MARK TWAIN (1835-1910) | If you tell the truth, you don’t have to remember anything.

Have you ever wondered why your child will tell you just about anything right up until the moment you most need them to tell you the truth?

They’ll tell you what their friend said at lunch, what happened on the playground, and why the dog is obviously responsible for the broken lamp. But let them make a mistake that might disappoint you, and suddenly their memory becomes unreliable, their explanations become remarkably creative, and nobody seems to know anything about anything.

It’s enough to make you wonder whether you’ve been raising a child or training a defense attorney.

We laugh because, if we’re being honest, most of us have probably done it ourselves on occasion. But underneath the humor is a pretty big question…”What happens inside a child when telling the truth means facing a parent’s disappointment?”

We want our children to be honest, even when the truth costs them something (maybe even especially when it does). What we don’t always consider is whether our reactions make that honesty easier…or harder.

The Flaming Sword

In an essay for PBS KIDS, educator and parent writer Deborah Farmer Kris recounts a story about her young son describing an incident that happened at preschool. A boy had apparently struck him with a flaming sword while the teachers were conveniently absent, and the adventure also…somehow…involved blasters on his shoes.

Needless to say, it was quite a story.

As his mother asked more questions, however, she learned that the actual incident involved rough play with a friend and a conversation with the teacher. The flaming sword was a…um…imaginative improvement on an uncomfortable afternoon.

What I appreciate about this story is the opportunity it presents. A parent can recognize a child’s imagination while still helping them distinguish between the story they wish had happened versus the one that actually did. The goal is to help the child face reality and take responsibility for their part in it.

You can read her account in the PBS KIDS’ article, “How to Talk to Kids About Honesty.”

A five-year-old’s playground story is a long way from a teenager hiding a serious mistake. The consequences and the guidance required will differ. Still, both situations raise an important question, “When our children do something wrong, do they believe they can tell us what happened and face the consequences, or have they learned that their safest option is to make the story sound better (or deny that it happened)?”

We Want Honesty (are we prepared to hear it?)

The Book of James offers a principle worth remembering when having a difficult conversation:

JAMES 1:19 CJB | […] let every person be quick to listen but slow to speak, slow to get angry […]

Imagine your teenager admits that he broke a rule. Perhaps he went somewhere he wasn’t supposed to go, stayed out later than agreed, or made a decision online that violated your family’s boundaries.

You have every reason to be concerned. His decision may have put him at risk, damaged trust, or harmed someone else. You need to address it.

But before you respond, consider what happens in the first few seconds after he tells you.

Do you listen to the whole story, or begin delivering the verdict before the evidence has been presented? Do you ask questions to understand what happened, or because you’re looking for another reason to be angry? Does the conversation address the “why” behind his decision, or become a speech about every questionable choice he’s made since the third grade?

Sometimes, a parent can begin with a legitimate concern and, through fear and frustration, turn that difficult conversation into an interrogation. The child sees the disappointment on their parent’s face and immediately regrets having said anything.

The original mistake may have been relatively small…but the experience of disclosing it can make the next confession that much harder.

We need to be honest about our part in this. Although our children remain responsible for their choices, we are responsible for how we respond to them. There are times when we can insist on honesty while reacting in ways that actually encourage concealment.

However, understanding that possibility doesn’t mean removing consequences. It just means that recognizing the way we handle a mistake is part of what our children learn from it.

Hiding In The Garden

Genesis gives us an enduring picture of what happens when wrongdoing converges with fear.

We’re all familiar with the story of Adam and Eve’s disobedience to God. Later, they hear Him in the garden and hide. God calls to Adam, “Where are you?” (Genesis 3:9).

Of course, God already knows what has happened, but His question invites Adam into the open. Instead, Adam justifies himself and shifts the blame elsewhere, and Eve follows a similar pattern. Their disobedience has led to hiding and blame rather than an honest acknowledgment of what they have done.

Genesis offers a sobering picture of what happens when we do something wrong and become afraid of the consequences. I know that impulse well (maybe too well). When the truth threatens to expose our failures, hiding and shifting the blame can seem a lot easier than admitting what we’ve done.

Our children need to learn a different response. They need to understand that wrongdoing must be brought into the light, responsibility must be accepted, and forgiveness and restoration are possible.

We help them learn this through our own example and through the way we respond when they fail. You can tell a child, “What you did was wrong, and we need to deal with it,” without saying, “I can’t believe you would do something like this. What is wrong with you?”

The first addresses the choice and calls the child toward responsibility. The second risks turning a bad decision into a judgment about the child’s identity.

Our children need to “know that they know” that their choices matter and that telling the truth is the beginning of making things right.

Understanding Is Not Excusing

Of course, children sometimes lie because they want to avoid consequences. After all, they’re children. They may be protecting a privilege, trying to get what they want, or escaping responsibility. So, we shouldn’t invent a deeper emotional explanation for every dishonest answer.

Yet understanding why a child hides the truth helps us respond better to the actual problem.

A child who expects an explosive reaction will be more tempted to conceal a mistake. A child who feels ashamed may find it difficult to admit what happened. A teenager who believes that one failure will permanently destroy a parent’s respect may work very hard to keep that failure hidden.

These are real reasons…but none of them excuse dishonesty. Rather, they help us distinguish between a child who needs to learn accountability and a child who also needs help feeling safe enough to disclose something painful or dangerous. And sometimes both are true.

There is a balance here. Anger alone may address the immediate offense without teaching the child how to handle the next difficult moment. Sympathy alone can leave the child without the accountability needed to grow.

We need to hold both together: compassion for the child and a clear expectation that he or she takes responsibility for their words and actions.

And that brings us to a question parents should ask themselves more often: “What happens inside us when our children disappoint us?”

The Parent Behind The Reaction

Perhaps anxiety kicks in and you immediately worry about your child’s future. A lie about something small becomes “evidence”, in your mind, of the kind of adult your child might become. A foolish decision makes you wonder whether all the years you’ve invested in raising your child have all been for nothing.

Maybe you’re embarrassed. What will other people think? Have you failed as a parent? Does this mean your child doesn’t respect you?

Or perhaps you grew up in a home where mistakes were met with anger, humiliation, or withdrawal. You promised yourself that you would never parent that way, yet you hear your own voice rising and recognize a familiar expression on your face.

These reactions deserve some honest self-evaluation. Sometimes we respond to our children’s mistakes as though each one were a verdict on our parenting. We want to correct the behavior, reassure ourselves that everything will be all right, and regain a sense of control.

Unfortunately, children don’t always learn their lessons on our timetable. We want them to understand what they did wrong, recognize the consequences, and promise never to do it again. Preferably before dinner. Parenting sure would be a lot easier if character development came with an overnight shipping option. It doesn’t.

We want the problem solved now. We want to know that the lesson has been learned and that this will never happen again.

But formation takes time. If every mistake becomes a family emergency, our children may become more concerned with managing our reactions than learning from their own choices.

Our responsibility is to help them face reality, including the consequences of their decisions. But that requires us to face reality about ourselves, too. We may need to acknowledge that our fear, embarrassment, or anger is making an already difficult conversation harder than it needs to be.

So what can we do differently the next time our child tells us something we wish hadn’t happened?

What Should You Do When Your Child Tells You The Truth?

Start by listening. You don’t have to approve of what happened to hear the whole story. Ask questions only when you need clarification, but resist the temptation to interrupt every sentence with a correction. You may discover facts that change your understanding of the situation.

Then acknowledge the honesty. You might say something like, “I’m glad you told me what happened. I know that probably wasn’t easy for you.”

This doesn’t mean the behavior was acceptable. It means you are acknowledging the importance of telling the truth, especially when the truth is uncomfortable.

Next, address the actual behavior. If a rule was broken, explain why it matters. If someone was harmed, discuss how to make things right. If a consequence is appropriate, impose it thoughtfully and proportionately. Your child should understand that love doesn’t depend on good behavior and that trust grows through responsible choices.

Finally, help your child identify a way forward. Ask, “What do you think needs to happen now?” They may need your help to recognize what went wrong, accept responsibility, and decide what can be done differently next time.

And what if you respond badly? What if you interrupt, raise your voice, or say something you regret?

Go back and repair the conversation. You might say, “I was right to be concerned about what happened, but I didn’t handle our conversation well. I’m sorry for that. We still need to address your decision, and I’d like us to talk about it again.”

You haven’t surrendered your authority by apologizing. You’ve demonstrated that taking responsibility applies to parents, too.

The Kind Of Parent Your Child Needs

Naturally, we want our children to become honest, responsible adults who can recognize when they’ve made a mistake, own their decisions, and make things right. But that’s the kind of maturity that only develops through practice. Children make mistakes, face the consequences, receive correction, and learn to repair what they’ve damaged.

Along the way, they need parents who are honest with them, willing to listen when they have something difficult to say, and ready to help them take responsibility for their choices.

Your child needs to know that you can be disappointed without becoming cruel, that you can be angry without becoming unreasonable, and that you can impose consequences without withdrawing your love. None of us will meet that standard perfectly, but we can keep working toward it.

So, the next time your child tells you something you wish hadn’t happened, remember that your task is twofold: (1) address the mistake and (2) help your child learn how to face the mistake honestly. Neither responsibility cancels the other.

As parents, our goal isn’t to raise children who never disappoint us. It’s to raise children who can recognize wrongdoing, tell the truth about it, accept responsibility, and do the work of making things right.

And when that moment comes (and it will), you want your child to know that coming to you was a good place to start.

The truth may bring consequences. It may require an apology, restitution, or a season of rebuilding trust. But it also gives us a place from which to begin repairing what has gone wrong.

That’s a lesson worth teaching. And it begins with how we respond when our children tell us what really happened.

Get more from Daniel Hagadorn in the Substack app

Available for iOS and Android

Get the app

C. S. Lewis (1898-1963) | The task of the modern educator is not to cut down jungles but to irrigate deserts.

The Abolition of Man

I had an odd thought recently.

Somewhere right now, there is a teenager having a conversation with someone who doesn’t exist. At least not in the way we normally think about existence.

Maybe she’s sitting on her bed with the door closed, trying to figure out what to say to a friend who hurt her feelings.

Maybe he’s staring at his phone after an argument with his dad, trying to decide whether he was actually wrong.

Maybe a child is embarrassed to ask a question because it feels too personal, too awkward, or too likely to produce one of those parental reactions that begins with, “When I was your age…”

So instead, they ask AI, and AI answers without sighing, raising an eyebrow, casting a disappointed look, asking, “What makes you think that’s a good idea?” or reminding them that it’s bedtime. It has no schedule. It’s simply there...patient, available, and responsive.

And, at least for the moment, it feels remarkably good at making that child feel as though somebody is listening.

That thought bothers me a little (okay, more than a little).

Before we go any further, let me reassure you that this is not an anti-technology screed. I view technology much as I view fire: a valuable tool that can provide warmth, light, and energy, but one that must be handled carefully and used responsibly.

I don’t think every child who uses AI is in danger. I don’t think technology is inherently destructive. And I certainly don’t think our children should be protected from every new thing that makes adults uncomfortable.

We’ve been having those arguments for a very long time now.

What concerns me is something much less obvious.

What happens when our children learn that they can go somewhere other than us whenever they have a question, a problem, a fear, or just something they want to talk about?

That’s why AI feels different...because the old search engines never asked how your day was going.

This Is Not Just Another Screen

We’ve spent years talking about screens. Numerous books, research papers, blog posts, documentaries, and podcasts have explored how much time our children spend on them. We debate social media. We argue about smartphones, video games, pornography, distraction, attention spans, and the age at which children should have devices.

Those conversations are legitimate, and I’ve written about some of them myself. But artificial intelligence introduces something so different that it cannot be conveniently folded into the old technology conversation.

A screen used to be a window you looked through. AI is becoming something you talk to...and something that talks back.

It remembers what you said and can adapt its tone. It can explain something three different ways. It can help with homework, generate ideas, write stories, offer suggestions, and, in some cases, provide something that feels surprisingly close to companionship.

Pew Research Center’s 2026 survey of U.S. teens found that nearly two-thirds had used AI chatbots. Sixteen percent reported using them for casual conversation, while 12 percent had relied upon them for emotional support or advice. Yet four in ten parents said they had never discussed chatbot use with their teenagers, and parents were significantly less likely than teens to say their children were using these tools.

This gap reveals that teenagers are already using AI in ways that many parents do not see, understand, or know how to discuss...especially when that use involves emotional support, personal advice, or companionship.

And before you moms and dads go on Expedia.com to book a guilt-trip, this is not because you have suddenly become irresponsible parents.

We are collectively living through a technological shift for which most of us have no inherited wisdom, shared expectations, or established parenting playbook.

Our parents did not have to figure this out...and neither did their parents.

So we’re learning as we go.

That should make us humble, but it should also make us pay closer attention.

Why Does Your Child Go There?

If your child uses AI to summarize a book, explain algebra in simple terms, brainstorm an idea, or settle an argument about a random historical fact, I don’t find that especially alarming. And even then, it should support learning rather than become a shortcut around it.

But what happens when the reason your child uses AI is more personal?

Maybe your daughter is lonely. Maybe your son is embarrassed. Maybe your teenager has a problem he doesn’t know how to explain to you. Maybe she’s worried about something she knows you’ll worry about. Maybe he simply doesn’t want to hear another lecture.

So your son or daughter asks artificial intelligence. And it responds.

This is where I think parents need to slow down because we can become so focused on whether AI is giving our children good information that we overlook a far more important question: “Why did my child bring their questions to AI in the first place?”

Perhaps they’re curious. Or perhaps talking with AI feels easier than talking with us...less awkward, less risky, and lecture-free.

That possibility should make us pause, not panic.

We Shouldn’t Be Surprised

One of the things I’ve learned over the years is that children are always looking for somewhere to bring their questions.

They want to understand the world, but they also want to understand themselves. They have questions about faith, relationships, fairness, sex, friendship, fear, success, failure, and what to do when two things they believe seem to contradict one another.

If we don’t provide an environment where those questions can be asked safely and honestly, then our children will eventually find somewhere else to ask them.

Of course, that doesn’t mean we’ll answer every question perfectly (*spoiler alert: we won’t*).

Sometimes our answers will be clumsy…and sometimes we’ll have absolutely no clue. And sometimes our child will ask something at the worst possible moment, and we’ll say, “Can we talk about this after dinner?” because we’re standing over a sink full of dirty dishes wondering why nobody in the house seems to know where the dishwasher is.

That’s okay.

A healthy relationship doesn’t require perfect answers...just enough trust for the questions to keep coming. And that’s really what we need to protect the most as AI becomes more widely accessible...our children’s willingness to bring us their questions.

The Real Competition Isn’t Information

I think it’s pretty obvious that parents are never going to win an information contest with AI, so we shouldn’t bother trying.

Your teenager can ask an AI system about anything in the world and receive a response in seconds. It can summarize a 400-page book before you’ve found your reading glasses. It can explain a math problem without reminding your child that they asked the same question yesterday. It can produce ten possible ways to phrase a difficult conversation while your teenager is still lying upside down across their bed.

The machine will be faster. It will sometimes be more patient.

So what do moms and dads offer?

This is so important to remember: parenting has never been primarily about transferring information. It’s just easier to think of it that way.

Explain the rule. Explain the principle. Explain the consequences. Explain the Bible verse. Explain it again.

I’ve done those exact things (more than once).

But as I’ve written in other posts, information can “inform” a person without actually forming them. That’s because true formation only happens through relationship, practice, modeling, responsibility, suffering, forgiveness, correction, and thousands of ordinary moments that seldom seem important while we’re living them.

AI can tell your child what courage means. But only you can show them what courage looks like by doing the right thing when you’d rather run away.

AI can explain forgiveness to your child. But only you can show them what forgiveness looks like by choosing to remain in relationship.

AI can tell your child that responsibility matters. But only you can give them real responsibility and allow them to experience the consequences of handling it poorly.

AI can tell your child that love is patient. But only you can demonstrate what that looks like when they test your patience and you respond by showing them you still love them, even when they are difficult to understand.

So...yeah...there is a world of difference between AI and parents in a child’s life.

Your Child Doesn’t Need Another Answer

I’ve also been thinking about this problem in light of something I’ve written before...our children don’t necessarily need more explanations from us.

Sometimes they need more experience. Sometimes they need to wrestle with something before we solve it for them. Sometimes they need to discover that they can survive a difficult conversation. Sometimes they need to know that making a mistake does not mean they have ruined everything. And sometimes they need to sit across from another human being who loves them enough to tell them something they don’t especially want to hear.

AI can answer a question, but it cannot assume responsibility for the person asking it. After all, a machine doesn’t have to live with the consequences of the advice it gives. It doesn’t have to stand beside your child when the friendship ends. It doesn’t have to apologize when it gets something wrong. It doesn’t have to persevere when your child becomes difficult, selfish, confused, rebellious, frightened, or simply exhausting.

But you do...and so do I.

And that’s at least part of why being a parent is the toughest job you’ll ever love.

What If the Question Isn’t About AI at All?

Perhaps the most useful thing we can do with all of this is to avoid turning every AI conversation into a conversation about AI.

When your teenager says, “I asked ChatGPT about it.”

Our instinct might be to respond, “Why are you asking a machine?”

“Do you know what kind of information it collects?”

“Don’t trust everything it tells you.”

All reasonable concerns. But perhaps the better first question is: “What were you trying to figure out?”

That question moves the conversation beyond the technology and toward your child. Their answer might be perfectly ordinary. It might also be something that matters deeply...or perhaps a question they have been afraid to ask you.

If any of this is true, then the most important thing happening in that moment isn’t the fact that AI exists.

It’s that your child has a question. So pay attention to the question.

Don’t Become Afraid Of The Machine

We should teach our children to think critically about AI.

Parents need to understand how their children are using these systems. That means having ongoing conversations about what AI can and cannot do, including its limitations around privacy, accuracy, bias, and manipulation. Children also need to learn that a system’s confident-sounding response is not necessarily a truthful or reliable one. For this reason, the American Psychological Association encourages parents to stay curious, discuss privacy openly, and build enough trust that children continue turning to people—not chatbots—for support.

With that said, we must avoid the temptation to use fear as our primary communication strategy. That conversation is never going to end well and besides, we’ve already tried that with a lot of other technology.

“Never use that.”

“Don’t talk to strangers online.”

“Your phone is ruining your attention span.”

“Social media is making your anxiety and depression worse.”

Some of those warnings contain important truths.

But children eventually have to learn how to navigate the world we actually gave them. So the objective is not to raise children who are frightened of AI, but to raise children who are not dependent on it for the things humans were meant to provide for one another.

What Your Child Still Needs From You

Your child still needs someone who knows them personally. Someone who remembers what happened last Tuesday. Someone who knows what makes them laugh. Someone who can recognize the difference between “I’m fine” and “I’m fine.” Someone who knows when to challenge them and when to let them be quiet. Someone who can say, “You’re wrong,” without making them feel worthless. Someone who can say, “I don’t know,” without losing credibility. Someone who can sit with them when there is nothing to fix. Someone who has enough history with them to understand what this moment means in the context of a much larger story.

In other words, the reason I beat this point to death is that someone cannot be replaced by a technological function, no matter how advanced it is.

It is always about relationship. And relationship takes time.

Which brings us to a sobering question: “If our children are increasingly surrounded by systems that are always available to respond to them, will we still be available to know them?”

Because AI may be able to give your child an answer at 11:47 on a Tuesday night.

But your child still needs to know where home is.

So What Should You Do?

If you were hoping for “Five Super Easy Rules Guaranteed to Help Your Child Deal With AI,” then I’m sorry to disappoint you. This is a complicated issue that cannot be reduced to a five-step formula. Still, there are a few things worth holding onto.

First, be curious. Ask your child how they use AI, what they like about it, whether it has ever helped them, and whether it has ever told them something they weren’t sure about. Not as an interrogation, but as an invitation. You will likely learn more from that conversation than you ever would from imposing another set of restrictions.

Second, keep the door open. Let your child bring you something awkward, embarrassing, or difficult without expecting an automatic lecture. You can still correct them and set boundaries, but make sure your relationship is strong enough to withstand honesty.

And finally, don’t outsource the ordinary work of relationship. Eat together. Drive together. Walk together. Ask questions. Listen to the long, boring story. Stay when the conversation gets uncomfortable. In an age when answers are easier than ever, those ordinary moments matter more than ever. Our children learn whom to trust not from explanations, but through years of experience with people who are faithful.

The Friend Your Child Can’t See

I have found myself thinking more deeply about what it means that my daughter can now ask questions of something that is available 24/7...not just a search engine or a tool, but something that responds, remembers, and can sound patient, thoughtful, and even personal.

The thought I kept returning to was that the issue was more than just our children’s access to a new source of information…it was their access to a new kind of relationship.

The good news is that we don’t need to compete with AI (we can’t). Nor do we need to panic (we shouldn’t). We just need to be the kind of people our children can trust with the questions that matter most.

Keep in mind that whatever answers AI does provide, it’s not the same thing as wisdom. It’s not the same thing as formation. And it’s definitely not the same thing as a human relationship.

There are questions in life that cannot be answered with information alone: Who am I? What is worth giving my life to? What do I do when I have hurt someone? What is love? What is true? What is good? What should I become?

Those questions lead us into the deeper realities that have always shaped human hearts and minds: relationship with God, life within a community, and the people who have been entrusted with our care.

And for our children, that journey ultimately brings them back to us.

So don’t be afraid that your child has a new friend you can’t see. Instead, pay attention to why they are talking to it. Are they curious? Lonely? Embarrassed? Are they looking for an answer they don’t believe they can get from to you?

The questions they ask AI reveal more than the answers they get. It shows what your child is carrying, what they fear, what they hope for, or what they are not yet sure how to say out loud.

And if you listen closely enough, you will discover that beneath the question they asked AI, is a child still looking for someone they can trust with the answer.

Because someday your child will face questions no AI program can answer for them.

And when that day comes, they won’t need another source of information.

They’ll need to know who they can trust.

Be. That. Person.

Get more from Daniel Hagadorn in the Substack app

Available for iOS and Android

Get the app

DALLAS WILLARD (1935-2013) | What kind of person am I going to be?

I’m probably the only parent who has ever had a conversation like this with their child, but here it goes...

“Did you do your homework?”

“Yeah.”

“Are you sure?”

“Yes.”

“Then why is your computer still open to YouTube?”

You look at her.

She looks at you.

For a moment, neither of you says anything.

Then comes the familiar sequence.

“Because I was taking a break.”

“A break from what?”

“Homework.”

“How long have you been on YouTube?”

“I don’t know.”

“Give me your phone.”

And just like that, an otherwise ordinary evening has now become a full-blown investigation.

Perhaps you’ve lived some version of this scene (or maybe it’s just me).

You ask a question because something doesn’t feel right and your child responds with an answer that doesn’t quite add up. So, you ask another question. Then another. Before long, you’re looking for evidence, reconstructing the “crime scene”, and checking their story for inconsistencies.

By the end of the conversation, your child feels interrogated. Because... basically...they were interrogated.

And you feel exhausted.

Somewhere along the way, parenting began to feel less like raising a child and more like policing one. That’s a difficult place to be.

No parent sets out to become the chief law enforcement officer of their own home. We don’t wake up one morning and decide that we want to devote our waking hours to monitoring behavior, investigating suspicious activity, issuing warnings, and handing out consequences.

Like almost everything else in life, it happens so gradually that we barely take notice of it.

You’re tired. You’ve already asked three times. The same problems keep coming back, and patience doesn’t seem to be working.

The answer? Vigilance. You watch more closely, correct more quickly, establish another rule, and add another consequence all while fully convinced that if you aren’t paying attention every second, the whole thing will completely fall apart.

I’ve known that feeling. Most parents have.

There is something especially exhausting about the realization that you seem to be spending a considerable part of your life managing the behavior of people who don’t particularly appreciate being managed.

Children can make that job remarkably difficult. They forget what you just told them, test boundaries you thought were perfectly clear, and can somehow hear a bag of chips opening from three rooms away while claiming they didn’t hear you call their name.

Yes...children need correction. They need boundaries. They need parents who are willing to say “no” and mean it.

But there is still a world of difference between being a parent with authority and becoming the chief law enforcement officer in your own home.

The Problem With Living On Patrol

While a police officer is primarily concerned with law enforcement, a good parent has to take a much larger view of things.

After all, we’re trying to raise a human being.

That probably sounds painfully obvious, but it’s surprisingly easy to forget when you’re standing in the kitchen looking at the same dirty bowl in the sink for the fourth day in a row. The immediate problem is the bowl, but the larger question is what you’re trying to teach...responsibility, consideration for others, and the ability to care for one’s own possessions and living environment.

These are not insignificant lessons because someday your child will live in a world where you aren’t there to remind them about dirty bowls.

That’s the part of parenting we can easily lose sight of when every day is reduced to a series of corrections. Before long, we start measuring success by compliance.

Did my child do what I said? Did my child stop? Did my child follow the rule?

Those are all important questions. A child who never learns how to respond to authority will have a very, very difficult time navigating the world.

Obedience, however, is not the final destination. Our objective is forming a person who is capable of governing themselves.

That’s where policing and parenting begin to move in different directions. A police officer maintains order, while a parent is helping a child become the kind of person who can eventually bring order to their own life.

That’s a much slower and messier process.

When Every Interaction Becomes An Investigation

Something...just...changes in a home when parents are suspicious of everything.

You start asking questions because you’re trying to catch your child in something.

“Did you finish your homework?”

“Are you telling me the truth?”

“Why is your door closed?”

“Who are you texting?”

“What exactly happened?”

And sometimes, those questions are absolutely necessary. Parents have a responsibility to know what is happening in their children’s lives. Still, it’s worth asking ourselves what kind of atmosphere we’re creating.

Does my child experience me as someone who wants to know them? Or someone who is looking for evidence of a crime?

Children know the difference.

They may not have the language for it, but they know when a conversation feels like an interrogation. They know when you’re asking because you care and when you’re asking because you’ve already decided they’re guilty.

Here is where this gets really challenging for parents...sometimes our suspicion creates some of the secrecy we’re trying to prevent.

If our children believe that every mistake will produce an interrogation, then it increases the likelihood that they will become highly skilled at avoiding one.

Now, that’s definitely not an excuse for dishonesty. Children should learn that trust matters and that lying damages relationships. But we should also be honest with ourselves about our part in this.

If telling us the truth always feels dangerous, then our children may very well decide that hiding it feels safer.

That is not the relationship we want with our children.

We want them to come to us, e-s-p-e-c-i-a-l-l-y when they have made a mistake, feel confused, or are afraid.

The irony is that we want our children to tell us the truth, yet we can unintentionally create an environment in which honesty feels far too costly.

Authority Is Not The Same Thing As Control

This may be one of the most difficult lines to draw in parenting.

Control says: I need to make sure you do what I want.

Authority says: I am responsible for helping you become capable of doing what is right, even when I am no longer around.

On the outside, these two approaches can look very similar. Both involve rules, consequences, and sometimes a parent saying “no.”

The difference is in the purpose behind the line.

Control is usually driven by some form of fear: fear that your child will embarrass you, fear that you’re losing influence, fear that if you don’t stop this behavior immediately it will become permanent, or fear that you’re failing as a parent.

At the risk of stating the obvious, fear can make us kind of intense. I’ve seen parents become deeply frustrated because, in the moment, their child’s behavior seemed to represent something much larger than the behavior itself.

A teenager rolls their eyes, and suddenly it’s no longer about an eye roll. It feels like a sign of total disrespect. A child forgets an assignment, and somehow we’re imagining a future in which they can’t keep a job. A daughter makes a decision we don’t understand, and we’re already wondering whether we’ve lost her.

That’s a lot of weight to place on one moment.

Sometimes our strongest reactions aren’t really about what just happened but what we’re afraid might happen next. And when fear drives our parenting, we often become controlling even while convincing ourselves that we’re simply being responsible.

Your Child Is More Than The Behavior You’re Trying To Stop

Every parent has a behavior they wish would disappear.

Maybe your child lies, argues about everything, explodes when they don’t get their way, or has become withdrawn. Or, maybe you’re dealing with something much more serious than any of those things.

To be clear, behavior matters. It has consequences, and loving parents don’t ignore destructive behavior. But behavior also communicates.

That’s not to say that every bad choice has a hidden psychological explanation absolving our children from personal responsibility. Sometimes a child simply wants what they want. Sometimes they know better and make a poor choice anyway.

Welcome to being human.

Still, good parents learn to ask other, much more important questions.

What else might be happening here? What is my child afraid of? What does my child believe? What is my child trying to protect? What does this behavior accomplish for my child? What has my child learned about getting what they want?

Those questions don’t replace discipline, but they do help us discipline with greater understanding.

A police officer sees an offense and responds to the offense. A parent has the harder task of responding to the behavior while continuing to see the person.

Your child needs to know that a bad choice does not make him or her a bad child. Correction should always leave room for relationship, and whenever possible, consequences should teach rather than punish.

We also need to remember something that is easy to forget in the midst of a difficult afternoon…our child is still learning how to become a person. And so are we.

The Parent Behind The Correction

We have to be willing to ask hard questions of ourselves and then have compassion for our answers. We are all learning are we not?

Eventually, if we’re honest, we will ask what is happening inside us when we correct our children.

Why does this particular behavior make me so angry? Why do I need to win this argument? Why does my child’s resistance feel like a personal rejection? Why am I so afraid to let this situation unfold? Why do I feel responsible for managing every outcome?

Those are all uncomfortable questions…but they need to be asked.

Parenting has a unique way of revealing things about us that might otherwise remain hidden. You may discover that you need your child’s cooperation because you are already feeling overwhelmed. You may realize that disrespect bothers you so deeply because of experiences you had long before you became a parent. You may find that your child’s struggles awaken fears about failure, your reputation, or the future.

None of that makes you a terrible parent. It makes you a human parent.

Understanding ourselves is especially important here because children can tell when our discipline is for their own good and when we’ve reached the point where we’re simply venting our own frustration out on them.

They may not describe it that way. But trust me, they know.

Most of us can remember what it felt like to be corrected by an adult who was trying to teach us something. Most of us can also remember what it felt like to be the nearest available target for someone’s bad day.

Needless to say, those experiences are entirely different. And our children deserve parents who are willing to notice the difference.

So What Does A Parent Do?

You don’t need to become softer or abandon the use of consequences. You don’t need to negotiate every expectation or explain every decision until everyone is completely satisfied.

Your child still needs to know that you mean what you say. Despite their protestations to the contrary, clear authority is profoundly reassuring to them.

The real question is whether your authority is serving your child’s formation or simply making your life more convenient.

The next time you need to correct your child, try to slow down long enough to ask a few questions (sometimes easier said than done).

First, what actually happened?

Try to respond to reality rather than the story you’ve already started telling yourself about what this behavior means. A forgotten chore may be irresponsibility. Or, it may also just be a forgotten chore.

Second, what does my child need from me right now?

That answer will sometimes be a consequence and sometimes it will be a conversation. Sometimes your child needs help learning how to do something they genuinely don’t know how to do yet. At other times, they need you to let the consequences do the talking.

Third, what am I bringing into this moment?

Are you correcting your child, or reacting to your own exhaustion or frustration? Do you need to address the behavior, or do you need a few minutes before you address anything?

That pause can change a lot more than we realize. Finally, ask yourself:

What am I trying to help my child become?

That single question changes the entire conversation.

When your goal is behavior modification, you’ll usually do whatever seems most effective in the moment. When your goal is formation, you take into consideration what the child needs to learn over time.

This allows you to see discipline as part of a much larger story about a child who learns that choices matter, other people matter, freedom and responsibility belong together, mistakes can be faced honestly, consequences are real, and love does not disappear when someone has done something wrong.

The Kind Of Authority Children Need

Children need parents who are willing to lead, who hold firm expectations even when those expectations make their children unhappy, and who give them room to grow without living under constant surveillance.

They need parents who are present and attentive, yet wise enough to know when to step in and when to let them learn from experience. They need parents who can say, “No, that’s not acceptable,” without turning every conflict into a battle for control, and who understand that authority is never diminished by compassion.

Most importantly, parents need to remember where all of this is ultimately headed.

One day, your child will make decisions without you. You won’t be there to remind them…monitor every choice they make…or always know what happened.

That isn’t a failure of parenting. It’s where parenting is supposed to go.

As American lawyer Frank A. Clark (1860–1936) wisely observed, “The most important thing that parents can teach their children is how to get along without them.”

Little by little, we give our children more responsibility in the hopes that they will eventually learn to carry it for themselves.

So the real question isn’t whether you can control your child today. It’s whether you’re helping them become someone capable of governing themselves tomorrow.

There’s no simple formula for raising a human being, of course, but the work requires something like this:

Authority + Boundaries + Consequences + Relationship = The gradual formation of a person capable of governing themselves

Your child is not a problem to be managed or a suspect to be monitored. They are an image-bearer of God entrusted to your care.

And one day, the child you’re now reminding, correcting, questioning, and sometimes wondering whether you’re going to survive will walk out into the world and begin making decisions without you.

Learning to listen to you and respond to your authority is an important part of growing up, but it was never meant to be the final destination. The deeper goal is to help them become someone who knows how to choose what is right when you’re no longer there to tell them.

Your child doesn’t need a police officer.

They need a parent willing to prepare them for that day.

Get more from Daniel Hagadorn in the Substack app

Available for iOS and Android

Get the app

DALLAS WILLARD | What a child does when not told what to do is the final indicator of what and who that child is.

HENRI J. M. NOUWEN | Whereas discipline without discipleship leads to rigid formalism, discipleship without discipline ends in sentimental romanticism.

You might think the problem is that your child doesn’t listen, but it may surprise you that “listening” is almost never the problem. Instead, somewhere along the way, it is far more likely that you both learned the first request doesn’t really count.

Here is a moment that every parent knows (maybe too well).

You ask your child to do something simple…

“Please put your shoes away.”

Nothing happens.

A few minutes pass.

“Hey, I asked you to put your shoes away.”

“I will.”

And then you move on because there are other things to do. Dinner needs to be made. Someone needs a ride. Someone needs help with their homework. The dog probably needs to be let out. Parenting has a way of filling every available space.

A few minutes later, the shoes are still sitting in the middle of the floor.

“Did you hear me?”

“Yes.”

And now…you feel…something…shift.

It isn’t quite anger yet, although it’s definitely getting there.

“Then why are your shoes still in the middle of the floor?”

A shrug.

So you ask again.

And maybe by the fifth time, it isn’t really a request anymore.

“PUT. YOUR. SHOES. AWAY. NOW.”

Even as the words come out, you hear yourself.

You didn’t want to sound like that and you certainly didn’t plan to sound like that.

Yet here you are, standing in the hallway, angry about a pair of shoes. Except you aren’t really angry about the shoes.

That’s the part we’re going to talk about.

Your Child Probably Heard You

In situations like this, the most common conclusion we reach for is that our children aren’t listening. Sometimes they aren’t. They’re kids. They get distracted. They become absorbed in what they’re doing. They forget. They genuinely miss what we said.

However…if you find yourself giving the same instruction three, four, or five times a day, it is worth considering another possibility.

Your child may have learned a pattern you never intended to teach.

The first request isn’t necessarily the one that requires action. Neither is the second. Maybe the third doesn’t matter that much either.

The real request comes later, after the reminders, the warnings, the change in tone, and finally the raised voice.

Children are remarkably good at learning patterns. They pay attention to what consistently happens, even when nobody sits down and teaches them the lesson.

If the first request rarely requires a response, your child learns to wait.

Usually this isn’t a conscious decision. Your child isn’t sitting on the couch thinking, Dad asked me three times, so I’ll wait until he gets really mad.

The lesson is a lot simpler than that.

I have some time.

If mom or dad eventually raise their voice, the child learns something else.

That’s when mom or dad really means it.

Obviously, neither of you chose this arrangement, but it has been practiced enough to become familiar.

How A Pattern Gets Built

“I’m going to create a home where everyone waits for someone to get angry before doing whatever they were asked to do”, said no parent EVER.

This is the kind of thing that happens, like most everything else, in ordinary moments.

You’re tired. You’re busy. You’re trying to get everybody out the door.

You ask your son to put his backpack away, then remember that you also need him to feed the dog. You remind him about the backpack while answering a text. He says he’ll do it. You believe him because you don’t have the energy to turn it into a conversation.

Then you walk past the backpack again.

And again.

Eventually, because you’re human, you get frustrated.

So, the next time, you start with a sharper voice because you already know where this is going.

Over time, the pattern becomes almost a reflex.

The child waits. The parent reminds. The child delays. The parent gets frustrated. The parent escalates. The child finally moves. Everybody gets through the moment…and everybody has learned something.

The child has learned that urgency eventually appears. The parent has learned that urgency eventually works.

So the cycle repeats.

This is one of the strangest things about family life. We create systems without ever consciously deciding to create them and then just repeat whatever seems to work in the moment. Then, time passes, and the thing that worked in the moment becomes the way the operating system for the household.

The Part We Don’t Like To Admit

At some point, our frustration stops being about the shoes.

It becomes: “Why aren’t you listening to me?”

Then: “Why do I have to keep saying this?”

And sometimes, underneath that: “Do my words matter to you?”

That’s where a small parenting problem can suddenly escalate into a much larger emotional event. Because our forgotten instruction begins to feel like disrespect. A delayed response begins to feel like defiance. A child who is simply moving slowly suddenly seems to be making a rebellious statement about our authority.

And now you aren’t just asking for shoes to be put away. You are asking to be acknowledged.

This happens to good parents. In fact, it has probably happened to every parent who has ever been responsible for getting another human being from breakfast to bedtime.

The danger is in our interpretation.

When we attach too much meaning to an ordinary act of childhood, our response becomes larger than the situation requires.

The shoes, the eye roll, the unfinished homework all become evidence. And before long, we aren’t responding to what is happening in front of us, we’re responding to what we have decided that it means.

That distinction cannot be overstated.

Authority Is Not the Same As Control

There is a difference between authority and control, and parenting becomes much simpler (not easier) when we understand it.

Control is connected to our own emotional state. We need our child to do something because we need the situation to feel settled or complete. When our child doesn’t cooperate, our sense of order begins to crumble, and we reach for whatever seems capable of restoring it.

Authority has an entirely different center.

A parent is responsible for their children…and that responsibility includes teaching them how to live responsibly.

The question here is less, “How do I make my child do what I want?” and more “What does my child need to learn here?”

That second question also changes our response.

A controlling parent tends to become more intense when challenged whereas a steady parent can remain calm because their authority does not depend upon “winning the moment.”

The expectation is clear and the child understands what is being asked.

The parent follows through and the consequence, when one is necessary, is predictably appropriate rather than emotional.

It’s weird how that kind of authority can feel almost uneventful, but that’s also part of its strength.

Children need to know where the edges of their world are. They need adults whose words they can trust and whose responses aren’t determined by the temperature of the room.

What Your Child Is Learning

Every ordinary moment in our homes is teaching something. Your child is learning whether your words mean what they say. Whether responsibility is real. Whether consequences are predictable. Whether authority is calm or reactive. Whether mistakes can be repaired. Whether love remains constant when someone is disappointed.

And almost all of this is taught without a single lecture. It happens through repetition. Through tone. Through consistency. Through what actually happens after the words are spoken.

This is one of parenting’s most humbling realities…we are always teaching something.

Sometimes we are teaching what we intended and sometimes we are teaching something else entirely.

For instance, you can tell your child that responsibility matters while repeatedly rescuing them from the consequences of avoiding it. You can tell your child to control their temper while allowing your own frustration to control the environment. You can tell your child to listen while giving instructions from another room and expecting them to immediately drop everything.

That isn’t hypocrisy. It’s humanity. So cut yourselves some slack (I’m looking at you mom and dad).

We are all learning.

And just to be clear, the goal isn’t to become “the parent who never gets frustrated.” The goal is to become increasingly aware of what our frustration is teaching.

So What Do You Do?

The answer isn’t to become stricter. It is to become clearer.

Start with one small change.

Say what you mean. If something needs to be done, give the instruction clearly enough that your child knows what you expect.

Get their attention…make the request…give them the opportunity to respond.

“Please put your shoes in the closet.”

That’s different from saying it while walking through the room, answering a question, and hoping they heard you.

Make the expectation concrete.

“Clean your room” is a classic because it can mean almost anything to a child.

Put the books on the shelf? Put the dirty clothes in the hamper? Make the bed? Put the shoes away?

Clarity removes at least some of the unnecessary friction between parent and child.

Don’t train your child to wait for the fifth request. If you’ve said it, let it mean something. And that requires follow-through.

If your child chooses not to do what you’ve asked, there should be a consequence that fits the situation and is delivered calmly.

“I asked you to put your shoes away. You chose not to. Here’s what happens now.”

Then stop [hint: this is the hardest part].

You don’t need to add everything your child has done since birth (or even last Tuesday). Don’t make obedience a referendum on your relationship.

Your child’s failure to put away a pair of shoes does not necessarily indicate a lack of respect. Your teenager’s eye roll doesn’t necessarily mean your authority has been lost. A delayed response doesn’t necessarily reveal a character defect in your child.

Sometimes, it’s just a kid being a kid, so correct the behavior without turning it into a verdict on the person.

Stay the parent. Don’t take on the role of “negotiator” or “prosecutor” (as tempting as that may be).

Without matching your child’s emotional intensity, remain the adult responsible for the situation (think calm, clear, and consistent).

I’m not going sugarcoat this…it’s a much harder form of authority than yelling because it requires something from us first.

Self-control.

Ask Yourself

One way to develop self-control is by asking yourself this question and then responding honestly. (But before you do, a word of advice. Don’t ask this while you’re angry and the house is in total chaos):

“What did I actually teach?”

Not what did I intend to teach.

“What did I actually teach?”

Did I teach that my words matter? Did I teach that responsibility is real? Did I teach that consequences can be predictable? Did I teach that correction can happen without humiliation? Did I teach my child that love remains constant even when I’m disappointed?

And this is where it gets really uncomfortable. Then ask yourself:

“Did I model what I am asking from my child?”

Because children pay attention to what we repeat and they take notice of what happens when we are frustrated. They learn how we handle disappointment. They watch whether our character survives the moments when life is inconvenient.

That can be uncomfortable to admit…but it can also be encouraging.

Because it means that every ordinary moment gives us another opportunity to teach something better.

You Don’t Have To Ask Five Times

As you have probably already guessed, the goal here isn’t instant obedience.

Children are…well…children.

They forget. They become distracted. They resist. They test limits. They get absorbed in whatever seems enormously important to them at the moment.

(By the way, parents do many of those same things, just with better vocabulary).

No, the goal is something much deeper: a home where your words carry weight because they are trusted, and where responsibility becomes part of your child’s character over time. You want to be able to speak without raising your voice, knowing that your authority does not depend on how loudly it is exercised.

And if you’ve already built the five-request pattern? Don’t despair because you can change it.

Now, I’m not saying it will happen overnight. After all, your child has already become very familiar with the old pattern, and will likely test whether you really mean what you’re saying when you begin doing things differently.

That’s okay.

You don’t have to create a PowerPoint slide deck to announce a new parenting philosophy at dinner, “The New Era of Household Accountability.”

Just start with the next request. Say what you mean. Make it clear. Follow through. And stay calm.

Then do it again tomorrow.

Eventually, something will begin to shift.

You stop asking five times. Your child doesn’t become perfect but you become more predictable. Your words become more trustworthy as the the household loses it dependence upon on escalation.

And one day you may still find a pair of shoes sitting in the middle of the floor.

You look at them. You look at your child. And you simply say, “Shoes, please.”

No big lecture. No emotional outburst. No passive aggressive threat.

Just an ordinary expectation in an ordinary home.

And that’s really the deeper work of parenting.

Because this was never really about putting shoes away…it’s about helping our children learn how responsibility works.

At the same time, we are learning what authority looks like when it isn't driven by fear, and how to let our children be difficult without becoming unsettled by it. We are learning, slowly, to remain calm and consistent when the people we love don't do what we ask.

That’s formation.

And it happens in the middle of the hallway, one ordinary moment at a time.

Get more from Daniel Hagadorn in the Substack app

Available for iOS and Android

Get the app

VIKTOR E. FRANKL (1905-1997) | When we are no longer able to change a situation, we are challenged to change ourselves.

One of the most common pieces of parenting advice I hear sounds perfectly reasonable on the surface:

“Just be better than your parents.”

At first glance, it seems wise. Most of us would have no trouble identifying things our parents got wrong. We remember the words that wounded us, the opportunities they missed, the fears they passed on, the ways they misunderstood us, and the moments when we wished they had shown up differently.

If we are honest, many of us carry a quiet determination to make sure our children never experience what we experienced growing up.

That desire usually comes from a good place. We love our children. We want better for them than what we had. We want to spare them unnecessary pain and provide opportunities we lacked. There is something noble in that impulse.

But there is also a problem.

Becoming the opposite of our parents is not the same thing as becoming who we were meant to be.

Some of the most emotionally exhausted parents I know are spending enormous amounts of energy trying not to become their mothers or fathers. They are so focused on avoiding their parent’s mistakes that they never stop to ask a deeper question: Who am I becoming?

After thirty years of working with young people and their families, I am convinced that one of the greatest dangers facing parents today is not that they will repeat every mistake their parents made. It is that those mistakes will continue shaping their lives from the shadows.

The past holds enormous power over us, not necessarily because it “controls” us, but because it influences our core foundational beliefs (what we believe about God, ourselves, other people, and how life works). Long after the original events have passed, the conclusions we drew from those events often remain.

L. P. Hartley (1895-1972) famously began The Go-Between with a sentence that captures an important insight into our relationship with childhood: “The past is a foreign country; they do things differently there.”

Sometimes we forget that.

We remember what happened, but we continue responding as though we are still living there.

Several years ago, I carried a tremendous amount of anger toward my father. My childhood was marked by experiences that left deep wounds. Then, after my mom suffered a cardiac arrest when I was eight years old, my whole life literally changed overnight.

She never fully recovered, and for the next thirteen years my dad and I became her primary caregivers. We fed her, cared for her, and watched helplessly as her condition affected nearly every aspect of our daily lives.

My dad carried burdens I could not fully understand at the time. He was a man shaped by hardships that would destroy most people. Raised during the Great Depression and surrounded by abuse, poverty, tragedy, and loss, he learned brutally hard lessons about survival, but virtually nothing about healing.

And survival and healing are definitely not the same.

The cumulative weight of his pain often emerged in ways neither of us understood back then. As the years passed, our relationship became increasingly fractured. Resentment hardened into bitterness, and bitterness eventually deepened into hatred.

For a long time, my number one goal in life was to avoid ever becoming like my dad. It seemed like a perfectly reasonable goal, especially when I could see things in myself that reminded me of him.

The problem was that I was still allowing him to define me.

I was looking backward, asking myself who I did not want to become, rather than looking forward and asking who I was called to become.

That’s an important distinction [insert ‘understatement of the year’ here].

The opposite of a prison is still a prison if someone else controls the walls.

Eventually, through a lot of grief work, forgiveness, and God’s patient healing, I reached the turning point that I noted earlier. I stopped asking, “How do I avoid becoming my father?” and started asking, “Who did God create me to become?”

The first question is organized around fear, but the second is organized around purpose.

Many parents today are unknowingly raising their children from a place of reaction. For example, if their parents were authoritarian, they become permissive. If their parents were emotionally distant, they become emotionally over-involved. If their parents controlled everything, they reject all forms of authority. If their parents neglected them, they attempt to meet every need immediately.

The specific reaction matters less than the reality underneath it because fear is still driving the car.

And whenever fear becomes our primary guide, it distorts reality. This is one of the most important lessons I have learned both in the classroom and in life. Unfortunately, fear has a remarkable ability to disguise itself as wisdom. It sounds responsible. It sounds protective. It can even sound loving.

But fear never produces the fruit we hope it will.

C. S. Lewis (1898-1963) understood something about this when he wrote, “There is no safe investment. To love at all is to be vulnerable.”

That is one of the hardest things for a parent (or anyone) to accept.

We want to protect our children from the things that hurt us. We want to make different choices from the choices our parents made. We want to create a home where our children feel safe, loved, understood, and prepared for life.

But there is no way to guarantee that.

Our children will experience disappointment. They will be misunderstood. Someone will hurt them. They will make decisions we wish they hadn’t made. They will experience losses we cannot prevent. Eventually, they will have to learn how to live in a world that is not safe simply because we love them.

So, our job is not to eliminate every possibility of pain…it is to teach them how to live faithfully while navigating reality.

That begins with us.

Sometimes the strongest reactions we have to our children have less to do with what they are doing and more to do with what their behavior triggers in us. A child talks back, and suddenly we are eight years old again. A teenager pulls away, and an old fear of rejection comes roaring back. A child fails, and we experience their failure as though it were somehow our own.

Our child is standing in front of us, but sometimes we lose ourselves to a memory, responding to someone else entirely.

This is why self-awareness matters so much in parenting. Not because we need to spend our lives analyzing ourselves, but because our children should not have to carry wounds they did not create. They should not have to spend their childhood managing our unresolved childhood.

To be clear, this doesn’t mean we should pretend our past never happened. Quite the opposite. We have to be willing to tell the truth about it. This hurt me. This changed me. I learned something from it. I made some conclusions because of it. Some of those conclusions were probably true. Some probably weren’t. And now I get to decide what I will carry forward (*warning: I’m going to repeat these points a lot).

That is the beginning of freedom.

Scripture offers a sobering picture of what happens when pain is left unresolved. The book of Hebrews warns us to “see to it that no one fails to obtain the grace of God” and that no “root of bitterness” springs up and causes trouble.

This is not simply a warning about anger; it is a warning about what happens when pain takes root and bitterness begins to spread.

It affects marriages. It affects friendships. It affects our relationship with God. And eventually, if we are not careful, it affects the way we raise our children.

That is why healing is different from forgetting.

Where did we get the idea that healing means reaching a point where somehow the past no longer hurts? That’s not how it works. All wounds matter and the scars left behind are proof of that.

But what if there is no scar because the wound is still open? Sometimes we just get used to the pain without ever healing from it. And then, if enough time passes, we mistake familiarity for healing.

We should never pretend nothing happened…but we need to stop allowing what happened to dictate our choices going forward.

That was a major part of what I learned in my relationship with my dad. Forgiveness did not mean deciding that everything he did was acceptable. It did not mean pretending that what happened in my childhood didn’t happen. It did not mean erasing the anger.

It meant telling the truth about what happened without allowing my anger to become the author of the rest of my story. That’s one of the most incredible gifts of grief work.

We learn to distinguish between the loss itself and the unfinished business we continue carrying because of it. And parents have a tremendous amount of unfinished business.

Some of it comes from our parents. Some from our marriages. Some from our children. Some from the expectations we had for our families that never became reality. Some of it comes from the person we thought we would become. And some of it comes from the childhood we wish we had experienced.

But if we don’t deal with those losses honestly, we will spend years trying to make our children compensate for them.

Although we will never never consciously think it or say it out loud, we begin asking our children, in a thousand subtle ways, to give us the childhood we never had.

That is a burden no child should have to carry.

So what should we do? Maybe the answer is not to be better than our parents. Maybe the answer is to become more honest about what shaped us.

Pay attention to the moments when your reaction seems bigger than the situation. Ask yourself why. Notice what you are afraid of. Notice the things you are determined never to repeat.

Then ask yourself a different question: What would love require of me here?

Not permissiveness. Not control. Not whatever happens to be the opposite of what your parents did. Love.

The kind of love that tells the truth. The kind of love that establishes boundaries. The kind of love that apologizes (and means it). The kind of love that lets a child experience appropriate consequences. The kind of love that does not confuse protection with control. And sometimes, the kind of love that can simply say, “I was wrong.”

But I have no idea what your childhood was like.

Maybe you had wonderful parents. Maybe you had parents who did the best they could while carrying wounds of their own. Maybe you had parents who hurt you deeply. Maybe you are still angry. Maybe you are still grieving. Maybe you have spent years trying to make sure your children never experience what you experienced.

If that is you, I totally understand the impulse.

I lived there myself (in fact, I built a house there).

But your children don’t need you to spend your life running away from the people who raised you. They need you to become the person God created you to be.

Okay, that sounds nice, but what does it look like in real life? It may mean learning to be more patient, finding the courage to do what is difficult, or learning to say, “I was wrong.” It may mean setting a boundary you were never taught to set, or giving your children something your parents never knew how to give you.

And sometimes it may mean grieving what you did not receive.

That last one is especially important.

Because you cannot change your childhood. You cannot go back and get the father you needed. You cannot make your mother say the words she never said. You cannot rewrite the family story.

But you can decide what happens with the pain you inherited.

There are really only three options. You can carry it. You can pass it on. Or you can begin the hard work of healing it.

This is where Grief Recovery becomes so important.

Grief Recovery is not a program that blames our parents, or rewrites history, or pretends the past didn’t matter. Instead, it helps us honestly identify the losses we have experienced, acknowledge the unfinished business those losses have left behind, and take responsibility for what we do with them now.

Hebrews 12 gives us a picture of bitterness taking root. Grief Recovery gives us a practical way to deal with the losses that create those roots.

Because eventually every parent has to answer a question that is much more important than, “Was I better than my parents?”

What did I do with what I was given?

Maybe your parents gave you some things worth keeping. Maybe they gave you some things you need to lay down. Maybe they wounded you. Maybe they loved you imperfectly.

In all likelihood, it was probably some combination of all the above.

But their story does not have to become your destiny. And your wounds do not have to become your children’s inheritance.

You can grieve what you lost. You can forgive what needs to be forgiven. You can take responsibility for the unfinished business that remains.

Instead of spending the rest of your life trying not to become someone else, you can begin becoming who you were created to be.

That is the greatest gift of all.

Get more from Daniel Hagadorn in the Substack app

Available for iOS and Android

Get the app

ELLEN G. WHITE (1827-1915) | The greatest want of the world is the want of men [...] who will not be bought or sold; men who in their inmost souls are true and honest.

RALPH WALDO EMERSON (1803-1882) | What you are speaks so loudly that I cannot hear what you say.

I believe there is a subtle lie that has settled into the bones of modern parenting. It quietly shows up in the way we measure success, in the questions we ask, and in the subtle (and not so subtle) anxieties we carry. It tries to convince us that if our children are safe, successful, and well-adjusted…if doors open for them and opportunities abound…then we have done our job well. It assures us that the goal is to position them advantageously in the world they are about to inherit.

But Scripture presses in with a deeper, more demanding vision. When Proverbs tells us that a good man leaves an inheritance to his children’s children, it is not speaking primarily about wealth or status, but about something far more enduring. In the Hebrew imagination, inheritance is not merely what is transferred…it’s what is formed. It is identity, character, and the shaping of a life that will echo into a time beyond what we can see. And that raises a rather unsettling question: what, exactly, are we passing down?

The Difference Between Success And Formation

At its deepest core, parenting is not about managing behavior or optimizing outcomes. It is about formation. Dallas Willard (1935-2013) often emphasized that every human life is being shaped into a particular kind of person, whether intentionally or not. So the issue is never whether formation is happening, but rather what is doing the forming. And in a world that constantly pulls at our attention, this question has only become more urgent.

Neil Postman (1931-2003) warned decades ago that we were becoming a culture defined by distraction. A culture that trades depth for amusement and substitutes information for wisdom. That observation seems more prescient than ever. Our children are growing up in an environment that increasingly rewards image over substance and performance over identity, and it is into that environment that parents are encouraged to primarily focus on preparation for success.

But the biblical vision is so much more than helping children successfully navigate the world. It’s about helping them become the kind of people who can stand firm within it, and when necessary, stand apart from it. That kind of formation cannot be outsourced, and it cannot be reduced to a set of techniques or strategies. It begins with a far more foundational reality: understanding who our children actually are.

Image-Bearers, Not Projects

From the opening pages of Scripture, we are told that human beings are made in the image of God. This is not a poetic flourish but a defining truth. Therefore, your child is not a project to be managed, nor an extension of your identity, nor a vessel for your unfulfilled ambitions. Your child is an image-bearer—someone designed to reflect the character, creativity, and authority of God into the world. The work of theologian Michael Heiser (1963-2023) consistently pointed to a profound biblical truth: humanity was created to share in God's governance of creation, bearing His image in ways that extend order, beauty, and goodness into the world He made.

If we allow that reality to settle into our hearts, it literally reframes the entire task of parenting. Control? No. Stewardship? Yes. The aim then, is not simply compliance, but formation into a life that is aligned with the heart of God. And that kind of formation does not happen primarily through what we say, but through who we are.

We Become What We Worship

G. K. Beale’s insight that we become what we worship goes directly to the center of this issue. Our lives are always oriented toward something, and over time, that orientation shapes us. If our lives are centered on comfort…we will become fragile. If centered on success…we will become anxious and driven. If centered on control…we will become fearful. But if our lives are centered on God, something entirely different begins to take shape.

This is where parenting becomes deeply personal, because our children are not ultimately formed by our instructions but by our lives. As I have repeatedly noted in my blog posts, they are extraordinarily perceptive. They notice what we prioritize, how we respond under pressure, and whether our words align with our actions. C. S. Lewis (1898-1963) warned about the danger of raising “men without chests”…people who are intellectually capable but morally hollow. That hollowing is not the result of information scarcity, but from a lack of lived integrity.

In that sense, character is “caught not taught.” It is absorbed through countless small interactions, through the tone of our voice, the consistency of our actions, and the authenticity of our responses. Which is why one of the greatest threats to a meaningful legacy is not failure, but pretense.

Whatever We Don’t Deal With…Our Children Will

And yet, there is another layer beneath all of this that is often left unaddressed (though it may be the most influential factor of all): the role of unresolved pain. Gabor Maté has written extensively about how unprocessed trauma and emotional wounds shape our perceptions, our reactions, and our relationships. Scripture articulates this reality in its own language when it speaks of patterns being passed down from one generation to the next.

This is not a statement of fatalism, but of recognition. What remains unhealed in one generation will reappear in another, not because it must, but because it has not yet been confronted. It shows up in moments of disproportionate anger, in the need for control that feels like responsibility, in emotional distance that is mistaken for strength. These patterns are rarely intentional, but they are deeply formative.

This is why the work of the Grief Recovery Institute resonates so strongly with what Scripture has been pointing to all along. Unresolved grief does not stay contained…it accumulates and expresses itself in the way we engage with others, especially those closest to us. For parents, this means that one of the most significant investments we can make in our children is in our own healing.

That realization can feel heavy, but it is also profoundly hopeful. It means that cycles are not inevitable. They can be interrupted. And that interruption begins with something both simple and difficult: honesty.

FRANK A. CLARK (1860-1936) | A father is a man who expects his son to be as good a man as he meant to be.

There comes a moment in every parent’s life when the gap between who we hoped to be and how we actually show up becomes undeniable. In that moment, the temptation is to defend, justify, or minimize. But there is another path, one that is far more powerful in the long run. It is the willingness to take responsibility, to acknowledge where we have fallen short, and to pursue restoration.

What is often described as “Own Your Stuff” is not just catchy cliche…it’s a relational turning point. When a parent admits fault, asks for forgiveness, and does so sincerely, it communicates something more than competence ever could. It demonstrates humility and a commitment to truth that builds trust over time. And in a world that prioritizes image over integrity, that kind of honesty stands out.

How Character Is Formed One Choice At A Time

Children do not need perfect parents (whew…what a relief). In fact, the pursuit of perfection creates more distance than connection. What they need are parents who are present, who are willing to be known, and who create an environment where honesty is safe. John Eldredge often speaks about the deep questions of the human heart—the longing to be seen, to be valued, and to be secure in relationship. Those longings are the realities that are lived out in the daily interactions between parent and child.

And this is where legacy begins to take on its true meaning. It is not built in grand gestures or defining moments alone (or even mostly), but in the steady accumulation of ordinary choices. Thomas Sowell once observed that good intentions are not enough; outcomes matter. In parenting, those outcomes are shaped by consistency over time, by the habits we cultivate, and the values we embody.

Aristotle (384-322 BC) wisely noted that we are what we repeatedly do. Character is not formed in isolation, nor is it the result of a single decision. It is the product of patterns of imperfect consistencies…of choosing patience when it would be easier to react, choosing truth when it is inconvenient, choosing presence when distraction is readily available. These choices seem small in the moment, but over time they compound into something considerably more substantial.

This kind of intentionality stands in contrast to the broader cultural currents that seek to shape our children in a multitude of ways. The writings of educator John Taylor Gatto (1935-2018) highlighted how modern educational systems prioritize conformity over critical thinking, and compliance over character. When parents disengage from the formative process, even unintentionally, they are not leaving a vacuum; they are allowing other forces to gain influence.

The Greatest Inheritance

Which brings us back to the central question of legacy. What are we actually leaving behind? Not in terms of possessions or achievements, but in terms of formation. Who are our children becoming as a result of the environment we are creating?

That is a hopeful, if sobering, question. The hope comes from understanding that it is never too late to begin moving in a different direction, but the weight comes from recognizing the significance of our role. Scripture consistently points to a God who does not merely forgive, but redeems…who takes what is broken and weaves it into something meaningful.

My own story reflects that reality with remarkable clarity. The pain that once threatened to define my life did not disappear, but it was transformed. What was once a source of bitterness became a source of compassion and purpose. That is not something I “manifested”; it is something God did in and through me.

And that is what makes legacy ultimately possible. Not our perfection, but God’s faithfulness. Not our ability to control outcomes, but our willingness to participate in the work He is doing.

At the end of our lives, our children probably won’t remember the milestones we helped them achieve or the opportunities we provided. But they will remember who we were. How we responded when things were difficult, whether we were honest when we failed, and whether they felt seen and loved in our presence.

If there is a single thread that runs through all of this, it is this: the greatest inheritance we can leave our children is not found in what we give them, but in who we become in front of them. That kind of legacy is not built without cost. But it is built, choice by choice, day by day, as we align our lives more fully with the God who entrusted these children to us in the first place. And it’s worth it.

Though much of that work will go unseen and unrecognized by the world, it is not unnoticed. There is a greater story unfolding…one in which every act of faithfulness, no matter how small, contributes to something that will last long after we are gone.

Get more from Daniel Hagadorn in the Substack app

Available for iOS and Android

Get the app

VIKTOR FRANKL (1905-1997) | Between stimulus and response there is a space. In that space is our power to choose our response. In our response lies our growth and our freedom.

CARL JUNG (1875-1961) | The psychological rule says that when an inner situation is not made conscious, it happens outside, as fate.

There comes a point in many of our lives when something begins to feel unsettled beneath the surface. The ways we learned to survive are now the very things slowly exhausting us. But not because those patterns were wrong. Not because they were weak. And certainly not because they failed.

More often than not, those patterns were actually necessary.

They helped you endure what, at the time, felt unbearable. They carried you through seasons of loss, instability, rejection, emotional unpredictability, disappointment, trauma, or environments where your needs simply did not feel safe to express themselves. And when something helps us survive, we tend to hold onto it tightly. Even long after the danger has passed.

But over time, these survival patterns stop feeling like behaviors and start feeling like identity.

Maybe you became the “strong one” in your family. The “caretaker.” The “achiever.” The “peacemaker.” The person who never needed help. The one everyone leaned on because you seemed capable of carrying what others could not. At first, those roles may have felt necessary. Perhaps they even felt noble. But eventually you discovered something painful: the role that once protected you has slowly become a prison you no longer know how to escape.

That realization can feel deeply disorienting.

Because the brain is not wired primarily for happiness or fulfillment…it is wired for survival. And once your nervous system begins associating something with danger, it adapts in order to protect you — often automatically and outside your awareness.

Sometimes the “danger” wasn’t even physical. Sometimes connection felt dangerous. Visibility felt dangerous. Rest felt dangerous. Speaking honestly felt dangerous. Depending on other people felt dangerous.

So your nervous system learned how to adapt.

You learned how to stay small enough not to draw attention to yourself. How to overfunction to prevent everything from falling apart. How to anticipate everyone else’s needs before they spoke them. How to avoid conflict. How to numb yourself. How to stay busy enough to outrun what was happening inside. How to become whatever other people needed you to be.

From the outside, those patterns can be easily mistaken for self-sabotage. And more often than not, they began as self-protection. That’s an important distinction. Because once you understand that a behavior was originally protective, shame stops being “useful” and curiosity becomes far more healing.

One of the more difficult aspects of healing is recognizing that the survival version of you was never fake. That part of you was genuinely trying to help. It stepped in when it needed to. It carried burdens that were too heavy for you at the time. It endured situations you were never meant to navigate alone. In many ways, that survival self was faithful and kept showing up long after exhaustion should have won.

That deserves compassion.

All too often we approach healing as though we need to destroy the parts of ourselves we no longer like. But healing is almost never about attacking the survival self. It is about understanding it…honoring the role it played…and eventually helping it lay down responsibilities it was never meant to carry forever.

Because survival identities always come with a cost.

The strong one may slowly lose the ability to ask for help. The caretaker may forget how to receive care. The achiever may never feel safe enough to truly rest. The peacemaker may disappear inside relationships without realizing it is happening. And the person who learned to hold everything together may feel quietly terrified of letting anything fall apart — even while exhaustion is swallowing them alive.

Underneath these survival patterns is grief. Not only grief over what happened to you…but grief over who you had to become because of what happened to you.

This is often the place where people become frustrated with themselves. They gain enough awareness to understand where the patterns came from. They can explain the family dynamics, the wounds, the disappointments, the years of emotional survival. And yet the reactions remain.

At least part of the reason is because these behaviors stopped being a coping strategies and became our identity.

“I’m the responsible one.”

“I’m the dependable one.”

“I’m the strong one.”

“I’m the one who keeps everything together.”

So when healing asks you to loosen your grip on those identities, it feels less like growth and more like loss. If you stop carrying everyone else, who are you? If you stop fixing everything, what happens then? If you finally allow yourself to need support too, what does that mean about the person you have spent years trying to be?

Those are not small questions.

For many of us, those questions awaken grief that has been sitting quietly underneath the surface for years.

And this may be one of the most important things to understand: the part of you that protected you is not the enemy. It adapted for a reason and deserves compassion, not contempt. But even good protection eventually costs us something.

For instance, you can become so guarded that intimacy feels unsafe. So independent that receiving love feels awkward. So hypervigilant that peace itself feels uncomfortable. Sometimes we isolate because connection hurt us too deeply. Sometimes we stay in constant motion because slowing down allows buried pain to rise to the surface. Sometimes we overachieve because somewhere deep inside we still fear not being enough.

But none of this means you are broken. It just means that your nervous system learned how to survive. The problem is not that these parts exist. The problem is when they are forced to remain on duty forever.

One of the deeper aspects of grief recovery work is recognizing that grief is cumulative. The losses we experience throughout life do not exist in isolation; instead, they stack upon one another, shaping us in ways we may not fully recognize. Although we usually associate grief with only death or divorce, it actually emerges from many forms of loss: betrayal, estrangement, illness, lost dreams, unmet expectations, childhood wounds, chronic stress, relational disconnection, identity shifts, or simply years spent emotionally surviving instead of fully living.

Many of us carry unresolved grief for decades without naming it for what it is. We simply assume, “This is just who I am.” But often it is not who we are but who we became.

And when grief remains unfinished, it continues shaping how we experience trust, conflict, safety, rest, and connection. Sometimes even success feels unsafe if visibility once led to pain.

This is part of why emotional completion is so crucial to our emotional health.

One of the reasons grief recovery work feels different from endless emotional processing is because the goal is not simply analysis. It is emotional completion. Not forgetting. Not “getting over it.” Not pretending the loss did not matter. But completing what remained emotionally unfinished.

When our unresolved grief begins to heal, our nervous system no longer has to work quite so hard to maintain old protective patterns. That does not mean triggers disappear forever (they usually do not). But we can experience more awareness around them. More clarity. More choice. Instead of reacting automatically from old wounds, we can respond from a more grounded and integrated place.

And that changes relationships too.

This is why couples spend years arguing about surface-level conflicts without ever touching the deeper pain that lies beneath them. Two survival systems colliding with one another can create an exhausting cycle of misunderstanding. One person withdraws while the other pursues. One becomes defensive while the other feels abandoned. One overfunctions while the other shuts down. And both people often end up feeling unseen.

Without healing, couples can waste years trying to solve arguments without ever reaching the wounds driving those reactions in the first place. But when people begin recognizing their own triggers, grief, and survival patterns, relationships often begin changing in practical and meaningful ways. Conflict becomes less about “winning” and more about understanding. We become more capable of saying, “This is what got stirred up in me,” or “This is what I’m actually feeling,” or “This is what I need.”

That kind of honesty creates room for compassion.

First toward yourself…then toward others.

And if something in you recognizes yourself in these words, you do not need to rush toward fixing anything right now. Maybe this is simply an invitation to slow down long enough to ask a few honest questions.

What part of me learned to survive?

What was it trying to protect me from?

And what has it cost me to carry that role for so long?

Those are not questions to hurry through. They are questions worth sitting with…for awhile.

Because many of us spend years trying to heal without ever grieving the identity survival required of us.

And perhaps that is part of the invitation here.

Not to shame the survival self. Not to erase it. But to thank it for carrying you this far — and gently begin helping it set the burden down.

You were never meant to live in survival forever.

You were made for something deeper than that.

For wholeness.

If this post resonated with you, it may be because you are beginning to recognize a difficult truth: many of the patterns that once protected you are now limiting your ability to fully experience life, relationships, and even God. Our “survival identities” helped us endure disappointment, rejection, grief, fear, or instability. But what happens when the strategy that once kept us safe becomes the very thing keeping us from becoming whole?

Check out our free webinar, Grieving The Person I Had To Become In Order To Survive, where we explore how survival mechanisms are formed, why they become mistaken for our identity, and how we can begin the journey from coping to wholehearted living. If you've ever felt exhausted by the person you've had to become, this conversation is for you.

Get more from Daniel Hagadorn in the Substack app

Available for iOS and Android

Get the app

IAN MACLAREN (1850-1907) | Be kinder than necessary, for everyone you meet is fighting some kind of battle.

Years ago, Stephen Covey (1932-2012) shared a story that has stayed with millions of people because it reveals something true about all of us.

He was riding the subway one Sunday morning in New York City. The car was quiet and a few of the passengers were reading newspapers. Others were lost in thought. It was the kind of peaceful silence that occasionally settles over a train full of strangers.

Then, at one of the stops, a man stepped aboard with his three children.

Within moments, the serene atmosphere changed. The children began running through the car, shouting, grabbing at things, and disturbing nearly everyone around them. Passengers exchanged irritated glances. A few sighed audibly.

The disruption continued, and what made the situation even worse was that the father appeared completely disengaged. He sat quietly with his eyes fixed somewhere in the distance, making no attempt to correct his children or even acknowledge the chaos around him.

Covey found himself growing increasingly frustrated. Surely this father could see what was happening. Surely he understood the inconvenience his children were causing everyone else.

Finally, Covey leaned toward him and said, “Sir, your children are really bothering a lot of people. Could you perhaps do something about them?”

The man looked up as though he had just awakened.

Then he quietly replied, “You’re right. I guess I should. We just came from the hospital where their mother died about an hour ago. I don’t know what to think, and I guess they don’t know how to handle it either.”

In that instant, the entire moment shifted.

The children were still loud. Their behavior was still disruptive. The facts of the situation remained exactly the same.

What changed was how those facts were understood.

The father was no longer a negligent parent. He was a grieving husband trying to comprehend the unimaginable. The children were no longer unruly brats. They were lost children whose world had just been shattered.

Covey’s story endures because it exposes a weakness that lives in every one of us. We see behavior and assume we understand the story behind it. We encounter someone in a single moment and then imagine we know their whole story.

As parents, I think there’s an obvious lesson here about extending grace to others. The mother whose child is melting down in the grocery store may have been awake all night with a sick toddler. The father who seems distracted and impatient may be carrying pressures nobody else can see. The family that appears to have everything together may be walking through a private struggle they haven’t been able to share with anyone else.

Most of us understand this, at least in theory.

But somehow, we fail to extend the same grace to ourselves.

I know too many parents who have become experts at offering compassion to everyone…except for the person they see in the mirror every morning.

When another parent loses their patience, we think, “They’re probably exhausted.”

When another parent seems overwhelmed, we think, “They might be carrying a lot right now.”

When we lose our patience, however, the story changes.

We don’t consider the sleepless nights, the financial pressures, the difficult conversations, the grief we haven’t fully processed, or the countless responsibilities we carry. Instead, we immediately move to self-condemnation.

We tell ourselves we should be stronger, more patient, more organized, more grateful, more present, more…fill in the blank.

In other words, we judge ourselves exactly the same way the passengers judged that father on the subway. We look at one moment without considering the story behind it.

It should be noted that self-compassion is not the same thing as making excuses. It doesn’t mean refusing to take personal responsibility or pretending that our mistakes don’t matter. It simply means being honest about reality.

After all, you are not raising children from a position of perfect strength. None of us are.

Instead, you are parenting while carrying your own history, your own disappointments, your own fears, your own wounds, and your own unfinished growth. Some days you carry those burdens well. Other days they feel a lot heavier than you expected.

The point is not to excuse our shortcomings. The point is to understand them accurately.

Growth begins with truth, and part of the truth is recognizing that human beings make far more sense when we know their story.

That is true for the stranger in the grocery store.

It is true for your spouse.

It is true for your children.

And it is true for you.

So, the next time you’re tempted to judge another parent, remember the subway story. And the next time you’re tempted to condemn yourself…remember it again.

There may be more to the story than you can see.

There almost always is.

And sometimes the very grace we are eager to extend to others is the grace we most desperately need to receive ourselves.

Get more from Daniel Hagadorn in the Substack app

Available for iOS and Android

Get the app

DALLAS WILLARD (1935-2013) | The most important thing in your life is not what you do; it’s who you become.

C. S. LEWIS (1898-1963) | Education without values, as useful as it is, seems rather to make man a more clever devil.

Every generation believes the previous generation has lost something.

If you spend enough time around grandparents, teachers, pastors, or parents…you’ll start to notice the pattern. One generation worries that the next lacks discipline. Another laments declining manners. Others point to weakening faith, shrinking attention spans, or an alarming dependence on technology. The details change from era to era…but the concern itself remains remarkably consistent.

Today, the smartphone has become the primary suspect.

Parents watch their children disappear into screens and wonder whether technology is reshaping them in ways they barely understand. Teachers observe shorter attention spans in their students. Counselors report rising levels of anxiety and depression in their clients. Young adults will often admit their life online feels exhausting, even as they struggle to disconnect from it.

So, the concern is certainly legitimate. The digital world has transformed how we communicate, learn, shop, date, work, and entertain ourselves. Never before have human beings carried such powerful technology in their pockets. Yet before we conclude that smartphones are solely responsible for what this present generation has “lost”, it may be worth considering a different possibility.

What if the smartphone is not raising our children? What if it is simply amplifying whatever has already been planted in childhood?

That question shifts the conversation in an important direction. It moves us beyond debates about screen time and parental controls and toward a deeper examination of formation, family, meaning, and the kind of people our children are becoming.

C. S. Lewis (1898-1963) frequently cautioned against what he termed “chronological snobbery”—the uncritical assumption that because we live in a later age, we somehow possess a superior understanding of reality than those who preceded us. Lewis argued that every generation is shaped by its own blind spots and cultural beliefs, making the wisdom of the past an indispensable corrective to the prejudices of the present. We often make a similar mistake when discussing technology. We assume that because the tools are new, the human heart must be new as well.

But it is not.

The fears, insecurities, ambitions, envies, and longings that animate a teenager doom scrolling through social media are not all that different from those that animated teenagers fifty…one hundred…or even five hundred years ago. Human beings have always wrestled with identity, belonging, loneliness, comparison, rejection, and meaning. What has changed is not the existence of these struggles but the environment in which they unfold.

A century ago, comparison was largely limited to one’s family, neighborhood, school, or church. Today, teenagers can compare themselves to millions of carefully curated digital lives before breakfast. The smartphone did not invent envy any more than the printing press invented pride. What it has done, is change the speed, scale, and visibility of human behavior with unprecedented speed and intensity. Thus, technology may amplify the human condition, but it does not create it.

Amplifiers are a useful metaphor here. They do not create the music…they just make it louder. If the melody is beautiful, the amplifier allows more people to hear it. If the melody is distorted, then the amplifier likewise exposes the distortion. Technology functions much the same way. It magnifies tendencies that already exist within individuals, families, and cultures. And understanding this distinction changes where we look for solutions.

Moreover, this distinction becomes even clearer when we observe how differently people respond to an identical digital environment. For example, two teenagers can receive the same unanswered text message and have completely different reactions. One assumes the other person is busy. The other becomes consumed with worry. Or two young adults can post something online and receive the same feedback. One shrugs it off while the other spirals into self-doubt.

Although the technology was the same…their interpretations were very different. And that raises a fascinating question: “If technology does not determine our response, then what does?”

The Childhood Beneath The Technology

Increasingly, researchers, psychologists, and trauma specialists offer an answer that is both simple and profound. Long before children learn how to navigate smartphones, they are learning how to navigate relationships. Long before they encounter social media, they are developing assumptions about trust, belonging, conflict, love, and safety.

In other words, they are learning how to interpret reality.

This may be one of the most important insights for parents in the digital age because the greatest challenge facing our children is not that they have smartphones. It is that smartphones amplify the interpretive frameworks they have already developed.

The implications of this insight are difficult to overstate.

For years, most conversations on the topic of children and technology have focused almost entirely on behavior. Parents ask how much screen time is too much, schools debate device policies, and experts argue over suggested restrictions on social media. While these discussions are undoubtedly important…they often take place too late in the story.

By the time a child receives a smartphone, much of the foundational work has already been done…for better or worse.

Remember, long before children learn how to use technology, they are learning how to interpret reality. They are developing foundational assumptions about God, themselves, other people, and how life works. They are learning whether relationships can be trusted, whether mistakes threaten connection, whether conflict is survivable, and whether love must be earned or is simply received.

These lessons are seldom directly taught and are almost always absorbed through experience.

A father who puts down his phone and listens attentively is communicating something meaningful about value and presence. A mother who responds to failure with patience rather than shame is teaching resilience. Family members who work through disagreements without withdrawing affection demonstrate that relationships can endure conflict. Grandparents who tell stories around a dinner table quietly connect children to a larger narrative than themselves.

Over time, these ordinary moments accumulate and become the lens through which future experiences are interpreted.

This is one of the central insights guiding the work of Gabor Maté. Much of what we call personality is really just adaptation. In other words, human beings instinctively develop strategies to navigate the environments in which they were raised. What appears later as confidence, insecurity, hyper-vigilance, avoidance, resilience, or anxiety is frequently rooted in survival mechanisms that once helped a child make sense of his or her world…but are no longer helpful as an adult.

For instance, a child who experiences consistency and emotional safety learns to interpret ambiguity with confidence. Therefore, a delayed response does not necessarily signal rejection, disagreement does not automatically threaten the relationship, and silence does not always mean abandonment.

On the other hand, a child raised in an unpredictable home learns a different lesson. Ambiguity feels dangerous. Silence feels threatening. Distance feels personal.

Now imagine that years later, these same two children encounter the same digital environment. Both experience unanswered messages, awkward interactions, misunderstandings, and social comparison. Yet they interpret those experiences through entirely different frameworks.

The technology remains the same but because their childhoods were different, the meaning of the experience is different as well.

I am going to suggest that this is why technology often reveals more than it creates. It just magnifies what is already present by exposing strengths and vulnerabilities that existed long before the child’s social media account was ever opened.

Understanding this should be both sobering and encouraging for parents. Sobering because it reminds us that formation matters. Encouraging because it reminds us that formation is still possible.

But if the roots of resilience are to reach deeper than technology, then the solutions must reach deeper as well.

The Institutions We Didn’t Know We Needed

This is where G. K. Chesterton (1874-1936) offers an unexpected contribution to the conversation.

Chesterton possessed a remarkable ability to notice things that modern people often overlooked. He understood that institutions and traditions survive, not necessarily because they are old, but because they serve important functions. His famous observation about fences remains relevant today: before removing a fence, one should first understand why it was built.

Unfortunately, modern society has spent decades dismantling institutions whose purpose and value it no longer fully understands or appreciates.

Perhaps this explains why family dinners have become increasingly rare. Why multi-generational households have declined in number. Why neighborhood communities have weakened. Why churches often occupy a much smaller place in family life than they once did. Why children spend less time with grandparents, less time in unstructured play, and less time participating in shared traditions that connect them to a larger community.

By the way, none of these changes happened overnight, nor are they entirely negative. In fact, many emerged alongside genuine advances in mobility, opportunity, and convenience. Yet convenience often conceals costs.

So, let’s take a closer look at some of these institutions. For generations, the family dinner table was not merely a place to eat a meal. It was a place where stories were told, values were transmitted, disagreements were navigated, and identities were reinforced. Children learned how adults think. They learned how to listen. They learned that they belonged to something larger than themselves.

Likewise, grandparents provided more than occasional babysitting. They embodied continuity and their stories reminded children that they were part of a narrative stretching beyond the present moment. They connected young people to a history they did not personally experience and offered wisdom forged through decades of triumph and hardship.

Faith communities served similar functions. At their best, they provided meaning, accountability, support, and a shared understanding of reality.

When these institutions weakened, the effects were not always immediately visible. The consequences emerged gradually, revealing themselves in rising loneliness, fragmentation, and uncertainty.

But children still yearn for belonging. They still need mentors. They still need meaning. They still need communities that remind them of who they are.

And the elimination of these fundamental needs is one thing modernity has never managed to accomplish.

The Crisis Beneath The Anxiety

If Chesterton offers insight into what has been lost, then Francis Schaeffer (1912-1984) helps us understand why the loss matters so profoundly.

Schaeffer devoted much of his teaching to the idea that every culture eventually reveals what it believes about reality. Thus, ideas are never confined to classrooms or books since they eventually shape families, institutions, laws, and lives.

As a result, children and teenagers are growing up in a culture that increasingly struggles to answer the most basic human questions: Who am I? Why am I here? What makes life meaningful? What is worth sacrificing for? How should I live?

Although previous generations did not answer these questions perfectly, they generally inherited answers from families, faith traditions, and communities. Today, far too many young people inherit questions…without answers.

This is largely due to the way that modern culture celebrates radical autonomy and self-creation. Young people are frequently encouraged to discover their own truth, construct their own identity, and create their own meaning. Yet beneath the “language of freedom” lies an impossible expectation.

Human beings were never designed to bear the weight of creating themselves.

It is often assumed that anxiety emerges from having too little information…but increasingly, the opposite appears true. Our present generation is drowning in information…even as it starves for wisdom. It has access to more facts than previous generations…but often possess fewer reliable frameworks for interpreting those facts.

Information is abundant. Meaning is scarce.

A smartphone can deliver endless content, but it cannot tell a child why his or her life matters. An algorithm can predict our preferences, but it cannot provide our purpose. Technology can connect people, but it cannot answer the deepest questions of the human heart.

Those answers must come from somewhere else.

Forming Souls In An Age Of Algorithms

This is why the insights of Dallas Willard (1935-2013) feel especially relevant to our cultural moment.

Willard consistently reminded his readers that every human heart is being formed by something. So, the question is never whether formation is occurring, but only whether it is intentional.

Parents will typically ask how to best protect their children from harmful influences. It is a reasonable question, but it sometimes obscures a more important one:

“What kind of person is my child becoming?”

The answer is shaped by habits, practices, relationships, and attention. Whatever consistently captures our attention gradually shapes our desires. Whatever shapes our desires eventually influences the kind of people we become.

Consequently, children need more than rules…they need wisdom. They need more than information…they need understanding. They need more than entertainment…they need beauty.

They need opportunities to encounter truth, goodness, and reality in ways that awaken wonder rather than just consume their attention. They need meaningful responsibilities that teach competence and character. They need relationships that require patience, forgiveness, and sacrifice.

Most importantly, they need adults who demonstrate what that sort of flourishing actually looks like in real life.

The Child Before The Screen

Which brings us back to the original question: “Is the smartphone raising our children?”

Parents often underestimate the cumulative power of ordinary faithfulness. That’s because we tend to imagine that children’s lives are shaped by dramatic moments (and sometimes they are). The truth is, character is formed more through repetition than revelation. The bedtime story, the shared meal, the difficult conversation, the apology, the prayer, and the thousand small acts of love that fill ordinary days collectively exert more influence than the major events we remember.

As we have already noted, long before a child receives a smartphone, something else is already shaping the architecture of their soul.

A child is learning whether he or she is loved. A child is learning whether relationships can be trusted. A child is learning what truth sounds like. A child is learning what kind of life is worth pursuing. A child is learning whether reality is something to embrace or escape.

These lessons are absorbed through thousands of ordinary moments that never make the headlines and almost never feel extraordinary while they are happening. And when the day finally comes when the child enters the digital world, technology simply amplifies whatever has already taken root.

If insecurity dominates the inner life, technology can magnify insecurity. If resilience has been cultivated, technology can strengthen resilience. If identity depends upon external validation, digital culture can intensify that dependency. But if identity rests upon the right foundation, then digital culture loses much of its power.

This is why the future of our children depends less on finding the perfect parental-control app and more on the slow, sacred work of formation. The use of technology is an important issue to consider…but the formation of character matters more. A lot more.

Despite the influence of technology on our children, it cannot begin to compare to the profound influence of the parents who love them…of the friends and communities that shape them…and the truths that guide them.

The most important work of parenting has never changed. It is not primarily about managing screen time and monitoring devices. It is about forming souls.

Long before our children ever encounter smartphones, social media, or algorithms, they are learning how to navigate reality itself. They are learning what love feels like, what truth sounds like, what courage requires, and where they belong. They are learning what is true, what is good, what is beautiful, and who they are becoming.

And in the end, those lessons—not the technology they inherit—will shape the men and women they become. For while technology may amplify a life, it cannot define one.

The deeper story has always been formation. It unfolds in family meals and bedtime prayers, in difficult conversations and shared hardships, in the ordinary moments where children learn what it means to be fully human.

That is where the real work of parenting begins. And that is where the future of every generation is ultimately decided.

Get more from Daniel Hagadorn in the Substack app

Available for iOS and Android

Get the app

DALLAS WILLARD (1935-2013) | The human heart was made to need God. We are not self-sufficient creatures.

CARL JUNG (1875-1961) | Until you make the unconscious conscious, it will direct your life and you will call it fate.

RICHARD ROHR | Pain that is not transformed is transmitted.

There is a sentence I have not been able to shake for years now.

“Whatever wounds that parents refuse to heal from…will be eventually inherited by their children.”

Although it might show up differently in the next generation, unresolved pain has a way of moving through families until someone becomes honest enough to stop and ask, “What is really happening here?”

I have seen this in my own life. In marriage. In parenting. In classrooms. In churches. In long conversations with people who looked completely functional on the outside even while they were quietly falling apart beneath the surface.

Of course, most people don’t walk around saying, “I think unresolved grief has shaped my identity.” It usually sounds more like…

“I’m anxious all the time.”

“I can’t seem to rest.”

“I overreact to little things.”

“I always feel like I’m failing.”

“I don’t know why criticism hits me so hard.”

“I feel disconnected from everyone, even people I love.”

And sometimes those struggles are exactly what they appear to be. But very often… underneath them…there is unresolved grief and shame working together in ways we cannot fully understood.

When Grief Quietly Becomes Identity

This is really important because grief and shame are not the same thing.

Grief says, “Something painful happened to me.” Shame says, “Something is wrong with me.”

One acknowledges the pain. The other absorbs the pain into identity.

And many of us learned to do that very early in life.

For example, a child who grew up in a household that constantly criticized does not think, “My parents were emotionally immature.” Instead, they come to believe, “I must be the problem.”

A child who grew up feeling unseen doesn’t conclude, “The adults around me did not know how to provide emotional safety.” Instead, they quietly decide, “Something about me must not be worth noticing.”

We instinctively understand (and science has proven) that children need attachment to thrive. This need runs so deep, that we will often sacrifice our authenticity in order to preserve connection. In our desperation to maintain this connection, we will even absorb blame…because blaming ourselves feels safer than risking the loss of love.

In childhood, that adaptation enabled us to survive. Then, as time went on, it started shaping everything in our adult lives.

It became people-pleasing. Perfectionism. Hyper-achievement. Emotional withdrawal. Addiction. Control. Busyness. The inability to rest. The fear of disappointing everyone around us.

This is not weakness, but the result of having learned survival before we learned safety. And that distinction between survival and safety deserves far more compassion than most people ever receive.

The Pain We Never Deal With Does Not Stay Contained

Years ago, I began noticing patterns in myself that, on the surface at least, didn’t really make sense. Situations that provoked overreactions. A simple disagreement felt disproportionately threatening. Silence sometimes felt personal. Criticism could linger internally for days even when I knew (rationally at least) that it should not.

Outwardly, everything had a logical explanation…but internally…something older and deeper was being stirred.

That’s the thing about unresolved grief and shame. They refuse to remain neatly contained in the past…and will eventually become filters through which we interpret the present.

A spouse asks a question…and shame hears an accusation.

Someone seems distracted in conversation…and shame hears rejection.

A disagreement suddenly feels like proof that you are failing…again.

With each passing year, those patterns feel more and more normal even as it becomes more and more difficult to recognize that you are interpreting life through the filter of your old wounds.

That’s why we spend years trying to manage symptoms and modify behaviors without ever addressing the deeper pain beneath them. The “answer”? Try harder. Work harder. Pray harder. Stay busier. Be more productive. More disciplined. More “together.”

But we cannot heal shame by outperforming it…and eventually exhaustion catches up to all of us.

If we never deal honestly with our own wounds, then our children end up carrying whatever we refused to face ourselves.

[I don’t say that to shame parents. I say it because I think it’s true, and because I’ve also had to face it in my own life].

What Children Learn From Wounded Parents

Children are extraordinarily perceptive. They may not fully understand your story, but they absorb your emotional world. They learn what relationships feel like by living inside the atmosphere you create. They notice the tension you never explain. They internalize the ways you respond to stress, disappointment, conflict, and failure.

If a parent has never dealt with their own grief or shame, then children often grow up sensing that mistakes are dangerous, vulnerability is unsafe, emotions should stay hidden, or love must somehow be earned.

This is not the result of parental maliciousness. Most of the time, wounded parents are simply trying to survive the only way they know how.

And that realization changed the way I think about healing.

Healing Begins With Honesty

For a long time, I thought healing was mostly about becoming better behaved. More disciplined. More spiritually mature. Less reactive. Less flawed.

Now I think healing begins somewhere much more honest.

It begins when we stop asking, “What is wrong with me?” and start asking, “What happened to me?”

What losses have I never fully grieved?

What pain have I quietly turned into self-rejection?

Where did I learn these beliefs about God, myself, other people, and how life works?

That kind of honesty can feel uncomfortable because we’re taught to avoid grief rather than face it. We were taught to move on quickly. To stay strong. To stop crying. To “get over it.” Sometimes we were taught to use spirituality as a way to bypass reality altogether.

But Scripture never treats grief as weakness.

The Psalms are filled with lament and there is even a book in the Bible called ‘Lamentations’. Jesus himself was described as “a man of sorrows, acquainted with grief.” There is nothing spiritually mature about pretending wounds do not exist.

That’s why healing begins with truth…and truth usually sounds much less dramatic than people would expect.

“That hurt me.”

“I felt alone.”

“I’ve spent years trying to prove that I mattered.”

“I am tired of pretending I’m okay.”

Simple honesty has a way of breaking down the power of shame because shame survives through secrecy and grows strongest in isolation. It convinces us that if anyone truly saw us, we would be rejected.

So we hide. We perform. We manage our image. We stay busy. We numb ourselves. We overproduce. Basically, we become whatever version of ourselves feels safest.

But underneath those behaviors is the grief that has never been given the words to express itself.

Most Coping Behaviors Are About Relief

One of the most important things I have learned through the Grief Recovery Method is that our destructive coping strategies make a lot more sense when viewed through the lens of unresolved pain and unhealed wounds.

Most of us are not addicted to pleasure. We are addicted to relief.

Relief from anxiety. Relief from shame. Relief from disappointment. Relief from loneliness. Relief from the grief we never learned how to process.

Although this doesn’t excuse destructive behavior…it does help explain why behavior modification alone cannot create lasting freedom. As long as the underlying wound remains untouched, we will continue searching for relief…somewhere.

Healing Changes What Your Children Inherit

This is why healing must go deeper than symptom management.

It requires honesty about what was lost. It requires grieving what mattered. It requires separating our pain from our identity. It requires learning how to receive truth instead of rehearsing shame. Here is where we need to give ourselves some grace because the process of becoming honest enough to stop hiding can be agonizingly slow.

Sometimes it looks like grieving the childhood you never had. Sometimes it means acknowledging that certain experiences shaped you more deeply than you’d like to admit. Sometimes it means learning that your need for love was not weakness.

Over time, changes begin to show up.

You stop reacting from constant self-protection. You become more emotionally present. You stop expecting other people to heal wounds they did not create. And perhaps most importantly, your children inherit something different.

Not perfect parents. Healing parents.

Parents who apologize. Parents who tell the truth. Parents who are willing to grow instead of pretending they have all the answers. Parents courageous enough to break their own cycles of pain instead of passing them forward.

I honestly believe that is one of the greatest gifts we can give our children.

Not polished perfection but presence…honesty…wholeness.

Children don’t need parents who never struggle. They need parents who are willing to face reality with courage and humility.

And maybe that is where healing begins for you too.

Not with shame. Not with self-condemnation. But with the simple willingness to finally tell the truth. Something hurt you. Something mattered. Some grief never had words.

But that grief does not have to become your identity.

And it certainly does not have to become your children’s inheritance.

When you have some time, consider, “What pain have I normalized that may actually need to be grieved?”…and then give yourself an honest answer.

If this conversation resonates with you, my wife and I recently taught a free webinar called The Shame Beneath the Grief: How Unresolved Pain Becomes Self-Blame and What It Takes to Finally Heal. We walk through how unresolved grief shapes identity, relationships, and emotional patterns — and what genuine healing can actually look like.

You can access the free webinar here.

Get more from Daniel Hagadorn in the Substack app

Available for iOS and Android

Get the app

BRENNAN MANNING | The greatest single cause of atheism in the world today is Christians who acknowledge Jesus with their lips, then walk out the door and deny Him by their lifestyle.

I used to assume that if my wife and I got the “important pieces” in place, the rest would follow.

Church on Sundays. Meaningful conversations when they came up. Saying our prayers at night. Maybe a book here or there, something thoughtful, something intentional. Not rigid, not forced—just enough structure to make sure faith had a place in our home.

And for a time, that felt like enough.

By the way, I didn’t approach this carelessly. Instead, I took the kind of approach that makes you feel like you’re doing what you’re supposed to do without becoming overbearing about it.

But after a while, something started to feel off…just enough…to make me pay closer attention.

It showed up in small disconnects. Moments where something important was being talked about, but it didn’t seem to land. And not because it was unclear or because it was being resisted. It just…sort of…hovered. Like it wasn’t attaching to anything real.

The longer I sat with that, the more uncomfortable the realization became.

Because the issue wasn’t that faith was absent in our home. It was that it wasn’t fully anchored.

The Way Good Intentions Drift

Most parents don’t intentionally distance themselves from their child’s spiritual formation. If anything, they care deeply about it. They want their children to love God, to know what is true, to have something stable under their feet, and to grow into the kind of faith that can actually hold up under pressure.

But this process often unfolds in unexpected ways. One of those ways is our reliance on structures.

This doesn’t happen because we’re lazy. We’re really trying to be wise. After all, it’s natural to look for environments that are established, people who are experienced, and systems that feel more consistent than the unpredictability of everyday life.

And slowly, without even realizing it, we begin to treat those structures as the primary place where faith is formed.

We still care. We still engage. But the center of gravity begins to shift from lived experience…to delegated responsibility.

What Cannot Be Handed Off

There are certain things in parenting that can be shared.

Education can be supported. Skills can be taught by others. Even certain forms of discipline or instruction can be reinforced in different environments.

But there is something about faith that resists being transferred that way.

Because faith is not primarily about information.

It’s not a set of ideas to be understood or even agreed with. It is a way of seeing reality, a way of moving through it, a way of orienting your life around something you believe to be ultimately true.

And that is not the sort of thing that can be absorbed at a distance.

It has to be witnessed. Up close and over time.

What Our Children Are Actually Watching

The truth is that our children don’t build their understanding of faith from our best explanations. They build it from our most consistent patterns.

From how we respond when something doesn’t go the way we planned. From what calms us when we’re under pressure. From the tone we use when we’re frustrated, the posture we take when we’re uncertain, the direction we move when we don’t have control.

These “lessons” are not occasional. They are constant…and because they are constant…they are formative.

We may not be talking about God in those moments. We may not even be thinking about it in those terms. But our children are still learning something about what we believe—because belief, in its truest sense, always shows up in how we live.

The Gap That Forms Without Notice

It’s possible to say all the right things about faith and still live in a way that doesn’t quite match up. I believe this happens because there is often a gap between what we affirm and what we rely on.

In other words, you can believe that God is present, and still move through most of your day as though everything depends on you. You can affirm that He is trustworthy, and still carry a low-level anxiety that never really gets resolved. You can talk about faith as central, and still structure your life in a way that consistently pushes it to the edges.

None of that happens overnight. It forms gradually, often without being named.

But your child doesn’t miss it.

They feel the alignment—or the lack of it—even if they can’t explain why.

Faith Was Never Meant To Be A Category

One of the reasons this happens is because we’ve learned, often without realizing it, to separate faith from the rest of life. So, it becomes a category. Something we step into at certain times, in certain settings, with certain expectations.

But Scripture doesn’t present it that way.

Returning to Deuteronomy 6…faith is not described as a place you visit. It is something that is meant to be woven into the rhythms of life itself. It is assumed to be present in the ordinary and not something expressly reserved for the exceptional.

All of which means that your child’s primary experience of faith is not what happens in designated moments, but rather, what happens in the flow of daily life.

In how you speak. In how you respond. In what you turn to without thinking.

The Pressure That Doesn’t Belong To You

At some point, if you’re taking this seriously (and almost all parents do), there’s a pressure that settles uncomfortably on your shoulders.

It’s a sense that this matters so much that you can’t afford to get it wrong. And as the pressure intensifies, authenticity retreats to the background.

You begin to manage your responses. To shape how things appear. To aim for clarity and confidence, even when that’s not what you’re actually experiencing.

But faith was never meant to be performative and your child certainly does not need a more polished version of it.

They need something they can recognize as real.

What It Looks Like To Live It

To be clear, living your faith is not an exercise in over-spiritualizing every moment into a cosmic life lesson. It means allowing your child to see what it actually looks like when your faith intersects with real life.

When you’re frustrated and have to slow yourself down instead of reacting quickly. When something doesn’t make sense and you sit with that instead of forcing a resolution. When you realize you were wrong and you own it without defensiveness.

Just because those moments don’t seem “note-worthy”, please do not underestimate their importance. Which is easy to do because they certainly don’t feel like life-altering breakthroughs.

But they do offer something that explanation alone never will.

They show your child that faith is not fragile. That it can exist in the middle of tension. That it does not require perfection to be real.

And that is priceless.

Authority Without Performance

This is where authority begins to take on a different shape. It sheds control and certainty and emerges as alignment.

In other words, you are not the source of truth. You are someone who is learning to live within it. And when your child sees that—not just in your words, but in how you move through life—it creates a kind of stability that doesn’t depend on you having all the answers. It depends on you being anchored in God.

That is the kind of authority that holds strong against the storms.

When Faith Becomes Tangible

Of course, there is a kind of faith that just remains conceptual. It sounds right. It can be clearly explained. It fits neatly within the right categories. But it doesn’t always carry its weight when life gets complicated.

And then there is a kind of faith that has lived through enough reality that it no longer needs to prove itself. It has been tested, not necessarily in dramatic ways, but definitely in ordinary ones. In frustration. In uncertainty. In moments where control was not an option.

That kind of faith is much deeper…and steadier.

And when your child encounters it consistently, it gives them something they can actually trust.

A Few Things To Think About

Let’s pause here for a moment…and please resist the urge to answer quickly (or shame yourself).

• Where is there a gap between what I say I believe and how I actually live?

• What does my child most consistently observe about how I handle pressure or uncertainty?

• What have I outsourced to others that was meant to be lived in front of my child?

• What would it look like for my faith to be more visible in ordinary, unscripted moments?

• Where do I feel pressure to be more certain than I actually am?

One Small Step This Week

This is a lot to take in, but don’t try to make it bigger than it really is.

Just slow down for a second.

The next time something “small” happens…a frustration, a question, a moment where your instinct is to immediately react…pause long enough to respond honestly.

Not to explain more. Not to sound better. Just to be real.

Because as we’ve been saying over several posts now, your child is not ultimately learning faith from what you assign, recommend, or outsource.

They are learning it from what they see.

And over time, what they see will either feel like something they can confidently step into…or something that seemed like a nice idea that never quite became real.

Get more from Daniel Hagadorn in the Substack app

Available for iOS and Android

Get the app

AARON SWARTZ (1986-2013) | What is the most important thing you could be working on in the world right now? And if you're not working on that, why aren't you?

RAINIER MARIA RILKE (1875-1926) | We lead our lives so poorly because we arrive in the present always unprepared, incapable, and too distracted for everything.

There was a period of time during my daughter’s younger years when I started to notice something I didn’t like.

Not in her. In myself.

It’s kind of insidious really, because it showed up in the mundane. You know…those forgettable kinds of moments that are easily excused if you aren’t paying attention.

My daughter was talking to me—telling me something that, to her, clearly mattered. I don’t even remember what it was about. And that’s part of the point. But I do remember the feeling of it. I was standing there, looking at her, nodding in the right places, even responding in ways that would probably sound attentive if you heard them from the outside.

Technically.

But underneath all of that, my attention was divided. Part of me was with her, but part of me was somewhere else—thinking about a I bill I needed to pay, a task I hadn’t finished yet, or an issue that needed to be resolved.

And over time, I started to see something I couldn’t unsee.

She could feel the difference.

Not because she could articulate it. Not because she was analyzing it. She was only five years old at the time. But because children are far more attuned to presence than we realize.

They don’t measure love the way adults do.

They experience it.

That moment stayed with me longer than it should have, which is almost always a sign that something underneath it needs attention.

It’s not like I stopped loving my daughter…not even a little bit. But that wasn’t the issue. If anything, my desire to love her well was exactly what made the moment so unsettling.

The issue was that my attention—the thing that actually brings love into her world—was divided.

And I had started to treat that as normal.

The Direction Your Attention Is Already Taking You

We tend to think of love as something stable, something we hold onto regardless of circumstances. And in one sense, that’s true. Love isn’t as fragile as our moods, and it doesn’t disappear just because we’re momentarily distracted.

But if we stay with it long enough, we start to see that love, as it is experienced—especially by a child—is not just something we feel. It’s something that is revealed, reinforced, and in many ways formed by what consistently receives our attention.

Jesus says something in Matthew 6 that’s so familiar it’s easy to let it slide by without really considering the implications: “Where your treasure is, there your heart will be also.”

Most of us instinctively reverse that. We assume our heart determines where our attention goes, that we focus on what we already love. But that’s not what Jesus actually says. He says your heart follows your treasure, meaning it follows whatever you repeatedly give your attention, your time, and your focus.

In other words, attention is not just an expression of love. It is one of the primary ways love is shaped over time.

And if that’s true—and I believe it is—then this is not a small issue. It’s not just about being a little more present here and there. It’s about recognizing that the direction of our attention is quietly shaping the direction of our hearts, and by extension, the relational world our children are growing up in.

We Are Not Forming In A Neutral Environment

One of the things that makes this harder to see is that we are living in a time when divided attention is not just common—it’s assumed.

Everything around us is designed to draw our focus, and not in an occasional way, but in a constant, low-level hum that never fully turns off. There is always something else to check, something else to respond to, something else waiting just beyond whatever moment we are currently in.

And over time, without consciously deciding to, we begin to live with a kind of internal fragmentation that feels normal simply because it is so familiar.

But children don’t experience it that way.

They experience our lack of engagement as inconsistency in presence.

They experience it as something they have to compete with, even if they don’t have the language to frame it that way.

And the hard part is, most of us are not choosing that intentionally. We are simply living inside a system that has trained us to divide our attention without realizing what it is costing us.

What Your Child Is Actually Learning

Children are paying attention…to our attention (or lack of it)…in ways that are easy to underestimate.

They notice what interrupts you and how quickly you respond to it. They notice when something pulls you away, even briefly, and whether you come back fully or only halfway. They notice when you’re physically present but mentally elsewhere, even if everything on the surface looks fine.

And from all of that, they begin to develop an understanding of what matters. Not based on what you say matters, but based on what consistently receives your attention.

None of this is processed intellectually. Instead, it quietly settles into how they experience relationships, interpret connection, and learn to give and receive attention.

So what does all of this mean? Whether we intend to or not, we are teaching our children what love looks like simply by how we give them our attention in ordinary moments.

Love That Can Be Felt, Not Just Intended

One of the things I’ve had to come to terms with is that love, if it remains primarily internalized, seldom translates in the way I assume it will.

I can love my daughter deeply…and still be unavailable in a moment that matters.

I can care sincerely about her welfare…and still be unable to show up in a way that she can feel it.

Please know that this isn’t condemnation…but we must be willing to face the reality before we can align ourselves with it.

Because here’s the thing…love becomes real, in a lived sense, through attention. Through presence. Through the simple but increasingly rare act of giving someone your full focus, even if only for a short time.

When that happens, something really profound shifts in the interaction. There’s a kind of settling, a sense that the moment is not being rushed through or shared with something else.

And children, more than anyone, recognize that.

The Tension You’re Probably Already Feeling

At this point, it would be easy to turn this post into just another standard that we should be box-checking or another item to add to the list of places where we’re falling short. That’s not how this is meant to land.

The truth is…no one but God can be fully present at all times. And like Father Cavanaugh said in the movie Rudy, “there is a God, and, I’m not Him.” We all have responsibilities, pressures, and limitations that are part of being human. Trying to eliminate all distraction is not only unrealistic, it would create a different kind of burden altogether.

But there is a difference between unavoidable distraction and unexamined patterns.

The invitation here is not perfection. It’s awareness.

It’s beginning to notice where your attention goes when you’re not intentionally directing it, and then asking whether that pattern is shaping the kind of relational environment you actually want your child to grow up in.

Formation Happens In The Ordinary

One of my core convictions that I repeat quite often in my blog posts is that Scripture consistently points out that the formation of our children is not confined to formal moments of teaching. It happens in the flow of everyday life—when you sit, when you walk, when you lie down, and when you rise (Deuteronomy 6).

In other words, it happens in the very moments we are most likely to overlook. Which means attention, in those moments, carries more weight than we usually assign to it.

Not because every moment has to be super intense or meaningful, but because over time, the accumulation of ordinary moments creates something far more lasting than any single, intentional conversation.

If this is beginning to feel a little heavy, it’s probably worth slowing down for a moment.

Because nothing changes in a meaningful or sustainable way by adding pressure. It changes by becoming honest about what is already happening and then taking a small step in a healthier direction.

So instead of trying to overhaul your entire life all at once, let’s begin with something simple and specific.

A Few Questions

…”When my child is talking to me, where is my attention actually going?”

…”What tends to pull my attention away most consistently, even in small moments?”

…”When do I feel most present with my child, and what is different about those times?”

…”What patterns of attention am I unintentionally modeling for them?

…”What would it look like to treat my attention as something I’m responsible for, instead of something that just gets used up?”

One Small Step This Week

The place to begin is not with a “system” or “5 Super Practical Steps To _____”, but with a moment.

The next time your child comes to you—especially in a moment that feels small or interruptive—pause what you’re doing (make sure your iPhone is put away), turn toward them fully, and then give them your attention without dividing it, even if only for a short time.

You don’t need to stretch the moment longer than it naturally goes. You don’t need to make it intense or overly meaningful.

Just be there. Fully present.

Because over time, those moments accumulate, and what they communicate is pretty important. They shape what your child experiences as love. And what they experience as love will, eventually, shape who they become.

This is slow work.

Change is not going to post itself in your social media feed…and it’s not going to produce immediate results.

But it is doing something real.

And it’s worth your attention.

Get more from Daniel Hagadorn in the Substack app

Available for iOS and Android

Get the app

PAUL DAVID TRIPP | One of the foundational heart issues in the life of every child is authority. Teaching and modeling the protective beauty of authority is one of the foundations of good parenting.

J. C. RYLE (1816-1900) | You will see many in this day who allow their children to choose and think for themselves long before they are able, and even make excuses for their disobedience, as if it were a thing not to be blamed. To my eyes, a parent always yielding, and a child always having its own way, are a most painful sight—painful, because I see God’s appointed order of things inverted and turned upside down—painful, because I feel sure the consequence to that child’s character in the end will be self-will, pride, and self-conceit. You must not wonder that men refuse to obey their Father which is in heaven, if you allow them, when children, to disobey their father who is upon earth.

UNKNOWN | One of the hardest jobs for a parent is making a child realize that “no” is a complete sentence.

Parenting unfolds in a series of moments…most of them fairly inconsequential. Or so it often seems. The truth is, moments are where life happens slowly over time. We just tend to notice the louder and more dramatic ones.

I can remember one of those moments with my daughter when I realized something had quietly slipped in our relationship.

She was about eight-years old and it happened in the middle of an ordinary interaction. Just a small correction…a simple boundary.

And yet, instead of confidence, I felt hesitation.

Not because I didn’t know what was right. I did. But something inside me wasn’t fully settled in my right to hold it. Unfortunately, I softened what should have been clear. I offered more explanation that was really necessary. I found myself hoping for agreement instead of standing in what I already knew was right.

It’s a strange feeling as a parent.

You’re the adult. You love your child. You carry real responsibility for their formation. But there’s still something inside you that is second-guessing your own authority.

Most of us don’t notice when this begins. It’s not like it posts an announcement on social media. It just slowly works its way into our responses until one day we realize we’re either overcompensating or backing down…and neither one feels quite right.

The Quiet Erosion Of Authority

Not only is the disappearance of authority gradual, but it usually fades away in a manner that actually looks quite reasonable in the moment.

Authority erodes through inconsistency when you’re worn down, through constant second-guessing driven by the fear of getting it wrong, and through a genuine desire to stay close to your child, even when that leads you to avoid uncomfortable but necessary tension.

But underneath all of that, there’s something deeper at work.

A question of identity.

Because if you are unsettled in who you are as a parent, you will experience a nagging sense of insecurity about the authority you are allowed to hold. You’ll look for cues from your child’s reaction, from social expectations, and even from your own emotional state in the moment. All of this destabilizes your authority because you’re trying to stand on a foundation that hasn’t fully taken shape inside of you.

The Two Directions We Drift

If you pay attention long enough, you’ll probably notice a pattern emerge. We don’t usually remain in one place. Instead, we move between two extremes.

Sometimes we move toward control. We use authority to demand compliance without inviting understanding. Although it often feels “strong”, it’s really just anxiety driven by the need to regain order and to keep hold of something that feels as though it’s slipping away.

Other times, we move toward collapse. That shows up more subtly. We loosen a boundary and let go of something that we meant to hold onto. We tell ourselves that it’s just not worth the hassle. But what’s really underneath that is the fear of disconnection. We’re worried that if we hold the line too firmly, we might damage the relationship.

So, we swing back and forth. Tightening, then loosening. Speaking firmly, then pulling back.

And even if our children don’t know how to explain it…they feel it.

Authority Was Never Meant To Be Force

It’s important to understand is the difference between what authority actually is—and what it isn’t. Authority is not control. It’s not about intensity. It’s not how quickly you can shut something down or how strongly you can assert your position.

Real authority is much…more…well…powerful than that.

It doesn’t rush to prove itself. It doesn’t need to win. It simply stands, grounded in something deeper and truer than the moment itself.

This is the kind of authority that doesn’t come from technique or strategy, it comes from identity. From knowing who you are…from knowing what you are responsible for…and what you are not.

Identity Comes Before Clarity

Attempting to “fix” your parenting responses without first addressing identity will leave you feeling as though you are just rearranging deck chairs on the Titanic.

You’ll still wonder if you’re being too much. Or not enough. You’ll still feel pulled to explain more than necessary or soften something that needs to be firmly held.

But when you settle into your identity, something shifts internally. You stop negotiating with your own convictions. You’re no longer driven by the need for constant reassurance that you’re doing it right. You begin to act with a kind of calm, confident steadiness.

That steadiness is what your children will feel. Not perfection. Safety.

Authority Within Relationship

Scripture presents a vision of authority that is profoundly relational.

In Ephesians 6:4, fathers are instructed not to “irritate your children and make them resentful; instead, raise them with the Lord’s kind of discipline and guidance.” There is both restraint and responsibility in that command. It assumes authority, but it also places healthy boundaries around how that authority is exercised.

Authority is meant to exist and function within relationship, and to be shaped by love, guided by truth, and anchored in something beyond our immediate emotions.

In other words, we are not inventing what is right in the moment but are aligning with what is already true, and then inviting our children to enter that reality with us.

The Internal Work Most Parents Skip

This is where the conversation probably needs to go (uncomfortably) deeper.

Although we talk about boundaries and communication, we don’t always talk about what’s happening inside the parent when these moments arise.

Because the hard truth is this…if we are internally overwhelmed, it is impossible to externally exercise calm, consistent, grounded authority.

When our bodies are flooded with frustration, anxiety, or urgency—our response will likely move in one of two directions. We will either escalate, or we will back down. Not because we lack wisdom, but because we’ve lost access to it in that particular moment.

This is where conscious parenting matters most..

The Moment That Changes Everything

There is a small but important moment that happens between what our child does and how we respond.

That moment is where everything can shift.

Unfortunately, most of us move through it much too quickly. Our reactions are based on habit, on past experience, or on whatever feels most urgent. But when we choose to slow that moment down—even slightly—we create enough space for a different outcome.

You begin to notice what’s happening inside of you. You begin to separate your child’s behavior from your own internal reaction. And in that space, you remember who God created you to be.

That pause doesn’t need to be long. It just needs to be intentional.

Connection Before Correction

When parents hear the phrase, “connection before correction” they sometimes mistakenly assume it means softening the boundary.

It doesn’t.

Connection doesn’t remove conviction—it anchors it.

It acknowledges what your child is feeling without being ruled by it. It allows you to say, “I understand why you’re frustrated,” and still hold the line. You’re not dismissing their experience, but you’re also not relinquishing your authority to it.

Both can exist at the same time.

And when they do, something important is formed.

Holding The Line Without Losing The Relationship

This is where the tension usually shows up because it feels like you’re having to make a hard choice between maintaining the boundary or preserving the connection.

But that tension goes away when your authority is no longer rooted in fear (yours or your child’s).

It’s what enables you to stay present and allow your child to feel disappointment without rushing to fix it or shut it down. And in doing so, you’re teaching them something far more important than compliance. You’re teaching them how to live within reality while remaining connected to someone who is on their side.

That’s formation.

In these moments, your child is not just learning whether or not they “get what they want.” They are learning the appropriate response to limits. They are learning how to process emotion. They are learning how to trust someone who provides both warmth and structure without falling into either extreme.

And most of that learning is not coming from what you say…it’s coming from who you are while you say it.

When Authority Is Avoided

It may seem counterintuitive, but if authority is consistently avoided, children don’t experience that as freedom. They experience it as uncertainty.

Some will push harder, not because they want control, but because they’re looking for stability. Others will disengage, sensing that the structure around them is unreliable and can’t be trusted.

Either way, something important is missing.

It bears repeating that rebuilding authority is not about becoming more forceful or getting every response right. It’s about returning to a deep confidence in who God made you.

A parent who is present.
Who stays engaged.
Who can hold both connection and conviction without losing either.

This is the kind of authority that doesn’t appear all at once (so cut yourself some slack). Instead, it forms slowly, as you begin living from a place that is less reactive and more responsive.

To Think About…

Take a few minutes with these. Give yourself time to surface what’s actually there for you.

• When I set a boundary, what do I feel internally?

• Do I tend to lean more toward control or toward backing down?

• What am I afraid might happen if I firmly hold the line?

• How do I typically respond when my child is disappointed or upset with me?

• In what ways has my own experience of authority shaped how I show up as a parent today?

One Small Step

This week, practice showing up differently. Before you respond—especially in moments that feel emotionally charged—pause.

Not to perform a technique or to “get it perfect.” Just to come back to yourself.

Take one breath. Notice what’s happening internally. And then respond from a place that reflects the parent you are becoming, not just what you’re reacting to.

That’s where authority begins to rebuild.

Quietly.
Steadily.
From the inside out.

You are not trying to become a different parent overnight (thankfully).

You are learning to stand—without hardening or collapsing—in something that God is already forming within you.

Over time, your child will feel that too. Not as pressure. But as something solid enough to trust.

And trust is the best motivator for obedience.

Get more from Daniel Hagadorn in the Substack app

Available for iOS and Android

Get the app

CARL JUNG (1875-1961) | Until you make the unconscious conscious, it will direct your life and you will call it fate.

PROVERBS 4:23 CJB | Above everything else, guard your heart; for it is the source of life’s consequences.

There are moments in parenting that feel bigger than they should. A small act of disobedience, a tone you take exception to, a look that feels dismissive—and suddenly something in you rises up faster than the moment deserves. Your voice sharpens, your body tightens, and you feel the need for immediate correction.

But if you pause long enough to look beneath the surface, you can usually tell it isn’t just about what your child did or said. It’s about what it touched in you.

I remember a moment like that more clearly than I’d like to admit. It wasn’t exactly dramatic and it was certainly nothing you’d point to as a defining parental failure. It was just an ordinary interaction that escalated faster than it should have. My daughter pushed back on something small and I corrected her. Then she pushed again and something shifted inside of me. The response that followed was neither measured nor patient and it definitely carried an intensity that didn’t quite match the situation.

After things settled down a bit, I could see the situation much better and how my reaction had outweighed the moment (that’s usually the best indicator that something deeper is involved).

At first, I did what most of us do. I tried to improve the approach—clearer boundaries, more consistency, a calmer tone, a better plan. Those things matter and they can certainly help. But they failed to reach the root, because the issue wasn’t only what my daughter was doing; it was what was happening inside me.

Strategy, as helpful as it can be, cannot heal the wounds underneath.

That’s an unsettling realization because strategy gives you something to implement and measure. But healing asks you to slow down, to pay attention, and to be honest about what is actually driving your reactions. It moves you from control to awareness…from performance to presence.

Scripture consistently brings us back to this interior starting point. God does not begin with behavior; He begins with the heart. In Ezekiel 36, the promise is not merely improved obedience but a transformed inner life: “I will give you a new heart and put a new spirit in you.” Without that inner work, change remains fragile. With it, change becomes grounded and sustainable.

This is most visible in the moments you don’t have time to prepare for—the brief space between what your child does and how you respond. Although that space is small…it is not empty. In fact, it’s filled with everything you carry…your history, your expectations, your fears, and the parts of your story that have not yet been fully told.

Unfortunately, we usually move through that space too quickly to notice it. We react, correct, and move on. But when you begin to slow down—even slightly—it’s easier to recognize what is happening within you. You feel the surge of emotion, the tightening in your body, the pull toward a familiar response. And occasionally, you become aware of it before you act.

That moment of awareness changes everything.

It is no longer just a “parenting moment”; it is a formational moment. You are not only addressing your child’s behavior…you are encountering your own patterns in real time.

Most of us were never taught how to live with that kind of awareness. Instead, we were taught to manage outcomes, to maintain control, and to move quickly toward a “resolution” (that usually just kicked the can down the road). But when you choose to stay present in that space, you start to see that your reactions are not only about the present moment. They are connected to something in your past—patterns you learned, disappointments you absorbed, experiences you never fully processed.

This is why it often feels like your child is “pushing buttons.” They are not creating those buttons; they are revealing them.

Once you begin to see that, your role will shift. You are still guiding, training, and correcting, but you are no longer assuming that every moment is as simple as it appears. You are willing to ask the more honest question lingering beneath the surface, “What is happening in me right now?”

By the way, asking that question does not weaken your authority…it establishes it. It allows you to respond rather than react, to bring a calm clarity instead of chaotic urgency into the moment.

Over time, this is where healing begins to take shape. Not in dramatic breakthroughs, but in small, repeated moments of awareness and choice. You still get it wrong. You still miss it. But your responses become less reactive and more mature. You begin to distinguish between moments that require correction and moments that are revealing something deeper in you, and you no longer treat them both the same way.

This is a kind of steadiness that cannot be manufactured because it only grows slowly from within. It is something your child feels it even if they cannot explain it. Children don’t just respond to our words, they respond to our presence. And as healing takes place, that presence is less tense, less guarded, and more anchored. You are literally becoming a place of safety and security for your children.

Admittedly, this doesn’t eliminate conflict, but it does change the environment in which conflict happens. And that imperfect environment is formative because it is consistent and real.

Of course, strategies still have a place. They help us think clearly and act intentionally. But they can only build on what is already happening inside you…they can’t replace it. The more you live from a place of healthy integration, your parenting changes in ways that are difficult to measure but easy to recognize—greater patience, clearer discernment, and a growing willingness to repair the relationship when you get it wrong.

Because you will get it wrong.

But even those moments can become part of our formative process. Our children learn that growth is expected of them because it is practiced by us in daily life. That kind of parenting carries authority because it is honest and authentic.

DALLAS WILLARD (1935-2013) | We don’t believe something by merely saying we believe it, or even when we believe that we believe it. We believe something when we act as if it were true.

Take a quiet moment this week—when nothing is urgent—and ask yourself one honest question: “What needs attention inside of me right now?” Let the answer come slowly, without forcing it.

Then, in the middle of a real interaction—when you feel that familiar internal surge—pause just long enough to notice what is happening. You don’t need to fix it immediately. Simply recognize it.

Healing often begins in that small space—the moment you would normally move past. And as you learn to stay present there, something new begins to take shape in you, and through you, in the life of your child.

Get more from Daniel Hagadorn in the Substack app

Available for iOS and Android

Get the app

DALLAS WILLARD (1935-2013) | We don’t believe something by merely saying we believe it, or even when we believe that we believe it. We believe something when we act as if it were true.

JOHN MARK COMER | Who you become is the result of what you practice.

ANNIE DILLARD | How we spend our days is, of course, how we spend our lives.

If information were enough to change a life, parenting would be almost embarrassingly simple.

You would explain the right thing, your child would understand it, and wisdom would follow. A well-phrased lecture would produce character. A few well-timed Bible verses would build resilience. One meaningful conversation about kindness, courage, or honesty would immediately take root and flourish.

But every parent knows that isn’t how formation works.

Children can recite what is right and still struggle to live it (so can we). They can explain why honesty matters and still lie when they are afraid. They can understand gratitude and still complain. They can sit through years of excellent teaching and feel inexplicably unprepared when faced with challenges.

A lot of parents are confused by this. They have provided solid teaching, thoughtful conversations, and spiritual instruction. Yet the fruit they hoped for—resilience, courage, humility, compassion—doesn’t always appear on schedule.

So the question lingers: Why doesn’t good teaching consistently produce good fruit?

The answer is both simple and deeper than we might expect. Knowing and becoming are not the same thing.

Information can illuminate a path. Formation teaches someone how to walk it. And Scripture has always understood the difference.

The Modern Assumption

Most of us were raised with some version of this equation:

Information + Understanding = Behavior

Teach clearly enough and people will live better.

This assumption shapes more than just education. It also shapes our parenting. When our child struggles, our instinct is to explain again. Clarify the principle. Reinforce the rule. Repeat the reasoning.

We simply assume more clarity will close the gap.

But information never travels alone. Emotions, habits, identity, and relationships all come along for the ride to influence how knowledge actually shapes behavior.

A child may know that anger damages relationships. But when anger surges, that knowledge can be quickly forgotten.

A teenager may understand that comparison steals joy. Yet the pressure of social media still draws them into measuring themselves against others.

A young adult may believe that fear shouldn’t drive their decisions. But when faced with uncertainty, fear still feels like a viable option.

Information is powerful. It matters. Deeply. But information alone does not form the soul.

Becoming The Environment

Parents often wonder how to build their children’s character in a complicated world. The answer is actually less complicated than it seems. (It’s just not easy).

Become the environment where growth happens.

Homes where humility, gratitude, courage, and patience are practiced consistently create an emotionally healthy ecosystem. Children raised in that environment begin to internalize those rhythms.

They learn that mistakes can be acknowledged. That forgiveness is possible. That fear does not have to make decisions. That joy can be found in ordinary moments.

These lessons seldom come through explanation alone. They emerge through years of watching how convictions play out in real life. Over time, those observations form identity.

Children who witness lived conviction carry something durable into adulthood. They don’t just hold ideas about what is good—they remember what it looks like in real life.

They have seen courage practiced. Patience stretched. Humility restore connection after conflict. And those lived memories become internal guides as life grows more complex.

Scripture & Formation

When we step back to examine the formation practices of the Bible, we notice something quite surprising. Biblical faith is not primarily transmitted through explanation. Instead, it is formed through story, imitation, rhythm, and shared living.

Families told and retold the story of God’s faithfulness. Meals became moments of remembrance. Festivals reenacted history. Sabbath interrupted the pace of life every week.

These practices did more than communicate ideas. They formed identity.

A child in ancient Israel did not simply learn that God delivered His people from slavery. They rehearsed that story every year through Passover. They tasted it in the food. Heard it in the songs. Saw it in the gratitude and reverence of adults.

Through it all, the goal was never merely the transmission of ‘correct information.’ It was the formation of a nation whose loves, habits, and imagination were shaped by the God who loved them.

When Knowledge Stays Abstract

One of the hidden risks of information-heavy parenting is fragility.

When children receive instruction without seeing those same ideas lived out, they struggle to integrate what they know into who they are becoming.

Consequently, a gap forms between belief and experience.

For instance, a child may believe God is loving but feel uncertain what love looks like during conflict. They may affirm forgiveness but rarely see it practiced. They may value honesty but feel the pressure to lie when afraid.

When real-world pressures come, that gap becomes much more visible.

This doesn’t mean the instruction was wasted. It still matters. But without lived expression, it often remains abstract—something admired, but not yet embodied.

Growth requires repetition, practice, and lived demonstration. Just as muscles develop through movement, character develops through experience.

The Power Of Imitation

Both developmental psychology and ancient wisdom point to the same reality…people learn by imitation. Children do not simply follow instructions. They mirror what they see.

A toddler doesn’t study grammar—they absorb language. A child doesn’t read about empathy—they watch it expressed.

The same pattern continues into adulthood.

When humility is observed consistently, it becomes normal. When courage is witnessed in ordinary moments, it becomes imaginable. This is why biblical learning was often based in apprenticeship.

Disciples didn’t just listen. They followed. They shared meals, traveled together, and faced challenges side by side. Learning happened right in the middle of living life.

The Weight Of Ordinary Moments

Formation rarely happens in grand speeches, rather, it happens in small, repeated moments.

When a parent admits a mistake and apologizes, humility becomes visible. When gratitude is spoken in ordinary situations, it becomes natural. When frustration rises and is handled with restraint, emotional maturity becomes possible.

These moments may feel insignificant. But over time, they tell a powerful story about how life works.

Children internalize what they experience most often and those patterns become the framework of their character.

Why Modeling Changes Everything

Explaining a virtue defines it, but living a virtue demonstrates that it’s possible.

That difference matters. A lot.

A child may listen to a thoughtful explanation about patience. But when they see patience practiced in a stressful moment, something deeper registers. They begin to understand how it looks and feels in real life.

Consistency between words and actions builds credibility. Credibility creates trust. And trust makes teaching believable.

And when explanations are aligned with lived examples, growth accelerates.

Formation Takes Time

One reason parents lean so heavily on information is that explanation feels…more… well…efficient. After all, you can clarify a principle in a few minutes or articulate a value in a single conversation. But embodied formation moves at a much slower pace.

Remember the cliche, “Repetition is the mother of skill”? Habits develop through repetition. Virtues grow through practice. Identity forms through years of observing how truth shapes real life. And that slower pace can feel very frustrating in a culture that celebrates quick results.

But growth has always been seasonal. Like a garden, it requires planting, tending, and waiting.

The Strength Of Consistency

What shapes children most is not perfection, but consistency.

They expect adults to make mistakes. In fact, honest acknowledgment of failure actually strengthens their development.

What matters is the steady presence of certain qualities over time.

When kindness regularly defines interactions, it becomes normal. When curiosity is welcomed, it grows. When gratitude is practiced, it becomes a default posture.

Consistency communicates that these are not performative…they are a way of life.

Start With One

This can feel overwhelming—until it becomes simple. And you don’t need to model everything all at once. Just start with one.

Choose a single virtue for a season: patience, gratitude, courage, humility, generosity (or whatever is on your heart).

Practice it visibly. Intentionally name it when it presents itself.

“I’m trying to be patient right now.”
“I’m choosing gratitude today.”
“I want to respond with kindness here.”

These small acknowledgments help children connect what they see with what it means.

Over time, they begin to understand how character is formed.

Not through perfection.

But through our repeated, intentional choices.

Get more from Daniel Hagadorn in the Substack app

Available for iOS and Android

Get the app

The greatest danger of fear-based parenting is not that it fails to protect children, but that it quietly teaches them the world is too dangerous to trust—and God too distant to find refuge in.

Last week we asked some hard questions to clarify the telos [purpose] of our parenting and this week we are asking an even more uncomfortable question, “What has actually been driving you?”

Because even when we fully understand the goal—wisdom, faithfulness, relational maturity before God—something else can still be influencing our decisions. And more often than we like to admit, that something is fear.

The Respectable Face Of Fear

Fear seldom presents itself honestly. It doesn’t walk into your kitchen and loudly announce, “Good morning, I’ll be raising the kids today.” It comes dressed as responsibility, calls itself vigilance, and speaks the language of ‘good parenting.’

Here’s the thing. In small doses, fear is actually quite useful. It alerts you to danger and sharpens your focus. It says, “Pay attention here.” But fear was never meant to drive your life. It was meant to signal a warning and then step aside. When it becomes chronic—humming constantly in the background—it reshapes the emotional climate of your home. Over time, it comes to define what “normal” feels like for everyone living inside those walls.

You may have clarified your telos last week. You may truly believe you’re raising a soul, not a résumé. But if fear is still the engine…then you’ll still hover. You’ll over-monitor. You’ll interpret ordinary developmental struggles as early signs of collapse. And your children won’t need you to say you’re anxious. They’ll feel it in the intensity of your presence and tone.

The Anxiety We Inherited

Scripture’s repeated command—“Do not fear”—is not a sentimental cliche. It is a reminder. Over and over again, God anchors that command not in the absence of danger but in His presence: “Do not fear, for I am with you.”

That is a radically different foundation. He does not promise a hardship-free path (wouldn’t that be nice). Instead, He promises to walk with us in our hardships.

Fear isolates you inside your imagination. Trust roots you inside relationship.

I should pause here to point out that you didn’t invent this level of parental anxiety. You inherited it.

We live in an age of constant inputs. Every scroll offers another warning—academic decline, technological distraction, social threats, economic instability, spiritual drift. It is almost impossible to be a thoughtful parent without absorbing the steady drip of alarmism.

Here’s the problem. Human beings were not designed to carry this much sustained stress. When our nervous systems are overloaded, it becomes considerably more difficult to tune into our natural instincts. The result? We end up parenting in our spare time—after work, after commuting, after tending to endless responsibilities. And that fatigue amplifies fear. It comes as no surprise then, that tired parents are more susceptible to catastrophic thinking.

When Safety Becomes Ultimate

When our thinking reaches this level of susceptibility, safety becomes our ultimate goal and fear becomes perfectly rational. For example, if your highest objective is preventing discomfort, then every potential hardship is viewed as a threat to your mission. You will respond by over-functioning…stepping in too quickly…interpreting challenges as something to eliminate rather than something to navigate.

The uncomfortable truth? We cannot raise resilient, courageous adults while eliminating every risk. We cannot teach trust in God while modeling fear and anxiety over every uncertainty. We cannot cultivate wisdom without allowing some friction.

Safety matters…but safety is not salvation.

The Emotional Climate Of A Fear-Driven Home

As I’ve noted any number of times in my posts, children are incredibly perceptive. If their grades dip and your intensity spikes, they learn that performance stabilizes you. If peer conflict arises and you immediately intervene, they learn that discomfort is unmanageable. If the news drones constantly in the background and your conversations incline toward worst-case scenarios, they learn that the world is fundamentally unstable.

Your nervous system disciples them far more effectively than your lectures do.

What makes this even more challenging is that fear often disguises itself as control. It falsely promises that if you just research enough, manage enough, anticipate enough, you can guarantee a certain outcome. Control offers a false relief while giving the insidious reassurance that tightening your grip will prevent loss.

But parenting is one long (sometimes painful) lesson in letting go.

You cannot control personality. You cannot control spiritual awakening. You cannot control every influence. You can guide. You can cultivate. You can model. But you cannot dominate outcomes without damaging relationships.

When fear refuses to accept that reality, love is reduced to a series of management techniques. And children instinctively know when they are being managed rather than truly loved.

The Subtle Theology Of Fear

There is a deeper theological layer beneath our fear. Think of it this way. If everything ultimately depends on your vigilance, then fear totally makes sense. If God is distant or unreliable, then fear totally makes sense. If suffering automatically equates to failure, then fear totally makes sense.

But if reality includes a God who loves us profoundly as we live out our story—even when we cannot see the next chapter—then fear must loosen its grip. Not vanish overnight. But loosen. A lot.

Remember that the psalmist never denied the valleys existed…he simply refused to walk them alone.

Self-Management & Reality

While I’m quite certain every parent would agree that self-management is a wise course of action, it requires considerably more than just coping strategies. It requires intentional alignment with reality.

M. SCOTT PECK (1936-2005) | Mental health is an ongoing process of dedication to reality at all costs.

And reality includes limits—our limits. It includes uncertainty as well as the fact that we are not God.

When you accept those realities rather than resist them, something shifts. Rest becomes obedience. Prayer becomes dependence. Self-care becomes stewardship (not escape).

If our cup is empty, we will demand regulation from a developing child while neglecting our own. But when our hearts are anchored—imperfectly, but sincerely—in God’s loving presence, our responses begin to soften. Not because circumstances are easier, but because our inner reality has changed.

Hyper-vigilance drains joy. It narrows imagination. It makes you impatient. You sit at a dinner table while mentally calculating future college admission prospects. You watch your child play and still feel tense about what it all means.

Fear lives in tomorrow. Love shows up today.

But the truth is that courage is contagious too. When difficulty arises and you respond from a place of joyful presence rather than frantic energy, your child learns something pretty profound. They learn that problems are not proof of disaster. When disappointment comes and you grieve honestly without despair, they learn that suffering does not displace God.

Steadiness builds security.

Advancing The Telos

You can pursue academic excellence from fear of falling behind—or from a desire to cultivate character. You can set boundaries around technology from fear—or from wisdom about attention and affection. The external action may look similar but the internal engine driving it changes everything.

I’ve had seasons where I could feel the fear running beneath my decisions. I read into things too much. I projected too far into the future. I carried a subtle tension that my daughter could feel even when I thought I was hiding it.

What I eventually learned was that she did not need a strategist nearly as much as she needed a steady, loving presence.

That shift required saying “no” to certain inputs. It required taking personal responsibility. It required admitting that some of what I called “wisdom” was really just anxiety dressed in respectable clothing.

A Practical Reset

You cannot eliminate all fear this week. But you can start to notice it. Observe what happens in your body when something stressful arises and then pause before reacting. As gently as you can, ask yourself, “What is driving me right now?”

And then you can choose, however imperfectly, to act from trust rather than fear.

Fast from one fear-fueling input this week. It may be a news source, a social media feed, or a comparison-driven conversation you regularly enter. Remove it—not to live in denial—but to create space to hear something quieter.

Notice what shifts. Notice whether your responses soften. Notice whether you become more present.

If fear is not the engine, what might trust look like?

Clarity is not control.

But clarity is peace.

And peace, settling slowly into your nervous system, becomes one of the greatest gifts you can give your child.

Get more from Daniel Hagadorn in the Substack app

Available for iOS and Android

Get the app

LAURA MARKHAM | The most important parenting skill: Manage yourself. Take care of yourself so you aren’t venting on your child. Intervene before your own feelings get out of hand. Keep your cup full. The more you care for yourself with compassion, the more love and compassion you’ll have for your child. Remember that your child will do every single thing you do, whether that’s yelling or making self-disparaging remarks about your body.

Telos [Gr. “end”; “goal”; “purpose”] is described by Aristotle (384-322 BC) as the final cause driving all things toward fulfillment—like an acorn becoming an oak or humans achieving eudaimonia [flourishing] through virtue. However, absent a transcendent anchor, it risks becoming subjectively interpreted. From God’s perspective (Romans 10:4; 1 Peter 1:9), telos is His directional purpose for creation, history, and humanity.

Basically, telos is a lot more than just the musings of an ancient Greek philosopher.

And when telos [the goal] is unclear, anxiety and fear will almost certainly fill that space.

For many of us, we never consciously chose a ‘destination’ for our parenting…we just…sort of…absorbed one.

Then, somewhere along the way, “success” began to be measured in very specific ways…academic achievement, athletic competence, social confidence, emotional intelligence, church attendance. None of these are wrong in and of themselves. But when they are elevated to supremacy, they completely redefine the telos.

And when the telos is borrowed…it makes everything feel that much more urgent.

So we hover. We compare. We panic when our child “falls behind” someone else’s timeline. We interpret normal immaturity as catastrophic parental failure because we haven’t slowed down long enough to ask: What am I actually raising this child for?

Because if achievement is the ‘goal’…then anxiety is the price.

Our Inherited Cultural Telos

Although modern parenting culture rarely names its telos explicitly…it signals it constantly.

LAURA MARKHAM | Human beings weren’t designed to handle the amount of stress our modern life loads on us, which makes it difficult to hear our natural parenting instincts. It’s almost as if we’re forced to parent in our spare time, after meeting the demands of work, commuting and household responsibilities.

Safety becomes salvation. Achievement becomes identity. Happiness becomes the highest good.

We are relentlessly told—both subtly, and not-so-subtly—that ‘good’ parenting produces well-adjusted, high-performing, opportunity-maximizing adults who avoid unnecessary pain and secure stability and success.

Again, none of these outcomes are inherently wrong. The problem here is not the presence of these goals. It is their elevation.

In other words…when safety becomes ultimate, then fear becomes rational. When achievement becomes ultimate, then comparison becomes inevitable. When happiness becomes ultimate, then suffering becomes unacceptable.

And so parents find themselves living in a constant state of low-grade panic while desperately trying to engineer an outcome that was neither promised, nor even realistic.

Telos In The Biblical Imagination

Scripture approaches these questions very differently.

From Genesis onward, humanity is first described in terms of relationship, not productivity or acclaim. We are created in the image of God, entrusted with stewardship, and invited into relationship with Him.

In Deuteronomy, parents are instructed to impress God’s words upon their children in the flow of daily life with the emphasis on His promises concerning our relationship with Him.

Proverbs frames the goal as wisdom—skill in living well before God. Wisdom is described as a cultivated orientation of the heart: honoring God and walking in integrity.

The Psalms celebrate steadfast love, faithfulness, and trust across generations. They do not glorify accomplishments on a résumé. Instead, they honor those who “walk uprightly,” who remember God’s promises, and who find refuge in Him during times of distress.

The biblical telos is not image management…it is whole-hearted, relational maturity. It seeks to be deeply rooted in God. To love what He loves. To trust the story He has written for our lives.

That is a very different destination than the one offered by our present culture.

Why Unclear Goals Create Anxious Homes

When the telos of God’s design is undefined and ignored, every decision carries disproportionate weight.

Is this school the right school? Is this sport a good fit? Is this friend group safe? Are we doing enough spiritually?

Without a clear end, the means become everything…and anything.

But having a clear telos anchors our decisions in wise discernment…and at that point, everything begins to change.

If my objective is wisdom and relational faithfulness to God, then the question shifts from “Will this look good on their their future résumé?” to “Will this cultivate a virtuous character?”

From “Will this protect them from every hardship?” to “Will this teach them to trust God when they experience hardships?”

From “Will this impress others?” to “Will this deepen love for God, self, and others?”

To be perfectly honest, clarity does not remove complexity. But it does reduce the frenzied, fear-based panic that has become the unintended normal for many parents.

Telos & The Wholehearted Life

I believe that wholeness precedes fruitfulness. In other words, we cannot raise what we are not becoming ourselves. And that means doing the same thing that we tell our kids to do…“Make good choices.”

If our own lives are ordered around achievement, then our children will absorb that—even if we loudly preach grace. But if our own hearts are anchored in God’s steadfast love, then our children will experience stability—even when circumstances change.

The recovery of telos in our families does not begin with our children’s future, but rather, our present alignment.

And the hard question? What are you living for?

Children are remarkably perceptive. They will learn more from whatever governs your emotional responses than from the Bible verses decorating the walls of your home.

If disappointment over grades produces disproportionate intensity, they will come to believe that performance equals belonging.

But if hardship produces humble prayer and honest grief, they will learn that suffering does not displace God.

Telos is caught long before it is ever taught.

Reframing Success

What if success looked like this…

An adult who knows they are deeply loved by God.

An adult who tells the truth and takes responsibility even when it costs them.

An adult who remains resilient when experiencing disappointment.

An adult who blesses others rather than pursuing selfish ambition.

An adult who remains faithful even in obscurity.

That vision of success probably won’t be trending on social media any time soon…but it echoes throughout Scripture.

The kingdom of God seldom celebrates the spectacular…but it always honors the faithful.

The Freedom Of A Clear Destination

When our telos is relational maturity, we actually gain a surprising amount of freedom.

We can say no to “opportunities” that disrupt the family rhythm without fearing permanent disadvantage.

We can allow our children to struggle academically for a season while cultivating mental and emotional resilience.

We can prioritize shared meals and Sabbath rest over constant advancement.

We can release the need to manufacture a flawless résumé or social media profile.

We can parent from peace rather than comparison.

Because our goal is not applause…it’s formation.

Telos & Trust

Ultimately, telos is a matter of trust.

Do we believe that God is more committed to our children’s ultimate good than we are?

Do we believe that faithfulness in small things matters more than outcomes based on societal values?

Do we believe that relational continuity across generations is more powerful than popular acclaim?

Scripture repeatedly testifies that God keeps His promises to a thousand generations. That promise does not eliminate human responsibility—but it does place human control in proper perspective.

Parents are called to plant, water, and weed. God will take care of the growth.

A Practical Exercise In Vision

Find a quiet moment this week and imagine your child at age thirty.

Not their job title. Not their income bracket. Not their social media following.

Who are they before God?

Are they humble? Are they courageous? Are they honest? Are they resilient in suffering? Are they generous?

Write a single sentence that captures that vision.

Keep it somewhere that you will see it. Re-read it when anxiety rises. Let it guide your yes and your no. And when you are re-reading that vision of the adult you hope your child becomes…pray this simple prayer:

“Dear Father, please reorder my daily decisions around this vision. Protect my heart from borrowed goals. Teach me to pursue union with You above all other things.”

Clarity is not control. It is peace.

And peace is a powerful place from which to parent.

Get more from Daniel Hagadorn in the Substack app

Available for iOS and Android

Get the app

CARL JUNG (1875-1961) | If there is anything that we wish to change in the child, we should first examine it and see whether it is not something that could better be changed in ourselves.

ROBERT FULGHUM | Don’t worry that children never listen to you; worry that they are always watching you.

“Just do better than your parents.”

I’ve said that sentence myself. It sounds strong. Confident. Determined.

But I’ve learned that awareness alone does not heal.

You can know exactly what hurt you as a child and still feel it rise up in your throat when your own child rolls their eyes. You can swear you’ll never be harsh, and then hear your voice get angry anyway. You can promise yourself you won’t withdraw the way your mother did, and then find yourself emotionally checking out because it feels safer.

You aren’t crazy. You’re human.

And you’re living inside a story that started before you.

The Fear Beneath The Promise

Why do we sometimes parent from a fear of repeating the past?

If we’re honest, we might even be feeling that fear right now.

A low-grade anxiety that says…What if I become what hurt me? Or worse…What if I already have?

Sometimes it shows up as overcontrol. Sometimes as over-permissiveness. Sometimes as a kind of emotional volatility you don’t recognize until after it’s too late.

We don’t want to pass down our wounds. No parent does. But I’ve also learned that ‘wanting’ is not the same thing as healing.

Why Insight Isn’t Enough

Unfortunately, we live in a culture that believes naming something fixes it. If you can identify the dysfunction, then you’ve solved it. But anyone who has been alive for more than a few decades already knows that insight is not the same as transformation.

You can intellectually understand your father’s anger and still carry anger in your own nervous system. You can recognize your mother’s fear and still live from fear yourself.

Unhealed wounds don’t magically disappear just because we see them. They go underground. And then they surface at inconvenient moments—usually when we’re tired, stressed, or scared.

Children are remarkably adaptive. They quickly learn to read whatever we haven’t faced. And whatever we don’t deal with…they will. So, they adjust themselves around our unresolved grief, our silent resentment, our unfinished business.

Not because they’re rebellious…but because they’re loyal.

The Story Scripture Actually Tells

The Bible is remarkably unsentimental about family history. It tells the unvarnished truth about patterns that echo through generations. It names brokenness honestly and without apology.

But it also tells a deeper story—that God’s mercy stretches further and deeper than our dysfunction ever could.

We were born into a love story set in a world at war. That means two things at once: brokenness travels through families, and so does grace.

God does not ask you to erase your past or pretend it never happened. Instead, He invites you to face it with Him. To bring it into the light. To agree with reality—even when reality is uncomfortable.

Dallas Willard used to say that reality is what you run into when you’re wrong. And in my own parenting, I’ve run into it more than once (okay, a lot).

But healing begins when you stop pretending you’re unaffected.

When you are willing to admit…This shaped me.

That’s not weakness. It’s alignment with truth. And mental health—real mental health —can only be experienced in union with God.

What Your Children Are Learning From You

Our children are learning from what we teach…and what we avoid. From what makes us tense. From what we overreact to. From what causes us to shut down.

If you were shamed, you may become hypersensitive to disrespect. If you were ignored, you may become too clingy. If you grew up in chaos, you may try to control everything.

And none of that makes you a bad parent.

It just makes you a parent who is carrying history.

Here’s the good news…the moment you see the pattern, it loses its invisibility. And what is no longer invisible…is no longer in control.

You are not doomed to repeat the patterns you’ve inherited. The pattern can be interrupted—not through sheer willpower—but by allowing God to heal what still aches beneath the surface.

Willpower reacts. Healing restores.

And though restoration always takes time…it actually changes the story.

One Small Step Toward Freedom

Those patterns? Remember the old cliche about “how do you eat an elephant?” One bite at a time. Don’t take everything on at once. Just focus on one thing.

Maybe it’s harsh tone. Maybe it’s emotional distance. Maybe it’s fear-based overprotection.

Whatever it is…be fearlessly honest and write it down.

Then instead of trying to fix your child’s behavior around it, take one small step toward your own healing.

That might mean an honest prayer where you stop minimizing the past. It might mean a hard but necessary conversation (or apology). It might mean sitting quietly and allowing yourself to feel grief you’ve avoided.

You don’t have to overhaul your entire family system this week.

Just move one inch toward truth.

You are not responsible for the family you were born into. You are responsible for what you do with it.

And here is the hope: God’s mercy is stronger than your history. He has been writing redemption stories for quite a while now…and He is not intimidated by yours.

You can parent from healing.

And healing, however slow, changes everything.

This was my path.

Get more from Daniel Hagadorn in the Substack app

Available for iOS and Android

Get the app

JIM HENSON (1936-1990) | The attitude you have as a parent is what your kids will learn. They don’t remember what you try to teach them. They remember who you are.

PAM LEO | Either we spend time meeting children’s emotional needs by filling their cup with love or we spend time dealing with the behaviors caused from their unmet needs. Either way we spend the time.

There is a particular ache we begin to feel as a parent, though we may not have words for it at first. It’s not as obvious as rebellion or open defiance. It’s subtler than that.

It’s the sense that we’re standing just outside the most important conversations shaping our child’s life.

You drive them around everywhere.
You pay for things.
You manage the calendar.

But somewhere along the way, you start to wonder whether you’re still the one forming their hearts.

And if we’re honest, that question can feel pretty frightening.

Why Do I Feel Sidelined In My Own Child’s Life?

We didn’t plan to feel this way (no one does). We entered parenting with the conviction that our presence mattered. That our voice mattered. That what we carried in our souls would somehow be passed on to the next generation.

But over time, the message changed.

We’re told which milestones matter…and which ones don’t. We’re given professional advice for every stage of child development (whether we asked for it or not). We’re warned about how much damage we’ll do to our children if we get it wrong.

Our authority gradually…almost imperceptibly…diminishes.

Over time, we feel less like a father or mother shaping a soul…and more like a project manager coordinating specialists.

If you’ve ever felt this way, you are definitely not alone. I have too.

Experts And institutions Know Better Than Parents

Please hear me on this…I am NOT against teachers (I have been one for 25+ years and personally know many excellent ones), coaches, doctors, or pastors. God has always used gifted people.

But somewhere during the last century, we absorbed an insidious lie about helping our children navigate their lives—professionals possess the expertise, and parents just supply the logistics.

How did it happen? There are several reasons, convenience and fear chief among them. But it also happened because modern systems are…well…impressive. They have charts and data and credentials and awards framed on the wall. They speak with confidence.

And if you are already unsure of yourself—and most parents are at some point—that confidence feels a lot safer than your doubts.

So we defer.

We outsource moral instruction to programs. We outsource identity formation to peer groups and platforms. We outsource spiritual formation to weekly events.

Without meaning to (and with the very best intentions), we come to believe that love is simply not enough…that proximity is not enough…that relationship is not enough.

But here’s the inescapable truth: no “expert” can replace the bond between parent and child because no “expert” will ever out-love a parent. Professionals can inform but they cannot replace a loving father or mother.

There is a difference.

C. S. Lewis once wrote that, “Education without values, as useful as it is, seems rather to make man a more clever devil.” He understood something that the experts have seemingly forgotten—formation is not the transfer of information but the shaping of the heart. And the heart is primarily shaped through relationship.

Not systems.

Relationship.

Biblical Reframe

In Scripture, parents are never treated as optional contributors to the development of their children.

Instead, they are entrusted with a sacred stewardship.

The ancient command in the book of Deuteronomy does not say, “Outsource these words to the nearest trained specialist.” It says you are speak “carefully to your children. You are to talk about them when you sit at home, when you are traveling on the road, when you lie down and when you get up.”

In other words, this kind of training represents the very fabric of daily life.

Formation was never meant to be a singular event. It was meant to be woven into countless ordinary moments—breakfast tables, walks in the park, bedtime stories. It assumes presence. It assumes authority rooted in love.

Consider this: God has billions of moms and dads on planet earth to choose from and He chose you to raise your children. The shaping of a soul happens best inside relationship—where correction comes with warmth, where discipline carries tears, where stories are shared, and where forgiveness is modeled, not merely explained.

You carry something no institution can replicate: your story with God.

Outsourcing Formation Always Reshapes Authority

When children learn—subtly—that meaning comes from outside the home, they will instinctively look outward for identity, interpretation, and belonging. This is not a rejection of you, it’s simply because the system has taught them that is where authority resides.

If the deepest conversations about truth, morality, sexuality, calling, and purpose always happen elsewhere, your role changes whether you want it to or not.

Again, this is not about rebellion or defiance. It is about design.

Children align themselves with whatever authority appears to hold interpretive power.

If you’re just the taxi driver and the ATM, they will still love you—but they will not look to you for formation.

And when you finally realize that loss…it can be absolutely devastating.

The Invitation

So what do you do?

You begin small.

You don’t need to make some big, dramatic declaration. You don’t need to initiate a complete overhaul of your family structure. (Which is really good news because those gestures rarely last).

Instead, reclaim one daily moment of intentional presence.

No instruction. No fixing. No “life lecture” tucked inside a casual comment.

Just shared attention.

Sit beside your child. Watch something together. Walk without an agenda. Ask a question and let the silence linger.

At first it may feel awkward. That’s alright. Deep relationships often grow through awkward beginnings.

But over time, something special happens. You reestablish proximity not as a “manager”… but as a parent. You communicate, without speeches, that your presence is more than functional—it is relational.

And from that soil, authority grows anew.

Here’s the good news: you don’t need to compete with every institution and you certainly don’t need to become an expert in everything.

You simply need to return to the ancient path. Do life with your children. Walk with them. Talk with them. Sit with them. Rise with them.

And that feeling of being sidelined”? It’s not by accident. Cultural currents are strong and systems are persuasive. But remember that the story is not finished yet.

Remember that God entrusted you with your child for a reason (and not because you are “perfect”). Love—lived out in ordinary days—remains His chosen instrument of formation.

And that is something no system can replace unless you hand it over.

So don’t.

Get more from Daniel Hagadorn in the Substack app

Available for iOS and Android

Get the app

JOHN ELDREDGE | We are born into a love story…set in a world at war.

SUE ATKINS | There is no such thing as a perfect parent. So just be a real one.

Most parents I know are tired.

Not because they don’t care—but because they care deeply while parenting inside a system that was never built to support formation. Parenting used to be shared. Rooted in community, story, and time. Somewhere along the way, it quietly became a high-stakes solo act. Outcomes matter more than the children. Metrics matter more than maturity. Comparison hums in the background of almost every decision.

If you feel the pressure, you’re not imagining it.

That’s why we need to slow the conversation down.

Not to give you better “tips, tricks, and techniques”, or another system to master. This isn’t about optimization. It’s an invitation to step back and reframe parenting itself—through a biblical and formational lens.

Scripture doesn’t start with methods. It starts with telos—a vision of who we are becoming before God. Identity comes first. From that flows posture. Then rhythm. Then responsibility. And only then, practice.

We need to start naming the quiet fears that many parents carry but seldom say out loud. Moms…dads…the goal here isn’t to add more weight to your shoulders. It’s to help you notice which weights were never yours to carry in the first place.

Why Does Parenting Feel Harder Than Ever?

I don’t think anyone really believes that parenting is easy (and anyone who is an actual parent certainly doesn’t believe that) but why does it feel so hard?

I’m going to suggest that it’s because many parents operate under a false (and self-sabotaging) assumption: If it’s hard, then I must be doing it wrong.

This assumption runs deep. Modern parenting culture treats challenges like a diagnostic tool. Basically, if something feels confusing, heavy, or exhausting, the unspoken conclusion is that a better method exists—and you just haven’t found it yet.

So struggle turns into self-doubt. And self-doubt quietly turns into shame.

But Scripture tells a different story.

Biblical Reframe

The Bible never presents parenting as “easy”, “efficient”, or “immediately rewarding”. From the obedience of daily instruction found in the book of Deuteronomy—spoken while walking, sitting, rising, and resting—to the slow cultivation of wisdom over time described in the book of Proverbs…formation is assumed to be a generational process.

Challenges aren’t treated as unexpected interruptions. They are assumed.

Biblically speaking, struggle is not evidence of failure. It’s evidence that something genuinely valuable is being formed in a fractured world. You are shaping your child’s heart in the midst of competing stories, rival loves, and constant noise. That was never going to feel light and easy.

But difficulty is not dysfunction [read that again].

Often, it’s the price of formation in a culture optimized for convenience, speed, and consumption. When parenting feels impossible, it might just be because you’re trying to do slow, sacred work inside a system that disciples through urgency and ease.

Formation takes time. It takes presence. And yes—it takes effort.

That doesn’t mean you’re failing. It likely means you’re actually doing the work.

The Invitation

This week, notice one place where you’ve interpreted pressure as personal failure.

Just one.

Write it down. Sit with it longer than feels comfortable. Then ask a gentler question: What if this pressure is normal?

Not proof that you’re behind.

Not evidence that you’ve missed something.

Just the honest cost of loving, forming, and staying present in a world that ruthlessly opposes all three.

You’re not broken.

And you’re not alone.

Get more from Daniel Hagadorn in the Substack app

Available for iOS and Android

Get the app