did, and Nate lay awake under her warm, familiar weight and watched the streetlight on the ceiling and thought about the fourth floor of the library.

On the second Saturday, they went out for dinner with her friends: Jess, Amira, Jess’s boyfriend Tom, who talked about crypto for forty minutes. Nate laughed in the right places. He held Sophie’s hand on top of the table. Under the table, his phone buzzed against his thigh, and he looked down without thinking.

Nate bit down on a smile. Not quickly enough.

“Okay, who’s that?” Sophie said, leaning into his shoulder, grinning. “Who’s making you smile like that?”

His heart stopped. Then started again, too fast.

“Elliot,” he said. “Project stuff. Whitcombe wants a draft by Friday.”

“Elliot!” Sophie lit up. “Tell him I said hi. Oh my God, you two are so cute. You’re like best friends now.” She turned to Jess. “Nate never had friends outside the team. Like, ever. And now he’s got this sweet, nerdy econ boy who’s literally saving his grades.”

“Bromance,” said Jess, approvingly.

“Total bromance,” said Sophie, and kissed Nate’s cheek.

Nate put the phone face down on his thigh and didn’t look at it again for the rest of the night. He drank three glasses of wine he didn’t want. When they walked home, Sophie swung their joined hands between them and talked about the wedding, about the hotel, about the ocean view and the dress she’d already bought, and Nate said “Yeah” and “That sounds amazing” and “Can’t wait,” and every word tasted like a lie, because it was.

Elliot saw them on the second Monday, in the dining hall.

He was in line for pasta with Priya when the door opened and Nate came in with Sophie, and Marcus, and Dev, and two girls Elliot didn’t know. Sophie was holding Nate’s hand. She said something, and he laughed and pulled her into his side, and she reached up and pushed his damp hair out of his eyes in a gesture so easy and so intimate that Elliot felt it physically, like a door slammed on his fingers.

Nate’s eyes swept across the room. They passed over Elliot without stopping. Not cold. Just... nothing. A face in a crowd.

Never in public, Elliot reminded himself. That’s the rule. You agreed to the rule.

“Ell,” Priya said quietly next to him. “You okay?”

“Yeah,” Elliot said. “Totally.”

He took his pasta and sat with his back to their table. He ate maybe four bites.

Three minutes later, his phone buzzed.

Then:

Elliot read it twice. Then he put the phone face down on the table, the way they both did now, and pushed his plate away.

Across the table, Priya didn’t say anything. She just reached over and stole one of his breadsticks, and kept her foot pressed against his under the table until they left.

On the second Wednesday, Nate picked him up at nine p.m. in his car outside the library.

“I want to show you something,” was all he said.

The car was an old dark blue hatchback with a cracked dashboard, a rowing-club air freshener that had long since stopped smelling of anything, and a back seat full of gym bags and empty water bottles. It smelled of Nate: soap, sweat and the river. Nate drove with one hand on the wheel and the other resting on the gear stick, and after a while Elliot put his hand on top of it, and Nate turned his hand over and laced their fingers together and drove like that, one-handed, through the dark.

They drove down the hill, past the Anchor, along the river road until the streetlights ended. Then down a narrow gravel lane between dark trees, and into a small empty parking area behind a long, low building.

“The boathouse,” Nate said, and switched off the engine.

It was quiet. The kind of quiet you never got on campus. In front of them, through the windscreen, the river was black and wide and moving, with the lights of the bridge far away upstream. A single security light on the corner of the boathouse threw a pale circle onto the gravel, and everything else was dark. The rain had stopped. Drops still fell from the trees onto the roof of the car, one by one, like a slow clock.

“This is where I come,” Nate said. “When I can’t think. Before practice, sometimes, at five in the morning. Nobody’s ever here.”

“It’s beautiful,” Elliot said, and meant it.

They sat in the dark for a while, hands still joined between the seats.

“The regatta’s next Saturday,” Nate said eventually. “My dad’s coming. My mom too. Halloran put me in the first boat for the trial.” He laughed, short and joyless. “I’ve wanted that since I was twelve. And now all I can think is: what if my dad looks at me and just... knows?”

“Knows what?”

“That something’s different.” Nate rubbed his thumb over Elliot’s knuckles. “He always knows. He knew when I had a cold before I did. He knew when I quit piano before I told anyone.”

Elliot looked at him in the faint light. At the profile of his face against the window. At the small pale scar through his eyebrow.

“Can I ask you something?” Elliot said.

“Sure.”

“Where’s that from?” He reached across and touched the scar, very lightly, with one fingertip.

Nate was quiet for a long time.

“I was twelve,” he said finally. “We were at the lake. There was a storm coming, a real one, black clouds, the whole thing. I wanted to go in. Dad said a real rower doesn’t go in because of a little weather.” He shrugged. “I capsized. Hit my head on the rigger on the way down. Eleven stitches. He drove me to the hospital and the whole way he talked about what I did wrong with my blade work.”

Elliot didn’t say anything. There wasn’t anything to say. He just undid his seatbelt, leaned across the gear stick, and pressed his lips very gently against the scar.

Nate closed his eyes. His breath shook.

“Nobody’s ever done that,” he whispered.

“Done what?”

“Asked.”

He turned his head and kissed Elliot, and it wasn’t gentle, and it wasn’t careful. It was the kiss of someone who had been holding something in for years and had finally found a place to put it down.

“Back seat,” Nate said against his mouth, breathless. “I’ll move the bags. I want... Elliot, I want to try. What you did. For you.” His face burned, even in the dark. “I’ve been thinking about it all week. I’ll probably be terrible.”

Elliot laughed shakily against his lips. “You won’t be terrible.”

“I might be really terrible.”

“Then we’ll practice,” said Elliot.

Elliot’s heart hammered as he clambered into the back seat of Nate’s car, their shoulders bumping and heads almost knocking together in their shared clumsiness. They laughed, breathless and exhilarated, the dim light from the boathouse casting long shadows across Nate’s face. Elliot watched him, this boy who was quickly becoming his world, as Nate leaned over to pull him onto the seat, their bodies aligning perfectly.

The cold glass of the window pressed against Elliot’s back, a stark contrast to the warmth radiating off Nate’s body. He could still feel the echo of Nate’s story, the tender way he’d kissed the scar on Nate’s eyebrow just moments ago. It was like a key had turned in a lock, unlocking something deep within him. He was falling in love with Nate Carter, and it both terrified and thrilled him.

Nate’s fingers fumbled with the buttons of Elliot’s shirt, his knuckles brushing against Elliot’s chest with each one he undid. Goosebumps prickled across Elliot’s skin, not just from the cold air but from Nate’s touch. Each scrape of Nate’s stubble against his stomach sent a jolt straight to his groin. His heartbeat echoed in his ears, his muscles tensing as Nate’s lips trailed lower and lower.

The windows started to fog up, their breaths misting the cool glass as Nate hooked his fingers into Elliot’s jeans. He pulled them down over Elliot’s hips, along with his boxer briefs, leaving him bare to the chilly air. Elliot shifted in the narrow space, the seat creaking softly beneath him.

Nate knelt awkwardly in the footwell between Elliot’s legs, bumping his elbow on the door and swearing quietly under his breath. They both stifled laughter as Nate shook out his hand, his eyes meeting Elliot’s before dropping to Elliot’s erect penis.

Elliot felt a rush of vulnerability, exposed and laid bare in more ways than one. He wanted this, wanted Nate so much it hurt. He watched as Nate swallowed hard, his Adam’s apple bobbing, and licked his lips nervously. He’s doing this for me, Elliot thought, a surge of tenderness welling up inside him.

“Tell me if I do it wrong,” Nate whispered, his voice barely audible over the soft patter of raindrops on the car roof.

Elliot nodded, his throat too tight to speak. He reached down and gently guided Nate’s head closer, his fingers tangling in Nate’s dark hair. Oh God, Elliot thought as Nate leaned in, his warm breath ghosting across Elliot’s skin before everything else faded away.

Nate started slowly, his mouth tentative and uncertain. He was clumsy at first, too fast, his teeth catching unexpectedly, making Elliot flinch. But Nate was learning, his tongue finding the right rhythm, his hand following suit as he wrapped it around the base of Elliot’s cock.

“Slower,” Elliot guided him, his voice barely above a whisper. “Use your hand too... like that.” He held onto the headrest with one hand, the other buried in Nate’s hair, guiding him gently.

Elliot could feel every movement acutely, each flick of Nate’s tongue sending sparks shooting up his spine. Amusement bubbled up inside him as Nate gagged when he tried to take too much, but it was quickly replaced by a surge of tenderness. This was Nate Carter, the boy who’d never done this before, doing it for him.

Nate looked up at Elliot, his dark eyes filled with determination, and Elliot felt his heart stutter. He’s beautiful, he thought, the emotion welling up inside him so strong it was almost overwhelming.

Elliot watched as Nate found his stride, his mouth and hand working in tandem, each stroke pushing him closer to the edge. The heat gathered low in his body, his thighs starting to tremble, his toes curling in his shoes. His breath came in ragged gasps, fogging up the window next to his face.

His thoughts began to unravel, fragments of words and phrases floating through his mind until only one remained: Nate. He was close, so close he could taste it. “Nate,” he panted, trying to pull him away by the hair. But Nate didn’t let him, holding his hips down instead.

The moment he tipped over the edge, Elliot saw stars. His back arched off the door, a low moan tearing from his throat as waves of pleasure crashed over him. I love you. The words almost escaped him, but he bit them back at the last second, his teeth sinking into his lower lip until he tasted copper.

His vision went white, his body convulsing with each pulse, every muscle taut and then releasing in a cascade of sensation. He was left trembling and oversensitive, his heart racing like it had just finished a mile-long swim. The cold air on his damp skin was a shock, the raindrops on the roof sounding incredibly loud in the sudden quiet.

Nate pulled back, coughing slightly before letting out a small laugh. He wiped the back of his hand across his mouth, looking both proud and embarrassed as he met Elliot’s gaze. Something huge swelled in Elliot’s chest, threatening to overflow.

Elliot couldn’t speak. Nate climbed back up onto the seat, half sprawling over him. They kissed, slow and deep, and Elliot could taste himself on Nate’s lips. When they broke apart, they were both smiling, their foreheads leaning against each other.

“Was that okay?” Nate asked, his voice barely above a whisper. “Be honest.”

Elliot looked at the windows, every one completely fogged up. Then he looked back at Nate, this boy who was stealing his heart one clumsy, sweet gesture at a time. “Nate. Look at the windows,” he said, and they both turned to look and burst out laughing.

Nate grinned, shifting slightly until Elliot could feel how hard he was through his jeans. He reached down, popping the button and sliding the zipper down slowly, deliberately. Nate’s breath hitched as Elliot wrapped his hand around him, feeling the heat, the size, the curve.

“Elliot,” Nate gasped, burying his face in Elliot’s neck as Elliot began to stroke him. His body tensed above Elliot, his grip on Elliot’s shoulder tightening as he started to move with Elliot’s hand. His breath was hot against Elliot’s neck, his name a whispered mantra on Nate’s lips.

Elliot felt every pulse, every tremble, every inch of Nate’s body pressed against his own. He held on tight, his heart pounding in sync with Nate’s. And when Nate finally came, it was with a low moan against Elliot’s neck, his body shuddering and then going limp.

They stayed like that for a moment, their bodies entwined, their hearts slowly returning to normal. Elliot looked at the fogged-up windows, feeling a sense of satisfaction unlike any he’d ever known. I’m in so much trouble, he thought. But God, it felt good.

Nate drove him back to campus just after eleven, the heater on full blast, the windows still clearing slowly from the edges inward. He stopped two streets away from Elliot’s dorm, in the dark between two streetlights, the way they always did now.

Before Elliot got out, Nate caught his wrist.

“Elliot,” he said. “I...”

He stopped. Elliot waited, his heart suddenly loud.

“Thank you,” Nate said finally. “For asking. About the scar.”

It wasn’t what he’d been going to say. They both knew it. But Elliot just nodded, and squeezed his hand, and got out of the car into the cold.

He watched the red taillights all the way down the street until they turned the corner.

He was brushing his teeth when his phone buzzed on the edge of the sink. He picked it up with the toothbrush still in his mouth, smiling, expecting Nate.

It wasn’t Nate.

It was a number he didn’t have saved.

Elliot stopped brushing.

A second message arrived while he was still staring at the first.

And then a third:

Elliot stood very still in the bright, empty bathroom, toothpaste foam in his mouth, the phone cold in his hand.

In the mirror, a guy with blond curls and a fogged-up heart looked back at him, and for the first time since the urinals, he had absolutely no idea what to do.

Leave a comment

That was how it felt, anyway. Four beers, two hours of sleep, and Coach Halloran’s voice booming across the water through a megaphone from the launch: “Carter! You’re rushing the slide! Again! Are you rowing or are you having a nervous breakdown?”

Both,

Read more

Elliot heard him come in at 8:58, heard the familiar sneakers on the wooden steps, and heard them keep going, past the second row, up and up, until they stopped somewhere near the top where Marcus and Dev always sat. A burst of laughter. Someone slapping someone’s back.

Elliot didn’t turn around. He wrote the date at the …

Read more

He told himself it was because he wanted a good seat. He told himself a lot of things on the walk across campus, most of them along the lines of: He won’t sit near you. He’ll sit at the back with his teammates. He said “nothing happened” and he meant it, and you should be grateful, because that’s the version of this where nobody gets hurt.

He sat down in the second row on the left side, took out his notebook, and wrote the date at the top of the page very neatly.

At 8:52 the door at the back opened.

Elliot didn’t turn around. He didn’t need to. He heard the sneakers on the old wooden steps, unhurried this time, and he heard them stop at the second row, and then a bag landed on the floor and someone dropped into the seat right next to him. Not across the aisle. Next to him.

“Hey,” Nate said.

Elliot looked at him. Nate was looking straight ahead at the empty projector screen, his jaw tight, a coffee cup in each hand. Without turning his head, he held one of the cups out sideways.

“I didn’t know how you take it,” he said. “So it’s just black. There’s sugar in my bag if you - ”

“Black is fine,” Elliot said. His voice did something embarrassing in the middle of the sentence. He took the cup. Their fingers didn’t touch, but it was close. “Thanks.”

“Sure.”

They sat there, side by side, both staring at a blank screen and drinking coffee as if it required their full concentration. The hall slowly filled up around them. Somewhere behind them, one of Nate’s teammates called his name, and Nate lifted a hand without looking back.

“You’re early,” Elliot said eventually.

“Yeah.” Nate turned the cup in his hands. “Figured I’d try it. See what all the fuss is about.”

“And?”

The corner of Nate’s mouth twitched. “Too early to tell.”

Professor Whitcombe arrived at nine exactly, and at 9:03 she ruined Elliot’s life.

“Midterm projects,” she announced, clicking to a slide covered in bullet points. “Pairs. Twenty-page analysis of a real-world decision-making failure of your choice. Due the week before Christmas. You will choose your own partners, because I am not your mother, and I will hear no complaints about who did the work, because I am also not your therapist.” She looked up over her glasses. “You have until Thursday to email me your pairs.”

The room erupted into murmuring and the frantic eye contact of two hundred students trying to secure a partner who would actually do the reading. Elliot looked down at his notebook. He usually worked with Mira from his tutorial group. Mira was organized and terrifying and had never once been late.

Next to him, Nate cleared his throat.

“So,” he said. “Do you, uh. Have someone?”

Elliot turned his head slowly.

Nate was finally looking at him. Up close, in daylight, he looked like he’d slept badly: faint shadows under his eyes, a small cut on his chin from shaving too fast. He was fiddling with the lid of his coffee cup, pressing the little tab in and out, in and out.

“Your teammates,” Elliot said. “Don’t they -”

“Marcus and Dev are working together. They’ll write about some sports thing. Probably the time our coach bet his car on a Super Bowl game.” Nate shrugged. “And I’m, honestly, I’m not great at this class. I’m good at the math part. I’m bad at the writing part. You look like you’re good at the writing part.”

“I look like I’m good at writing?”

“You take notes in full sentences,” Nate said. “With semicolons. I saw.”

Elliot laughed before he could stop himself, a short, startled sound. Nate’s face did that thing again, that sudden opening up, like a window being pushed wide.

Don’t, Elliot told himself. This is a terrible idea. You’ll spend ten weeks sitting next to him, and he’ll be nice to you, and he’ll go home to Sophie every night, and you’ll be wrecked by Christmas.

“Okay,” Elliot said. “Yeah. Let’s do it.”

They met for the first time on Thursday afternoon in the library, at a table on the third floor by the window, which Elliot had chosen precisely because it was public and well-lit and absolutely not romantic in any way.

It was fine. It was more than fine. Nate showed up on time with a bag of pretzels and a list of ideas scribbled on the back of a gym timetable, and most of them were bad, but one of them was good. Really good: a decision-making failure inside a university rowing program, a whole season thrown away because a coach had refused to change a losing strategy he’d already sunk too much into.

“Sunk cost fallacy,” Elliot said, sitting up. “That’s perfect. That’s exactly the chapter we just did.”

“I lived through it,” Nate said. “Freshman year. Worst six months of my life. He made us row the same race plan nine times in a row and we lost all nine. My dad still brings it up.”

“Your dad?”

Nate’s shoulders went a little stiff. “He rowed too. Back in the day. National level.” He picked at the pretzel bag. “He’s got a lot of opinions about how things are supposed to go. For me, I mean. Rowing. Business degree. Nice girlfriend. Big wedding, eventually.” He said the last part lightly, like a joke, but he didn’t smile.

Elliot didn’t know what to say to that, so he didn’t say anything. He just nodded, and after a moment Nate looked up and something in his face eased, as if not being answered had been exactly what he needed.

They worked for three hours. At some point Elliot realized that the sun had gone down outside the window and he had laughed more that afternoon than in the whole previous month.

Sophie found them at 6:15.

Elliot recognized her immediately from the photo on Nate’s phone: blonde, bright, a scarf wrapped twice around her neck. She came up behind Nate and put her hands over his eyes, and Nate jumped so hard that his knee hit the underside of the table.

“Guess who,” she said.

“Jesus, Soph.”

She laughed and kissed the top of his head, then turned to Elliot with a wide, warm smile and stuck out her hand. “Hi! You must be the econ genius. I’m Sophie. Nate says you’re going to save his GPA.”

“Elliot,” Elliot said, and shook her hand. Her grip was firm and friendly. “I don’t know about genius.”

“He’s being modest,” Nate said, rubbing his knee. He wasn’t looking at either of them.

“Well, thank you anyway,” Sophie said, perching on the arm of Nate’s chair and stealing a pretzel. “Seriously. He’s been so stressed about this class. You should come out with us sometime! A bunch of us go to the Anchor on Fridays. Bring whoever you want.”

She was lovely. That was the worst part. She was funny and kind and completely, obviously sincere, and when she slid her arm around Nate’s shoulders he leaned into it out of what looked like pure habit, and Elliot felt something small and ugly twist inside his chest and was immediately ashamed of it.

“Maybe,” Elliot said. “Thanks.”

When they left, Sophie waved from the stairs. Nate didn’t look back. But at 6:40, while Elliot was packing up, his phone buzzed with a message from a number he didn’t have saved.

And then, a minute later:

Elliot saved the number. He typed and deleted three different replies. In the end he sent:

The answer came back in under ten seconds.

That night, Priya was at her girlfriend’s place, and the room was dark and quiet and far too empty.

Elliot lay on his bed with his phone on his chest and read the messages again. Then again. Thanks for today. Really. It was nothing. It was what anyone would write to a project partner. He knew that.

He also knew how Nate had looked at him across the table when he’d laughed.

Elliot set his phone aside, its screen casting a faint glow on the ceiling before it faded to black. The room was bathed in an orangey light from outside, the world beyond their little dorm hushed and still. He closed his eyes, thoughts drifting like leaves on water.

Nate’s knee had pressed against his under the table that afternoon, firm and warm, for the whole last hour, and neither of them had moved away. A simple touch, yet it had sent a jolt through him. Nate’s laugh echoed in his mind, deep and rumbling, filling the quiet space between them. The coffee Nate had brought him on Tuesday, black, because he hadn’t known how Elliot took it.

His thoughts slid like silk to the urinals, to the thick, veined length of Nate’s cock, curving slightly to the right. He remembered the way Nate had stared, how his own dick had hardened in response, and how Nate hadn’t been able to flee fast enough when he’d noticed Elliot’s reaction.

The locker room flashed into mind - Nate in a towel, water running down his tanned skin, the white terrycloth tenting as Nate’s cock strained against it. The memory made Elliot’s own dick twitch, and he slipped his hand under the waistband of his boxers, wrapping long fingers around himself.

He stroked slowly, his grip tight but not too rough. His mind filled with images of Nate - Nate on his knees in front of him, Nate’s mouth wrapped around him, Nate’s cock in his own hand as they leaned against opposite walls of the shower, the steamy air thick between them.

In his fantasy, Nate was here now, lying next to him in the dim light. He could almost feel Nate’s breath on his neck, hear Nate’s heartbeat echoing in his chest. Nate kissed him, their lips meeting in a soft, slow dance. Elliot whimpered into Nate’s mouth as Nate’s hand slid down into his boxers, wrapping around him.

“Elliot,” Nate whispered against his ear, voice low and rough. The sound of his name on Nate’s lips sent a shiver down his spine. He arched into Nate’s touch, fucking into his fist as Nate’s thumb brushed over the head of his dick.

His orgasm hit him like a wave, sudden and intense. His cock pulsed in Nate’s hand, spilling warmth onto his stomach. He gasped, body tensing as pleasure coursed through him.

As he came down from the high, reality sank back in. The room was still dark, still quiet, but now it felt emptier than ever. Nate wasn’t here - wasn’t likely to be anywhere near him. He was probably with Sophie right now, laughing at some joke Elliot couldn’t hear, touching her arm as he explained something.

A lump formed in his throat, and he whispered into the empty room, “You’re such an idiot, Hale.” Then he reached for his phone, the screen illuminating his sad smile as he turned off the ringer and fell asleep with it still clutched in his hand.

Monday’s session moved from the library to Elliot’s room because the third floor was closed for a fire drill and the café was too loud and, as Nate pointed out, Elliot had a printer.

“Priya’s out until ten,” Elliot said, unlocking the door, and immediately wished he hadn’t, because it sounded like an invitation, and Nate’s eyes flicked to him and then away.

The room was small. Two beds, two desks, a window looking out over the parking lot, fairy lights Priya had strung along the shelf above her bed. There was only one desk chair that wasn’t covered in laundry, so after twenty minutes of awkward shuffling they ended up sitting side by side on Elliot’s bed, backs against the wall, Elliot’s laptop balanced across both their knees.

It should have been easy. It was a spreadsheet. It was a chart about race times. But Nate was warm and close and smelled of soap and the cold air outside, and every time he leaned over to point at the screen his shoulder pressed against Elliot’s and stayed there a second longer than it needed to.

They worked anyway. They got through four pages of the outline. Nate turned out to be quick and sharp with numbers in a way that surprised Elliot, and Elliot turned out to be able to explain sunk costs in a way that made Nate say, “Oh. Oh, that’s literally my dad,” and then go quiet for a long minute.

Around nine, Nate stretched, cracked his neck, and let his head fall back against the wall.

“Can I ask you something?” he said to the ceiling.

Elliot’s pulse jumped. “Sure.”

“When did you know? That you were...” Nate made a vague gesture. “You know.”

“Gay,” Elliot said.

“Yeah.”

Elliot looked at the side of Nate’s face. Nate was still staring at the ceiling, very determinedly, as if he’d asked about the weather.

“I don’t know,” Elliot said honestly. “Kind of always? But I didn’t have a word for it until I was maybe fourteen. There was this guy on my swim team. I used to get so nervous around him I’d forget how to talk.” He smiled a little. “I thought I just really wanted to be his friend.”

Nate huffed out something that was almost a laugh. “Did you tell him?”

“God, no. I told my mom, two years later. She cried, then she made pancakes.” Elliot shrugged. “It was fine. Better than fine. I got lucky.”

Nate was quiet. On the laptop screen, the cursor blinked in the middle of a half-finished sentence.

“Why?” Elliot asked carefully.

“No reason.” Nate’s throat moved. “Just curious.”

He turned his head. They were very close now, closer than they’d ever been, Elliot’s shoulder against his, the laptop warm across their knees. Elliot could see the tiny pale line of the scar through Nate’s eyebrow, and the place on his chin where he’d cut himself shaving last week, almost healed now. He could see Nate’s eyes drop, just for a second, to his mouth.

Neither of them moved.

Nate pushes the laptop aside onto the mattress without so much as a glance away from Elliot. The screen casts a pale glow on their faces, illuminating the tension that hangs between them like a thick curtain.

Their hands rest side by side on the mattress, knuckles brushing. Slowly, so slowly it’s almost imperceptible, Nate’s little finger stretches out, touching Elliot’s. Neither man flinches nor pulls away. It’s a tentative, hesitant touch, a question asked in silence.

Nate’s hand shifts, his palm settling on Elliot’s thigh, just above the knee. The warmth of him seeps through the denim, a stark contrast to the cool air in the room. Elliot feels it like a brand, his breath catching in his throat.

A sensation stirs in Elliot’s groin, a familiar yet unexpected pressure. He feels himself hardening, his cock thickening and lengthening, pushing against the constraints of his jeans. The head swells, turning dark, the prominent vein along the underside pulsing with each beat of his heart. He shifts slightly, trying to ease the discomfort, but it only serves to press him more firmly against Nate’s hand.

Their eyes lock, and Elliot knows Nate can see it, the evidence of his arousal tenting his jeans. Nate’s gaze drops, lingers on the growing bulge before rising back to meet Elliot’s eyes.

Nate’s thumb begins a slow journey up Elliot’s thigh, each inch painstakingly traversed as if he’s treading on eggshells. It stops just shy of Elliot’s crotch, leaving him yearning for more, his breath hitching in his chest.

Their faces drift closer, foreheads almost touching. Their breaths mingle, warm and ragged, lips so close they can feel the other’s exhale. They don’t kiss, but the tension between them is palpable, a live wire sparking with unspoken words and untouched skin.

Down the hall, a door slammed. Someone shouted a name and laughed.

Nate flinched as if he’d been hit. He snatched his hand back, stood up so fast the laptop nearly slid onto the floor, and caught it with both hands, and for a second the two of them just held it between them, breathing hard.

“I should go,” Nate said. His voice was wrecked. “It’s late. Sophie’s... I said I’d...”

“Yeah,” Elliot said. “Sure. Of course.”

Nate grabbed his jacket from the back of the chair, missed the sleeve twice, and gave up and carried it. At the door he stopped, his back to the room, exactly like in the locker room.

“Same time Thursday?” he said, very quietly.

Elliot closed his eyes. Say no, he thought. Say you’ll do the rest of it by email. Save yourself.

“Same time Thursday,” he said.

The door clicked shut.

Nate made it to the bottom of the stairwell before his legs gave out. He sat down on the last step under the flickering emergency light, put his elbows on his knees, and pressed the heels of his hands into his eyes until he saw stars.

He could still feel it. The warmth of Elliot’s leg through the denim. The way Elliot had stopped breathing when Nate’s thumb moved. The way Elliot had looked at him, not scared at all, just waiting. As if he’d have let Nate do anything.

As if he wanted him to.

Nate’s breath hitched as he sat on the cold concrete step, the rough edge digging into his ass. His sweatpants did little to hide the heavy bulge tenting them. He shifted uncomfortably, trying to adjust himself without success. A jolt of pleasure shot through him at the friction, and he groaned internally.

He couldn’t help but press his palm against the hard length straining against his pants. Half out of desperation to make it go away, half because he couldn’t resist touching himself, he rubbed a few times through the thin fabric. The sensation was intense, and he bit back a moan.

His mind wandered to Elliot, his green eyes filled with that same look from earlier - not scared, just waiting. Nate imagined their lips pressing together, Elliot’s soft mouth opening under his. He could feel Elliot’s long fingers splayed across his chest, pushing him down onto the bed, their bodies aligned and straining against each other.

The fantasy was so vivid, so real, that Nate gasped. He wanted it. God, he wanted it so badly it physically hurt. His hand moved faster, rubbing the length of his cock through his pants, chasing that feeling.

Then, overhead, footsteps echoed down the stairwell. Nate’s heart stopped. He yanked his hand away from his crotch, holding his breath as the steps came closer, then paused on the floor above him. Time seemed to stretch out interminably as he waited, frozen, for the unknown figure to pass by. The footsteps finally moved on, fading away along the corridor above. Nate let out a shaky breath, his body still throbbing with unspent need.

His phone buzzed.

He looked at the message for a long time. Then he stood up, put on his jacket properly this time, and walked out into the cold.

He didn’t look up at the third-floor window as he crossed the parking lot.

He didn’t have to. He knew Elliot was standing there, watching him go.

End of Chapter Three

Please let me know your thoughts.

Nothing happened.

He’d been tired. He’d been up late with the guys watching the game, then up at six for practice, then late for Whitcombe. His brain had been running on two hours of sleep and a protein bar. People stared at random things when they were exhausted. It didn’t mean anything. It was a glitch. A misfire.

He’d looked because the guy had looked first. That was all. Some kind of reflex, the way you turn your head when someone else turns theirs.

Nothing happened.

By the time he got to his room he had almost convinced himself. Then he dropped his bag on the floor, sat on the edge of his bed, and the memory came back so sharply that he had to put his face in his hands.

Not the looking. The being caught.

The way the other guy had turned his head, slow and careful, and their eyes had met. Green eyes, Nate thought, and then hated that he knew that. Green eyes, a little wide, and something in them that wasn’t disgust or mockery or any of the things Nate had expected. Something that looked almost like hope.

His phone buzzed.

Nate stared at the screen for a long moment. Then he typed a reply.

He added a heart after it, the way he always did, and put the phone face down on the mattress as if it might see something on his face.

The Thai place was small and loud and smelled of lemongrass and chili. Sophie talked about her statistics group project, about her roommate’s terrible new boyfriend, about her sister’s wedding in December and whether Nate would wear the navy suit or the grey one. She was funny and quick and she kept stealing food off his plate, and Nate loved her. He was sure he loved her. They’d been together for almost two years. She knew how he took his coffee and which song made him cry and that he hated being touched on the back of his neck when he was asleep.

“You’re quiet,” she said, halfway through dessert.

“Long day.”

“Whitcombe again?” She grinned. “Did she call you out for being late?”

“Something like that.”

She reached across the table and laced her fingers through his. “You know you can tell me stuff, right? Even dumb stuff.”

For one wild second Nate imagined saying it: “I looked at a guy today. I looked at him and I couldn’t stop, and when he caught me I felt like I was falling.” He pictured her face, the confusion and then the hurt, and his stomach turned over.

“I know,” he said, and squeezed her hand. “It’s nothing. Really.”

Sophie stayed over that night. She usually did on Tuesdays.

Nate’s small dorm room is bathed in the soft glow of the desk lamp, casting long shadows on the narrow bed where Sophie and Nate lie entwined. The streetlight outside the window paints stripes on the wall, a familiar dance of light and dark that Nate barely notices anymore. Sophie starts kissing him, her lips soft and confident, her hands already familiar with the map of his body. It’s easy, like this always is.

She undresses him slowly, her fingers tracing the lines of his muscles, the tan skin stretched tight over them from years on the rowing team. Her own body is revealed bit by bit, pretty and warm, her blonde hair spilling over her shoulders as she leans down to kiss his chest. Nate helps her out of her clothes, his hands knowing just where to go, where to touch to make her gasp.

Their bodies fit together like puzzle pieces, familiar and comfortable. She straddles him, her eyes locked onto his as she guides him inside her. They move in sync, their breaths falling into the same rhythm, their bodies slick with sweat under the dim light. Nate’s hands grip her hips, his fingers digging into the soft flesh there as he thrusts up to meet her.

Halfway through, Nate closes his eyes, losing himself in the sensation. But suddenly, Elliot’s face flashes into his mind - green eyes intense, blond curls falling into his face. The urinal, the flash of skin, the unexpected hardness that had sprung up at the sight. Nate’s body responds immediately, his cock twitching inside Sophie, growing even harder.

Shock jolts through him and he opens his eyes, forcing himself to focus on Sophie. Her breath hitches as she feels him swell inside her, her nails digging into his chest. They both pick up the pace, chasing their release, Nate’s earlier shock forgotten in the heat of the moment.

Sophie throws her head back, her blonde hair cascading down her spine as she finds her peak. Nate follows soon after, a groan tearing from his throat as he spills into her. She collapses onto his chest, her breath coming in ragged gasps, and murmurs, “You were different tonight. Good different.” Nate kisses her hair, unable to form words around the sudden knot of guilt in his throat.

Afterwards, she fell asleep almost immediately, curled against his side with one arm thrown across his chest. Nate lay awake and watched the streetlight make slow shapes on the ceiling.

Different. He had been different tonight. Different because of Elliot. And he had no idea what to do with that.

You were tired, he told himself. It was a glitch.

But glitches didn’t come back. And this one kept coming back, every time he closed his eyes.

At two in the morning he gave up on sleep, slid carefully out from under Sophie’s arm, and went down the hall to the shared bathroom. The dorm was silent except for the hum of the vending machine on the landing. He turned the shower on hot and stood under it with his forehead against the tiles.

He thought about Sophie. He tried to.

Under the scalding water, Nate’s body responds without his consent. His cock stiffens, throbbing against his abdomen, as if seeking relief from the steamy air. He tries to ignore it, scrubbing at his skin with soap, but his flesh has other ideas. His hand drifts down, wrapping around his length, stroking in slow, deliberate motions.

He pictures Sophie, her curves pressed against him earlier tonight, her lips parted as she moaned. But the image flickers like a faulty photograph, and suddenly it’s not Sophie he sees. It’s Elliot, standing at the urinals, his athletic form tense under Nate’s stare. The memory of Elliot growing hard is vivid, that prominent vein pulsing along the underside of his cock. Nate can almost see the blush creeping up Elliot’s face when their eyes met.

Nate tries to push the image away, focusing back on Sophie. But it’s no use. His mind betrays him, switching back to Elliot - green eyes, blond curls, the dark flush on his cheeks. He grits his teeth, attempts to force the image out again. This time, he pictures Sophie riding him, her breasts bouncing with each thrust. But even as he wills it, Elliot’s face reappears, this time with a smirk playing at the corners of his mouth.

Defeated, Nate gives in. He lets himself think only of Elliot - Elliot’s hand on him instead of his own, long fingers wrapping around his thickness. The image sends a jolt through him, and he strokes faster, harder, his breath coming in ragged gasps. His cock pulses, swelling at the tip as he nears release.

With a low groan muffled against his forearm, Nate comes hard. Thick ropes of cum shoot from his cock, splattering onto the tiles before being washed away by the water. He leans into the spray, chest heaving, heart pounding in his ears.

Silence envelops him except for the steady drum of water against tile. Then shame and confusion crash over him like a tidal wave. Nate leans his forehead against the cool surface, whispering, “What the hell is wrong with me?”

He stood there until the water ran cold.

When he crept back into bed, Sophie murmured something in her sleep and pressed closer, warm and trusting. Nate stared at the ceiling until the window turned grey.

Elliot didn’t see Nate again until Thursday.

He hadn’t been looking for him. That was what he told his roommate, Priya, when she caught him scanning the dining hall for the third time at lunch on Wednesday.

“You’re doing the thing,” she said, without looking up from her laptop.

“What thing?”

“The meerkat thing. Where you pop your head up every time the door opens.” She finally looked at him over her glasses. “Who is he?”

“Nobody.”

“Elliot.”

“Nobody,” he repeated, and stabbed at his salad. “Some guy from econ. He’s straight. He has a girlfriend. It’s nothing.”

Priya made a noise that meant she didn’t believe a word of it, but she let it go. That was the best thing about Priya. She always let it go eventually, and then brought it up again at the worst possible moment.

On Thursday evening Elliot went to the campus gym, because he always went to the campus gym on Thursday evenings, and not because he had heard someone in the corridor mention that the rowing team did their weights session there on Thursdays.

The gym was in the basement of the sports center: low ceilings, mirrored walls, the constant clank of plates and the thud of music nobody had chosen on purpose. Elliot did his usual warm-up on the rowing machine, then moved to the squat rack at the far end of the room, put in his earbuds, and focused on his breathing.

He saw Nate in the mirror on his third set.

Nate was across the room at the bench press with two of his teammates, the same broad-shouldered guys from the lecture. He was wearing a faded black tank top and shorts, his hair pushed back with a headband, and he was spotting one of the others with his hands hovering under the bar, saying something that made the guy laugh so hard he almost dropped the weight.

Elliot’s knees nearly went on the way up. He racked the bar with a clang that made someone glance over, and stood there breathing hard, pretending it was from the squats.

In the mirror, Nate’s head turned.

Their eyes met in the glass. Just for a second. Nate’s expression went completely blank, the way a screen goes blank when it loses signal. Then he turned back to his teammate, said something short, and did not look in Elliot’s direction again for the rest of the session.

Not once. Elliot knew, because he checked. More often than he would ever admit to Priya.

Okay, Elliot thought, working through his last set with his jaw clenched. Okay. Message received. It was nothing. He’s pretending it never happened. That’s fine. That’s probably the sanest thing either of us can do.

It didn’t feel fine. But he finished his workout anyway.

By the time Elliot got to the locker room it was nearly nine, and the place was almost empty. The rowing guys had left a few minutes earlier; he’d heard them in the corridor, loud and laughing, heading for the exit. One of the showers at the far end was still running. Steam drifted along the ceiling.

Elliot sat on the bench, pulled off his shirt, and leaned back against the lockers for a moment with his eyes closed. His muscles had that good, heavy ache. His head was a mess.

The shower at the end shut off.

Footsteps on wet tiles. Elliot opened his eyes.

Nate Carter came around the end of the row of lockers with a towel slung around his hips and water still running down his chest, and stopped dead when he saw who was sitting there.

For a second neither of them moved.

Elliot’s gaze traced Nate Carter from the top of his dark head, water glistening in the harsh fluorescent light, down to his bare feet. His hair was slicked back, a few strands clinging to his forehead just above the small scar through his left eyebrow. Water ran in rivulets down his tanned chest and over the hard planes of muscle. Elliot’s eyes followed the path, lingering on the defined abs, the V-shaped lines disappearing into the towel slung low around Nate’s hips.

The damp fabric clung to him, outlining every inch of what lay beneath. The towel rode precariously low, hinting at the thick length nestled within, prominent veins visible even through the thin material. It was impossible not to see it, and Elliot found his eyes drawn there like a magnet.

He tried three times to look Nate in the face, each time failing as his gaze was pulled inexorably back down. His heart pounded in his chest, echoing the throb that was building between his legs. Despite his best efforts, he felt himself growing hard, his cock pressing insistently against the thin fabric of his gym shorts.

Elliot leaned forward, elbows on knees, and dropped his head, hiding what was becoming increasingly obvious. He was acutely aware of his state, half-naked, exposed in a way that made him vulnerable to Nate’s notice.

Nate’s eyes flicked over Elliot’s bare chest for a moment before skating away, leaving Elliot feeling a mix of relief and disappointment. The silence stretched out between them, thick with tension, each second ticking by like an eternity. Elliot’s breath was coming faster now, his body humming with a desire he couldn’t ignore. Yet, they remained still, separated by more than just the empty bench between them.

“Hey,” Nate said finally. His voice came out rough.

“Hey.”

Nate went to a locker three down from Elliot’s, opened it, and stood with his back to him, staring into it as if it contained the answer to something. Water dripped from his hair onto his shoulders. Elliot looked down at his own hands.

“Your teammates left,” Elliot said, because the silence was unbearable.

“Yeah. I stayed to - ” Nate stopped. “I wanted a shower without them yelling at me.”

“Makes sense.”

More silence. The vent in the ceiling rattled. Somewhere a pipe knocked twice.

Then Nate said, still facing his locker: “About Tuesday.”

Elliot’s heart kicked hard against his ribs. “Yeah?”

“That was - ” Nate’s hand tightened on the locker door. “I wasn’t... I’m not...” He blew out a breath. “I was really tired. I didn’t mean to stare. I don’t even know why I did that. It was weird. I’m sorry if it was weird.”

He said it fast, like a speech he’d rehearsed in the shower. Maybe he had.

Elliot could have said a hundred things. He could have said: “You didn’t look tired, you looked like you couldn’t stop.” He could have said: “I’ve been thinking about it for two days.” He could have said: “I saw your face.”

Instead he said, carefully, “It’s fine. Nothing happened.”

Nate turned around.

It was the first time he had looked straight at Elliot since the restroom, and up close, in the harsh fluorescent light, he looked younger than he did in the lecture hall. Unsure. His eyes were dark brown and there was a crease between his eyebrows, right next to the little scar, and he was looking at Elliot as though Elliot had said something in a language he didn’t quite speak.

“Right,” Nate said slowly. “Nothing happened.”

“Exactly.”

Nate nodded. He didn’t look away.

Elliot watched Nate’s gaze trail down his bare chest, over the ridges of muscle he’d earned from years of swimming, then lower still to where his gym shorts rode low on his hips. His heart pounded in his ears, a drumbeat echoing through him as Nate’s eyes lingered on the bulge at his crotch. Elliot was hard, his cock tenting the thin fabric, the head swollen and dark against the light grey material. He could feel every pulse of blood there, every inch straining against the cotton barrier.

Nate’s eyes widened slightly, a flicker of surprise before they darted up to meet Elliot’s gaze. This time, Elliot didn’t look away, didn’t try to hide it. He held Nate’s stare, his body humming with a silent challenge. Nate swallowed hard, his Adam’s apple bobbing in his tanned throat.

Then, slowly, almost imperceptibly, Nate’s towel began to tent. A ridge formed along the length of it, growing more prominent by the second. Elliot could see the outline of Nate’s cock, long and thick, curving slightly to one side. The towel did little to hide the prominent veins running along its shaft or the broad head pressing against the fabric.

Nate seemed to realize what was happening at the same moment Elliot did. He spun sideways, grabbing onto the locker door as if for support. His knuckles turned white with the effort of holding himself there, not moving, not saying a word. The air between them crackled with tension, electric and silent, a shared secret hanging heavy in the space.

Neither of them spoke. For a few seconds they were frozen in place. Then Nate turned fully away, breaking the spell, his shoulders hunched as he reached into his locker.

He grabbed a T-shirt and pulled it over his head so fast he got stuck in it for a second, and Elliot had to bite the inside of his cheek not to laugh, not because it was funny, but because if he didn’t laugh he might do something much worse.

Nate dressed with his back turned and his shoulders tense. Elliot made himself look at the floor. Neither of them said a word. When Nate finally slammed his locker shut and shouldered his bag, Elliot thought that was it: he’d walk out, and on Tuesday he’d sit somewhere else, and that would be the end of the stupidest crush of Elliot’s life.

Nate got as far as the door.

Then he stopped, one hand on the frame, and said without turning around: “What’s your name?”

Elliot blinked. “Elliot.”

“Elliot,” Nate repeated quietly, as if he were testing how it sounded. “I’m Nate.”

“I know.”

That made Nate glance back over his shoulder. For half a second something flickered across his face. Surprise, then something warmer, then something that looked a lot like fear.

“Right,” he said. “Whitcombe.”

“Whitcombe,” Elliot agreed.

Nate looked at him a moment longer. Then he pushed the door open and was gone, and the locker room was empty except for the drip of the showers and the rattle of the vent and Elliot, sitting on the bench with his heart going like he’d just done another set.

He pulled out his phone. One new message.

Elliot stared at it. Then he typed his answer.

Three dots appeared immediately. Then:

Elliot put the phone down on the bench, tipped his head back against the lockers, and closed his eyes. He was smiling. He couldn’t stop.

Across campus, Nate sat in his car in the dark parking lot behind the sports center with the engine off and both hands on the steering wheel.

Elliot.

His phone lit up on the passenger seat.

Nate didn’t pick it up. Not for a long time.

End of Chapter Two

Please let me know your thoughts.

It was a good rule. It had kept him focused through two years of university, through a breakup that had left him wrung out and quiet for most of last spring, through a dozen nights out where friends had tried to set him up with guys who talked about crypto for forty minutes straight. At twenty, Elliot had decided that the smartest thing he could do was keep his head down, keep his grades up, and keep his heart somewhere safe and boring.

The rule lasted until 9:07 a.m.

Lecture Hall B was the oldest room on campus, all creaking wooden seats and tall windows that let in a pale October light. Professor Whitcombe was already halfway through her opening slide on behavioral economics when the door at the back swung open and someone came down the steps two at a time.

Elliot heard him before he saw him: the quick, apologetic rhythm of sneakers on old wood, the muttered “Sorry, sorry” as he squeezed past a row of backpacks. Then the guy dropped into the empty seat directly across the aisle from Elliot, and the rule quietly died.

He was tall, even sitting down. Broad through the shoulders in a way that made his grey hoodie look like it had been cut for him, the sleeves pushed up over forearms that belonged to someone who actually used them. Dark hair, slightly damp, as if he’d jumped straight out of the shower and run. A sharp jaw with a day of stubble. When he leaned forward to dig a notebook out of his bag, the hoodie pulled tight across his back and Elliot had to look at the projector screen very deliberately.

Rowing team, Elliot thought. Or swimming. Something with early mornings and too much discipline.

“Mr. Carter,” Professor Whitcombe said dryly, without turning around. “How kind of you to join us.”

“Traffic,” the guy said, and half the room laughed, because everyone knew he lived in the dorms four minutes away.

Carter. Elliot filed it away and immediately hated himself for doing it.

For the next fifty minutes he took the worst notes of his academic career. He wrote down “loss aversion” three times. He drew a box around nothing. Every few minutes, without meaning to, his eyes slid across the aisle: to the way Carter chewed the end of his pen when he was thinking, to the silver ring on his right thumb, to the small scar through his left eyebrow, to the moment he laughed at one of Whitcombe’s jokes and his whole face changed, opened up, went warm and boyish and impossibly easy.

It was ridiculous. Elliot knew it was ridiculous. You did not fall for someone because of the way they laughed in a lecture about rational choice. That was the opposite of rational choice.

And yet.

Halfway through the lecture, Carter’s phone lit up on the desk. Elliot wasn’t trying to look, but the screen was bright and the photo was big: Carter with his arm around a pretty blonde girl, both of them squinting into the sun on some beach. A little red heart next to the name. Sophie.

Of course, Elliot thought, and something in his chest folded itself neatly away. Of course he has a girlfriend. Of course he does.

He looked back at the slides and tried to care about the endowment effect.

When the lecture ended, the room dissolved into the usual noise of zippers and chairs and people already on their phones. Carter was swept up almost immediately by two guys from the back rows, both built like they lifted together, and Elliot heard snatches of “tonight” and “the game” and someone calling him Nate.

Nate Carter.

Elliot packed slowly, waited for the aisle to clear, and told himself he was going to walk straight to the library like a sensible person. Instead, he found himself turning left down the corridor toward the restrooms, mostly because he needed a minute alone to splash cold water on his face and remind himself who he was.

The men’s room in the old building was long and narrow, with cracked white tiles and a row of urinals along one wall under a frosted window. It smelled of industrial soap and radiator heat. Elliot pushed the door open, expecting it to be empty.

It wasn’t.

Nate Carter was standing at the far urinal, one hand braced against the tiled wall, head tipped back slightly as if he were counting ceiling tiles.

Elliot’s step faltered for half a second. Every unwritten rule of men’s rooms everywhere said: take the one furthest away. Leave a gap. Look at the wall. Be invisible.

There were five urinals. Nate was at the last one.

Elliot took the one right next to him.

He didn’t fully know why. Maybe it was the same reckless, stupid impulse that had kept his eyes drifting across the aisle all morning. Maybe some part of him just wanted to be near him for thirty seconds, while nobody was watching, before he went back to being sensible. His heart was going hard enough that he could feel it in his throat.

Nate glanced sideways, registered him with a small nod, the universal, wordless greeting of two guys in a bathroom, and looked back at the wall.

Elliot looked at the wall too. For about three seconds.

Then, because the rule was already dead and buried, he let his eyes drop.

Just a glance. Quick, guilty, the kind of look he’d have denied under oath. But long enough.

It was a momentary lapse of control, and it sent an electric jolt through him. Nate stood at the urinal beside him, oblivious, his penis jutting out, a sight Elliot couldn’t unsee. It was a beast among men, thick and long, veins bulging like rivers on a map. The size matched Nate’s athletic body, a perfect reflection of his power and strength. It curved slightly, a natural arc that made it all the more enticing. The head was wide, flushed pink against his tanned skin, and droplets gathered at its tip, ready to fall.

Elliot’s breath hitched in his throat as he took in every detail. His face burned like he’d stood too close to a fire, heat spreading across his cheeks. His own cock twitched in response, starting to plump up in his hand. Panic surged through him, a wild horse stampeding in his chest. He was standing next to a straight guy, for God’s sake, in a men’s room, and now he was getting hard.

He had to stop this, had to make it stop before Nate noticed. Elliot wrenched his gaze back up to the tiled wall, his heart pounding like a drum in his ears. His mind screamed at him, thoughts tangling together like a ball of yarn. What if Nate saw? What if he knew what Elliot was thinking? What if... No. Stop. He’s straight. He has a girlfriend. Sophie. The little red heart next to her name flashed in Elliot’s mind, a warning beacon.

Get a grip, he told himself, and squeezed his eyes shut for a second. Finish up and get out.

He stared at a crack in the tile that looked a bit like the coast of Norway. The radiator ticked. Somewhere down the corridor a door slammed.

And then he noticed the silence next to him.

It took him a second to understand what was wrong with it. Nate had stopped moving. No zip, no shuffle, no sound of someone finishing up and stepping away. Just a stillness, close enough that Elliot could feel it on his skin.

Slowly, carefully, Elliot turned his head an inch.

Nate wasn’t looking at the wall anymore.

He was looking down. Not at himself. At Elliot.

His gaze wasn’t the quick, accidental flick of a guy who’d glanced the wrong way. It was steady. Fixed. His lips were slightly parted and there was a faint flush spreading along the line of his jaw, and for one long, impossible moment he simply stared, openly and unguardedly, as if he’d forgotten where he was or who might see him. As if he’d forgotten himself entirely.

Elliot felt it before he saw it. A prickling heat, like the first brush of sunlight on bare skin, stirring at his groin. He looked down, following Nate’s gaze, and there it was: his own cock, half-hard already, standing at attention under Nate’s unblinking stare.

Nate wasn’t just looking; he was taking in every detail, as if committing it to memory. Elliot felt the scrutiny like a physical touch, and his body responded in kind. His dick throbbed, lengthening and thickening, the head swelling until it was almost purple with need. A single vein pulsed along its underside, like a heartbeat visible through skin too thin. It was as if Nate’s gaze was a hand, stroking him, coaxing him to life.

Elliot could feel the heat spreading from his cock, up his belly, flushing his chest and neck. His breath hitched in his throat, coming faster now, mirroring Nate’s own quickening breaths. He saw Nate’s Adam’s apple bob as he swallowed hard, saw the knuckles of his hand on the wall turn white with tension.

He should move, should shift away from that intense scrutiny. But Elliot stood rooted to the spot, caught in the spell of Nate’s gaze. Embarrassment warred with excitement within him, a heady mix that left him lightheaded and dizzy. His heart pounded in his ears, each beat echoing loudly in the silence of the room.

For a few more seconds, neither of them moved. And Nate Carter, who had a girlfriend and a beach photo and a little red heart next to her name, kept looking at him like he’d discovered something he hadn’t known he was searching for.

Then Nate blinked.

Whatever spell it was snapped. His eyes jumped up and met Elliot’s for a single heartbeat, wide, startled, almost frightened, and the color in his face went from faint to deep red.

“Shit,” Nate said under his breath. Not to Elliot. Maybe not to anyone.

In the second before Nate turned away, Elliot’s gaze flicked down, drawn like a magnet. There, against Nate’s thigh, his cock was swelling, thickening visibly, a vein pulsing prominently along its length. It curved slightly to the right, nudging against his leg, a shade pinker at the broad head. Nate’s body tensed, hands fumbling as he tried to cover himself, but it was too late. Elliot had seen.

Nate whipped around, his back now facing Elliot, shoulders hunching as if trying to hide within himself. His movements were clumsy, panicked, like a deer caught in headlights. The shock of realization hit Elliot squarely in the chest. It wasn’t just him. The attraction was mutual, raw and undeniable, reflected in Nate’s flushed face and hardening cock.

Nate zipped up so fast he fumbled it. He didn’t go to the sinks. He didn’t say anything else. He grabbed his bag from where he’d dropped it by the door, shouldered it, and pushed out into the corridor without looking back, the door swinging hard on its hinges behind him and then easing slowly, slowly shut.

The restroom was quiet again. The radiator ticked. The crack in the tile still looked like Norway.

Elliot stood there for a long time with his heart racing and his face burning, trying to make sense of what he’d just seen.

Nate Carter was straight. Nate Carter had a girlfriend.

And Nate Carter had looked.

Not by accident. Not for a second. He had looked like someone who couldn’t stop.

Elliot finally walked to the sink and ran the water as cold as it would go. He splashed his face once, twice, and stared at his reflection in the cloudy mirror: flushed cheeks, too-bright eyes, a guy who had broken his only rule before ten in the morning and somehow didn’t regret it.

“Second row, left side,” he murmured to himself. “Next Tuesday.”

He had no idea what he was going to do. But for the first time in a very long time, he couldn’t wait to find out.

End of Chapter One

This is the first story i ever wrote, please comment your thoughts.

The whole story is fully fictional and not based on anything real.